Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

I'm not one for hammering without discussion.

I'm sure older players remember when I once rush-hammered a phase to lose the game for town. So yeah. I refuse to make that mistake again.

You know it's not lylo, though, right? So really your hammer or not hammer should just be about do you think it's not Blaine?

I know you said it's the wrong direction, but you also said you've lost grip on your town read of him.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd actually like for Doddsy to prove his usage.

This is a fair point. I retract my previous post. @Doddsy execute this man, please.

 

[Chloe B]

Blaine has done nothing to earn his place here if town so I'm not that against it. But I prefer Barry who hasn't proven jack shit with being a vig

 

[Chloe B]

i also dont see the relevance of alco's usage when theres no way we will be able to prove it regardless, so its all wifom. if you have a point to make, make it sir

No it's not WIFOM, it's a simple question, do you think he was lying, yes or no?

 

[Comrade Khan]

No it's not WIFOM, it's a simple question, do you think he was lying, yes or no?

I think he could be, sure. hes scum

 

[Chloe B]

I think he could be, sure. hes scum

At that point in the day do you think lying about usage would be the right move from a scum POV?

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

: )

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Why does it matter? Alco flipped scum so him lying about usage is moot.

 

[Big Man]

sorry for the limited activity, been busy and only able to post around this time. haven't read since I last posted but seen the stuff on Doddsy on this page and can't really see him being scum. he hinted at executioner as soon as he entered the thread, it's a very strong role and it makes no sense to give that up just for your claim. I do think we should have him use it though to make sure he actually is a executioner and that is what he was hinting at with the scummy role comment.

I still think on play PHEN0M/Smark are most likely scum tbh but obviously being seen visiting Jeff looks good. it doesn't clear him though because we don't know what role he used. I know I said tweet/blaine yesterday but what magic said about tweet seemingly trying to talk people out of lynches was a good point and looks good for him so I wouldn't really be interested in him. I'd probably lynch Smark or Barry before him tbh but Blaine first.

also @Jeff Valley Driver how did you gain the proximity mine role? we only know you got the daykill by recieving x number of votes.

 

[Comrade Khan]

At that point in the day do you think lying about usage would be the right move from a scum POV?

I would honestly need to go look back at the temperature of alcos claim (like when he came in etc).

The MAIN reason I think he COULD be lying, is, as others brought up his flip. we know scum had a bus drive, and we know everyone wanted to shoot tweet on n1 yea?

 

[Big Man]

At that point in the day do you think lying about usage would be the right move from a scum POV?

the logical use would be to busdrive tweet who was going to be vigged and drive him with someone they wanted dead, if they did that then obviously he's going to lie about that. I think he busdrove him with me but it failed because I commuted so he would have half told the truth in that case.

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Big Man I answered this already when doddsy( iirc) asked me early in the game. I had more than one role unlock from votes remember? its tiered

 

[Chloe B]

Why does it matter? Alco flipped scum so him lying about usage is moot.

No it's not when scum would have to consider investigative roles catching them out

 

[Comrade Khan]

the logical use would be to busdrive tweet who was going to be vigged and drive him with someone they wanted dead, if they did that then obviously he's going to lie about that. I think he busdrove him with me but it failed because I commuted so he would have half told the truth in that case.

this makes the most logical sense, yes. thats what i was getting at regarding tweet.

 

[Chloe B]

Seems like I can't say nothing to change y'all minds.

Well, get on with it mothefu...unvote vote Blaine