Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

If you are choosing to ignore possible scum motivation behind wanting votes then sure...

I dont think its unreasonable for me to be apprehensive of that though especially when any such role would be unconventional already, why would it automatically be a town role?

I think Big Man was getting at the reasoning for that being why would scum want votes on them? This doesn't really compute with me because why would town?

I'm just not really getting what either of you are saying maybe

I guess the question is why would voting somebody that seems to active want votes be a bad thing? Like the only way I can even imagine it being bad is if he's exactly a jester and even thats not exactly the end of the world lol

Like can you even think of any reason why it would be bad for town to vote a scum in any scenario? Whether they apparently wanted votes or not lol? I just don't think you really thought it through at all, ergo why I think it's just virtue signalling on your part

 

[Doddsy]

*unplugs Doddsy*

Statement:

doddsy prob town too cause he would hide behind the pr like a coward.

that's 3 people out of 21.

i am only going to read from where i left off, i dont give a shit about phase the game is on. i'll solve it all via day 1 and deaths cause you guys probably aren't going to stfu.

Declaration: This is overtly incorrect as I always do risky shit as scum.

Conclusion: Magic good guying me for sure

I just read the first 2 pages and couldn't bother with the rest of it. But I think Poyser is scum.

Vote Poyser

Statement: I have missed this particular meatbag

Chimp I've caught Tweet, thoughts?

Declaration: This is as premature as your ejaculations

 

[Comrade Khan]

good morning

 

[RDK]

I guess the question is why would voting somebody that seems to active want votes be a bad thing? Like the only way I can even imagine it being bad is if he's exactly a jester and even thats not exactly the end of the world lol

Like can you even think of any reason why it would be bad for town to vote a scum in any scenario? Whether they apparently wanted votes or not lol? I just don't think you really thought it through at all, ergo why I think it's just virtue signalling on your part

I mean in this instance for the exact same reason it might be good to vote a town in this instance it may not be. Like I've never heard of a town role that could power up but why couldn't that role be scum too? And in that instance realistically you'd want to know for sure that was the lynch before piling votes on, otherwise you risk powering up scum with no gain for town.

I'm also wondering what you think MY motivation would be here as scum?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ill start with the tweet sitch.

The claim obviously does nothing for me, unsurprisingly. My main issue with tweet, as I think someone else pointed out, is the comparison to the way he refused to claim.

When he was the vig, for example, sure he refused to claim. but he also dissected his wagon, burried everyone on it, and i believe even caught scum out of it (lethal).

Here he's tried about 5 different tactics, including what Id describe as the Eeyore defence, which he has often used as scum . That's the one where he's more defeatist (like saying his role wont save him in a im sad way i guess). Idk if that makes sense but thats the vibe i got off the defence posts.

Also we can't really just wait like 4 phases for a potential scum suspect to prove a role thats not even auto-town, so yea, at this juncture id be in favour of lynching

 

[Comrade Khan]

I also agree with @Poyser that Lethal's posts didn't make me want to rip my eyes out and flush them down the toilet, and thats a GOOD thing thusfar.

 

[NotBrutus]

good morning

Death Meta Morning

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

Ok, just read throughish. Still sorta confused at what I read. Probably need to go back through the first 17

 

[Comrade Khan]

what is confusing you blaine?

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

what is confusing you blaine?

not sure. I don't comprehend stuff as fast as others. Given I gave some posts a read through and I skimmed through some, probably missed something. Wasn't it Tweet who claimed even tracker or was it Poyser?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also I've read through Haza's posts. Im not really seeing a problem currently? I also had done a small haza intro comparisson yesterday afternoon, and his intro looked a LOT more like 2 games ago ( town) than last game (scum). Obviously its early, but I think i usually have a pretty damn good handle on reading the tone of hazas posts, and thusfar, seem fine to me

 

[RDK]

not sure. I don't comprehend stuff as fast as others. Given I gave some posts a read through and I skimmed through some, probably missed something. Wasn't it Tweet who claimed even tracker or was it Poyser?

This obliviousness is kinda sketch. Like you are aware enough about the claim to know it has a modifier but not who made it?

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

This obliviousness is kinda sketch. Like you are aware enough about the claim to know it has a modifier but not who made it?

I forget simple stuff alot. Names happens to be one of them.

 

[Comrade Khan]

tweet claimed even night tracker.

i dont believe poyser has had any sort of wagon...well unless you consider chimp as a wagon :/

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

tweet claimed even night tracker.

i dont believe poyser has had any sort of wagon...well unless you consider chimp as a wagon :/

Probably just recency bias from another forums mafia, but would you think there would be an odd night tracker?