Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

Also i agree with doddsy that the Jeff/Chimp dynamic would be a bit weird if both are town.

Though Chimp shooting randomly doesn't feel scummy and nor does Jeff having a public day kill as he pointed out.

Why don’t you think a public daykill could be scummy out of interest?

 

[Poyser]

It Doddsy has more killing roles then yeah I think it looks more likely that jeff isn’t town

 

[Comrade Khan]

Statement: I do not have an info role

well that does track, you said you had a "scummy" role.

If you have extra knowledge to make you think so, fair enough I guess. I know I'm town however, so I that would leave chimp on the outside looking in from my POV obviously

 

[Poyser]

Statement: Time and time again you've been proven enough of a coward to kill CP day one


Decalration: I will say outright at this point that one of Jeff or Chimp is scum

I wasn’t denying I would kill CP early, that doesn’t make me guilty as most people would kill him early. It also wasn’t really the point alco was making, he tried to make it look like I killed CP for suspecting me even tho he clearly wasn’t suspecting me

 

[Ace]

Why don’t you think a public daykill could be scummy out of interest?

I didn't say it couldn't be scummy, but forcing scum to name their target in thread seems somewhat counterintuitive for obvious reasons.

 

[Comrade Khan]

It Doddsy has more killing roles then yeah I think it looks more likely that jeff isn’t town

it would be a lot with lethal as well. Should he not also be in the pile with Tweet flipping town?

 

[Smart Marx]

It Doddsy has more killing roles then yeah I think it looks more likely that jeff isn’t town

Why not Chimp out of interest?

 

[Poyser]

I didn't say it couldn't be scummy, but forcing scum to name their target in thread seems somewhat counterintuitive for obvious reasons.

Not really, 99.9% of daykills have to bold their kill in the thread no matter their alignment. That’s kinda the point of a daykill lol

pretty sure I’ve seen scum not have to bold their daykill twice in the whole time I’ve been here, and I actually think they’ve both been barry games

 

[Smart Marx]

well that does track, you said you had a "scummy" role.

If you have extra knowledge to make you think so, fair enough I guess. I know I'm town however, so I that would leave chimp on the outside looking in from my POV obviously

Oh right, that does track.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I wasn’t denying I would kill CP early, that doesn’t make me guilty as most people would kill him early. It also wasn’t really the point alco was making, he tried to make it look like I killed CP for suspecting me even tho he clearly wasn’t suspecting me

Agree with this. CP is a viable kill every game, trying to finger Poyser for it is pretty terrible science. Imm go look at these alco posts

 

[Poyser]

it would be a lot with lethal as well. Should he not also be in the pile with Tweet flipping town?

Who, lethal?

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

I wouldn't consider my role to be an info role, but I can get info from it.

 

[RDK]

Interesting. I mean that doesn’t surprise me as it’s my role that gives that gift as I have to “mentor” you etc.

Good to hear it’s powerful, though.

I have a line that says under certain circumstances my shit my change but that's it

 

[Comrade Khan]

Who, lethal?

yes

 

[Poyser]

Why not Chimp out of interest?

The act of the duel itself but also his post aimed at big man just makes me 100% sure chimp is not scum. He COULD be indy I suppose but I don’t even think that’s likely. You’ve played with chimp as scum before right?