Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Big Man]

Tbh,I doubt poyser would decide to kill cp just off what was quoted earlier.

it's WIFOM and a conclusion shouldn't be made one way or the other based on the kill.

 

[Smart Marx]

Me personally would rather kill Haza then give him supposedly powerful roles that could be used against me if I was scum, but fair argument I guess.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Me personally would rather kill Haza then give him supposedly powerful roles that could be used against me if I was scum, but fair argument I guess.

well the devils advocate argument would be ud power him up in hopes of leading him astray with the roles, plus you could relay all info back to you QT giving scum that advantage, but haza the balance of the power. I can see what Big Man is saying here spec wise, it makes sense to me .

 

[Smart Marx]

well the devils advocate argument would be ud power him up in hopes of leading him astray with the roles, plus you could relay all info back to you QT giving scum that advantage, but haza the balance of the power. I can see what Big Man is saying here spec wise, it makes sense to me .

I stopped talking to him in there as it didn’t seem like we were vibing well together, but fair again.

I honestly don’t even know what he gets so a big gamble either way and I hope he makes us proud.

Us as in town.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I stopped talking to him in there as it didn’t seem like we were vibing well together, but fair again.

I honestly don’t even know what he gets so a big gamble either way and I hope he makes us proud.

Us as in town.

interesting, if you said this earlier i may have missed it. kk

 

[Smart Marx]

interesting, if you said this earlier i may have missed it. kk

I did. I believe Poyser asked me.

 

[Comrade Khan]

probably skimmed through that this am.

 

[Big Man]

Im gonna do some reading later but my gut for now says

vote alco

Tbh. Him trying to blame the CP kill on me was super slimy but it's not just that, he brought it up and waited to see if anybody else would bite rather than voting me himself even though he clearly for some reason went digging for the post so must have thought it was pretty damning considering its the only CP post he quoted.

I mean he could have just brought it up because he was genuinely weary tbh. I think bringing up the he was waiting thing is a bit disengineous because I highly doubt he would try to push you based on someone's death, nor does he believe people would want to push you based on that. I guess it would make people trust you less which could be his motive as scum but I think it's kind of a dumb play and alco isn't dumb. I think he would be aware it looks slimy too if he made the post as scum and had a motive.

 

[Smart Marx]

All my role says is it’s called mentor and he receives a power role for every day that we’re both alive.

 

[Comrade Khan]

All my role says is it’s called mentor and he receives a power role for every day that we’re both alive.

yeah that at least makes sense with the character (mentor)

 

[Comrade Khan]

ofc the other character spec would obviously make u(smark) look bad but you already knew that

 

[Smart Marx]

ofc the other character spec would obviously make u(smark) look bad but you already knew that

I did and with Doddsy pointing that out earlier is why I said to him in our qt it didn’t look good for us.

I also didn’t know he didn’t know about my mentor role.

 

[Smart Marx]

I said to him my pm makes me believe I can trust you.

 

[Poyser]

I mean he could have just brought it up because he was genuinely weary tbh. I think bringing up the he was waiting thing is a bit disengineous because I highly doubt he would try to push you based on someone's death, nor does he believe people would want to push you based on that. I guess it would make people trust you less which could be his motive as scum but I think it's kind of a dumb play and alco isn't dumb. I think he would be aware it looks slimy too if he made the post as scum and had a motive.

Im not really sure I'd go with this tbh. I agree there could be town motivation to it too, I just feel like a townie is probably more likely to press it further or at least vote. I dont think alco would go through the thought process of being aware its slimy though

 

[Alco]

I distinctly remember people sussing me some 2 years ago for being too self-aware (i was mislynched off it multiple times). So that last phrase doesn't hold true