Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

Phenom hasn't looked good at all since the start of the game. Not out of the question for that to be an early bus.

What would be the bus? Big man on phenom?

 

[Laughable Chimp]

What would be the bus? Big man on phenom?

Yes

 

[Laughable Chimp]

For the record, I haven't liked Big Man this game either. I think it's possible both are scum.

 

[Tweet]

Kinda weird to speak of the possibility of a bus when none of them has flipped scum yet.

 

[Ace]

Poyser do you actually think I'm scum? Cos towards the end of my discussion with Magic you said you thought I had defended myself well and now you're suddenly saying you agree with Magic that I'm scummy?

What changed?

 

[Ace]

Also, re alco flipping scum

 

[Ace]

Kinda weird to speak of the possibility of a bus when none of them has flipped scum yet.

Agreed.

 

[Lethal]

My only issue lethal atm, is that as day has gone along, magic has looked more and more town to me. Since you brought him up and went back to look and the way he comes in on magic seems a bit...too confident? like he claims its not info, but most of the case is pretty meta spec that he seems certain enough to straight up vote to start day. then claims vt as a what looks like a good guy move. but he fully claims, with flavor, willy nilly. felt a bit weird on the read back again. maybe im being paranoid

 

[Lethal]

I really don’t know what to make of Jeff’s post on lethal because it was terrible and it’s 1000x worse when you consider hes loterally just been scum with lethal and knows all too well how weak he is as scum

It reminds me so much of scum Jeff seeking to paint a terrible picture on an easy target.

 

[Poyser]

Yes

But why, I don’t really understand why this is where your head is at or why you’ve got there

 

[Poyser]

Poyser do you actually think I'm scum? Cos towards the end of my discussion with Magic you said you thought I had defended myself well and now you're suddenly saying you agree with Magic that I'm scummy?

What changed?

I’m undecided honestly. I did like your defence but doesn’t change the fact magic made good points either. Plus I can’t really argue that your play around alco was weak

I will say I thought your interaction on early D1 seemed pretty genuine

 

[Poyser]

It reminds me so much of scum Jeff seeking to paint a terrible picture on an easy target.

My problem is it’s 100% what you do as town pretty much every game lol you confidently act like somebody is scum and vote them whether what you’ve got is good or not

which is decidedly not something you really do as scum and especially not at a magic, maybe a skybox

i just really struggle with believing that jeff actually thinks you’re scum

 

[Lethal]

Day 1 Final Vote Count

Tweet: (8) - Jeff, Lethal, Phenom, Poyser, Chimp, Barry, Ace, Doddsy
Haza: (2) - Magic, Big Man
Brutus: (2) - Doddsy, Alco
Smark: (3) - CP, Tchalla, Tweet

Day 2 Final Vote Count

Alco: (9) - Ace, Magic, Poyser, T'challa, Doddsy, Chimp, Jeff, Haza, Lethal
Jeff: (1) - Alco
Phenom: (1) - Big Man
Haza: (1) - Flay

Vote patterns from the first two phases. Underlines are leans, solids are reads. I've stated my stance on Magic. Flay I think Smark was onto something with the rolecop spec. T'challa is suss to me due to the overreliance on CP's read on him. I note that PHEN0M was on Tweet, but not Alco - he was on and asking who to vote as well. I have Doddsy as town because of his play - he made us fully aware of who he was with the "my role is scummy as fuck" and unless it's a huge bluff, I buy it. Watch him be scum executioner though and this be a ballsy ploy. Hard to make a lean/read on Big Man as I always want to put him scum :S

Duel votes to win

Brutus 3 - Brutus, CP, Tchalla
Chimp 11 - Chimp, Poyser, Barry, Jeff, Phenom, Big Man, Haza, Doddsy, Tweet, Ace, Lethal

 

[Lethal]

Is Ace the type of player to start a wagon on a teammate? Could've just started it to get the ball rolling and then dip away and see what happened. Chimp has favour with the duel, but with all these other killing caveats around, it's strange.

 

[Tweet]

I’m undecided honestly. I did like your defence but doesn’t change the fact magic made good points either. Plus I can’t really argue that your play around alco was weak

I will say I thought your interaction on early D1 seemed pretty genuine

Pretty much where I'm at as well tbh