LC8: Defiant-Sensei v. -PHENOM-

[The_King]

Defiant-Sensei's Entry

-PHENOM-'s Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Sunday May 27, 2012 at 8 PM (Central Time).
Good luck!

 

[Heisenberg]

Defiant-sensei gets my vote.

 

[Andrew]

Defiant gets my vote

 

[The_King]

Defiant: Absolutely love this piece. It's pretty simple, but everything just works for me. Great lighting, coloring, picture, flow, and text.
-PHENOM-: Definitely a good piece here as well. Nice coloring and a unique approach. A bit too bright for my taste, and the render gets lost in all the effects.

My vote goes to Defiant.

 

[Lub]

I'm going with Defiant . Amazing piece, -PHENOM-'s piece is great too, but it seems to me like a little bit of ... chaos.

 

[Doink]

Phenoms piece was awesome but he came against a perfect piece from Defiant, I vote Defiant

 

[Ryan]

I haven't really been commenting on these battles so much, but I took a look at this one and felt compelled to vote.
Defiant: Awesome piece. It does look a bit choppy, but your composition is very good. This is WAY better than anything I could've done as are most, if not all, of your pieces. Your effects are spot on as is your use of color. The lighting also works well.

Phenom: You have definitely made much better. I feel you are not as well suited to the stock sigs as Defiant. You get two focal points in the lower right hand corner of the banner and the upper left hand corner where you've put those two bright brushes or C4Ds and then you see the text and then the render is kind of an after thought cause everything else is just SO bright.

VOTE: Defiant.

 

[The_King]

*Bump*. Can we get more votes in here and the other two battles?

 

[Derrick]

Both are awesome. Defiant's one is better though.

 

[The_King]

The battle is now closed.
Defiant-Sensei (7) def. -PHENOM- (0)