Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Tweet]

@Tweet I have another question. I looked back on your points about barry around the brutus wagon. While you have a point that he was the first to vote and others were suspicious, why would that make barry the scummy ones? Wouldnt it be also fair to have more suspicions on the people throwing shade and NOT the ones that voted first? if that was the case, should you not also be suspicious of big man, and poyser?

It's just the sum of his votes so far, he's been voting with the concensus all day and as far as I can tell he never gave much or any reasoning behind it, just strikes me as potentially sheeping scum.

And FWIW I am wary of something like a Poyser/Big Man/maybe Jeff/maybe CP team just strongarming its way through the game but it's too early for that kind of conspiracy theory.

 

[Tweet]

That being said his reasoning behind voting Brutus doesn't look made up, I don't think he can make up that sort of reasoning on short notice so ima put Barry on the back burner for now.

 

[Tweet]

vote CP

 

[Tweet]

But the whole “I’ve got meta reasons for reading him scum but I’m not gonna elaborate in case he adapts” is no buys lmao

also if you’re actually town then that’s some pussy ass shit

How is there even the slightest possibility in your head right now that I might be town after all the stuff you allegedly nailed me on?

@Poyser can you answer this please?

 

[CraigPelton]

Not a fan of this reasoning behind dropping your suspicion of me, I'd like to think that your initial suspicions should have been more founded to the point where they're not something that could just be swept away by a certain character claim.

seems like a high expectation for me d1 lmao I usually just pushever looks sus at a given moment (jeff, you earlier) or is being pushed by someone I think is town (brutus, cause Poyser) unless I have a strong reason to suspect a particular player i.e smark

 

[Poyser]

Poyser did you ever answer why there's the slightest doubt in your mind about me being scum? According to yourself, you've nailed me on logical inconsistencies left right and center so why do you even venture that I might still be town?

Lol are you seriously going with this

I wasn’t venturing that you might be town lmao. I was letting you know it was shit and it would be pussy shit even if you were town

 

[Poyser]

He's using literally the same word as me, "tryhard", why is it that I have to elaborate and he doesn't?

Because you related it haza’s meta and he didn’t

 

[Big Man]

No, his hints mostly came after I voted.

then you can't really be using that as a reason to say you're not aligned lol

 

[Big Man]

Tweet's read list seems genuine. I think his posts since coming back have been a lot better in general tbh, they more align with how I'd expect him to react to himself being wagoned as town

 

[Poyser]

1. Haza - No idea, gun to head I'd say scum but it's more of a 55/45 deal atm
2. Alco - Just a hunch, he's kinda sus of me but feels the least slimy about it
3. T'Challa
4. Poyser - Can't tell whether he actually thinks he's on to something regarding me or just opportunistic, I sure have made it easy to be sus of me so far.
5. Ace
6. Tweet
7. Big Man - Seems to be making good points but it's been a while since I've seen scum Big Man and something feels wrong, can't quite put my finger on it.
8. Barry
9. Smark - Same as Haza
10. Brutus
11. Blaine
12. CP - Slimebag
13. Magic
14. Kajuh
15. Jeff - Still think it's weird that relatively few people seem to question whether it's actually a good idea to let his role reach full power, but I currently think that makes it more likely that he's town and some of those votes are scum who don't wanna stick out.
16. Doddsy
17. Lethal
18. TKOK
19. Phenom
20. Chimp
21. Flay

I'm obviously biased since I know I'm town so I can't entirely overlook the people sussing me, but at the same time I realize that I've made it very very easy for scum to go in on me this game and that's something I'm sorry for.

This is pretty awful lol
The jeff read doesn’t make any sense as a town read. Surely you should be reading him based on his own play rather than people playing around him in the most convoluted connection of all time

why is ace scum? Why is Phenom scum? I know you said you hated his voting patterns or w/e but I don’t think you’ve ever elaborated. Not even sure you’ve mentioned ace so dunno where that comes from and you’ve not even felt the need to elaborate on it for whatever reason

is Brutus town just for not thinking you’re scum?

 

[CraigPelton]

come on guys you really think town smark is this disinterested in my suspicion and wagoning of him lol

 

[Poyser]

on the point of speed of wagon, you and I are in agreement at least.

Why?

its 5 votes in a 21 player game lol. Even if Brutus is town they could very easily all be town votes

this speed of wagon stuff is nonsense lol

 

[Poyser]

@Poyser can you answer this please?

This is legit fucking awful man

 

[Smart Marx]

then you can't really be using that as a reason to say you're not aligned lol

I think you misunderstood. I said us being aligned is what makes sense. Him being town and me being scum is what doesn’t make sense to me if Tweet’s case if the main being presented. If it’s not, then fair enough.

 

[NotBrutus]

Why?

its 5 votes in a 21 player game lol. Even if Brutus is town they could very easily all be town votes

this speed of wagon stuff is nonsense lol

Haven’t even gave a reason what about my posts pinged you