LC6: Andy (#4) v. Doink (#6) v. Lewbrication (#5)

[The_King]

Andy's Entry

Doink's Entry

Lewbrication's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Monday May 14, 2012 at 8 PM (Central Time).
Good luck!

 

[Chriss]

I don't really like Andy's piece. Too dark and blending doesn't work. 3rd place.

Lewb's is simple but nice. I don't think some'd be able to create something better for a GTA based sig. You chose the wrong character, there are not many options how to make an awesome sig about GTA. Although, great effort put in. 2nd place.

Doink's Ezio is just perfect. I left more comments in his thread. 1st place.

Vote: Doink

 

[The_King]

Andy: I like the piece. It's a bit repetitive, but I can get over it. My problem is that it's just too dark and the effects are too heavy.
Doink: Already gave my comments in your thread but awesome piece.
Lewbrication: Definitely a close second because this was a really well executed piece. Unfortunately, you just happened to go up against a pretty perfect piece. Tough luck

My vote goes to Doink.

 

[!PHENOM!]

1oink.....2:Andy.....3:Lewbrication
...Doink's entry is just awesome...nice colors and texts been used......andy's enry has 1 weak point is too dark colors,unless it will be good......lewbrication's entry comes too simple,it needs little effects to make it kinda different than the original pics for the game...

Doink gets this....

 

[Defiant]

Voting Doink

Andy - I get the theme but its too monotonous and grimy. This could be redeemed by adding some lighting and bringing out the main render more.

Doink - This one stands out because its more structured, but still kinda basic. The render effect shows you have the right idea with colouring and blending but it all doesn't really flow.

Lewb - Pursuing GTA's aesthetic was rather daring but its quite difficult to do with a horizontal canvas. To me thats the main reason this doesn't really work. The text and the render also just aren't in the right place and they're spread out everywhere. You nailed the theme but some of the basics are missing.

 

[Andrew]

Voting Doink here.

His piece is nice, Lewb with a close second.

 

[Heisenberg]

Doink gains my vote.

 

[Derrick]

Voting for Doink.

Andy: It's nice and such, but the other two are better.
Lewb: To me it looks like too much copied. I mean, I know what you aimed for with this one, and you kinda got what you wanted, but, it lacks originality. Doink was better.
Doink: Your piece is just awesome. Wrote you all I wanted in the sig thread.

 

[Rated R Superstar]

Doink gets my vote.

 

[The_King]

Doink (8) def. Andy (0) & Lewbrication (0)
Congrats to Doink on the clean sweep against two good pieces!