LC7: PHENOM (#1) vs. Doink (#6)

[Andy]

-PHENOM-'s Entry

Doink's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Monday May 22, 2012 at 8 PM (Central Time).
Good luck!

 

[The_King]

-PHENOM-: I left my comments in your battle thread with Andrew. I like, but it's a bit plain for my tastes.
Doink: I like it. Not your best but still good. I think it needs to be brighter, and it would be great.

Another close battle for me, but my vote goes to Doink.

 

[Andrew]

Doink stands out a bit more, however my issue is the font.

Voting: Doink

 

[Rated R Superstar]

My vote goes to Doink.

 

[Heisenberg]

My vote goes to -PHENOM-

 

[Andy]

My vote goes to Doink.

 

[Defiant]

Voting for PHENOM.

Unfortunately, Doink, your sig was ruined by the text but is otherwise impressive. You're showing more and more improvement.

 

[!PHENOM!]

seems i placed hard render effects and texts with damnly eye catching space effects but the less comments on my sig socked me......

 

[BDC]

Man both of these just jump out at ya! I love them.

But I'm goin with Phenom...sorry DOINK...

 

[Prodigy]

Great blending on Phenoms sig, really works and the pen tooling is off the hook. The main Lionel Messi text is good, but is let down by the best player in the world text, I know exactly what you were going for, it's either silkscreen or vistaprint (I think) but you forgot to set the text to none on the style. Good job though.

Doink, you have improved, but the text lets your piece down bro.

 

[Prodigy]

Phenom gets my vote.

 

[Derrick]

Voting Doink. Because it's just awesome, even though the text kinda sucks. But it's still awesome.

Phenom, on the other note, you are an awesome GFXer and I know you are one of the bests we have here, but this one is just one of your worse pieces. Sorry bro.

 

[Adampunk]

vOTE fOR _PHENOM_ awesome graphic

 

[!PHENOM!]

Great blending on Phenoms sig, really works and the pen tooling is off the hook. The main Lionel Messi text is good, but is let down by the best player in the world text, I know exactly what you were going for, it's either silkscreen or vistaprint (I think) but you forgot to set the text to none on the style. Good job though.

Doink, you have improved, but the text lets your piece down bro.

thanks ,mate....best player texts's layer is placed somewhere else which makes kinda effected ...but the text layer is none effected....thanks dude...i worked harder for the texts on this.....

 

[Doink]

So this new guy called Adampunk signs up, votes for Phenom twice on the gfx league as his only posts even though there are more threads open and then goes off without doing anything, and right after that Phenom comes on? Bit suspicious. Screams alt to me.