Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Grim]

Flay being killed by Magic is believable to me and I don't see any evidence of an SK.

Why is it believable? Magic always harps on about saving x-shots for later in the game. Do you genuinely believe that Magic would shoot N1 of all nights when there are no certainties?

 

[Laughable Chimp]

At the very least, it would be absurd for Flay to waste his role night 1 on a player who he doesn't even know has an active role, to off Barry of all people when several people had already claimed day 1. And no, he doesn't really go rogue as scum.

If those 2 are the only possibilities, Jeff is lying is the much more likely one.

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

Vote Count:

CP ~ 2[Poyser, Rugrat]
Poyser ~ 2[T'Challa, Chimp]
Juice ~ 1[Lethal]

VOTE: Jeff - the QT isn't an actual point, but you are also discounting the QT theory by the way T'Challa is playing. Why are you doubling down on the QT then? Unless you are actually involved in the QT - and T'Challa has probably ignored what you are telling them to do? Perhaps you've tried to talk them down. Yeah - you would make a logical parter for T'Challa at this point

Especially with the fact he just made a parody vote on you to try and make a point - a parody vote, that you've totally ignored.

vote poyser

no buys

Flay isn't going to visit you night 1 lol. Jeff is lying.

Vote Jeff

Vote Count:

CP ~ 2[Poyser, Rugrat]
Poyser ~ 3[Jeff,T'Challa, Chimp]
Juice ~ 1[Lethal]
Jeff ~ 2[Juice, Chimp]

 

[Comrade Khan]

I disagree tbh, barry was never going to get watched so using the block/kill delay they had on barry makes sense as its safe. Obviously it blew up in their face in this case it looks like, but if I'm scum barry is defo a safe target early on

 

[Laughable Chimp]

@Poyser Get your ass in here and argue this case for me. You're granted a stay of execution.

 

[Grim]

At the very least, it would be absurd for Flay to waste his role night 1 on a player who he doesn't even know has an active role, to off Barry of all people when several people had already claimed day 1. And no, he doesn't really go rogue as scum.

If those 2 are the only possibilities, Jeff is lying is the much more likely one.

He would if the team is trash enough. Which reminds me...

Vote: Chimp

This little exchange gives us something to work with, because you entirely forgot about Lethal proving that Jeff hid the other night.

Unless you want to say that he's a commuter, but I find it pretty difficult at this point.

 

[Rugrat]

Last time Magic was the vig in 2016(?) he shot Klee N1

 

[Grim]

Last time Magic was the vig in 2016(?) he shot Klee N1

Did Klee flip town?

 

[Laughable Chimp]

No, he wouldn't. I'm sorry but the worlds where Flay wastes his role day 1 like that is incredibly miniscule.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Can someone explain to me how Lethal helped prove Jeff's role because I seem to have missed that argument

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Did Klee flip town?

Does it matter?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Last time Magic was the vig in 2016(?) he shot Klee N1

I see. hmm. well that was 5 years ago so not sure if his feeling have changed lol.

Tyhat being said, what goes first. PGO or vig shot?

 

[Grim]

Does it matter?

It kinda does. If Klee flipped town then I don't see Magic making that mistake again and waiting until he's certain.

 

[Comrade Khan]

No, he wouldn't. I'm sorry but the worlds where Flay wastes his role day 1 like that is incredibly miniscule.

i disagree vehemently, it looks liek a delay kill he had to be alive for by my reading of his role pm? Might be an assumption, but if you have a delay kill, you use it asap, youd dont risk holding it. this is bad logic

 

[Rugrat]

Did Klee flip town?

yes