KingMaker I Game Thread

[Worst Player Ever]

I get the feeling half the field have forgotten they signed up for this game by now and flat out won't show up lmao

Just 4 left to check in woohoo... ace alco buffy juice

 

[Smart Marx]

Stonesgate in MCU

That was because the direction was fairly clear.

99.99% of the rest of the time I'm open. If you're going to lynch me when that makes no sense, shit is different.

 

[Tweet]

I mean ultimately the main thing about whoever gets made king is that they shouldn't be someone who easily makes selfish decisions, ideally regardless on who is made king we'll be talking about who should get lynched and the king is just the one who brings the hammer down on who most people wanna see lynched. So the king should be someone who listens to reason and doesn't go rogue.

Wouldn't recommend any of the new guys for the job cause of "oh look I got a new toy" shenanigans tbh.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I mean ultimately the main thing about whoever gets made king is that they shouldn't be someone who easily makes selfish decisions, ideally regardless on who is made king we'll be talking about who should get lynched and the king is just the one who brings the hammer down on who most people wanna see lynched. So the king should be someone who listens to reason and doesn't go rogue.

Wouldn't recommend any of the new guys for the job cause of "oh look I got a new toy" shenanigans tbh.

Who would you currently trust atm

 

[Smart Marx]

Since not many nominations have been listed, I'll go ahead and vouch for myself.

I will say most of the time when a game gets to endgame, I try my best to slow it down and talk it out.

So unless I had a super hunch, and most of the time I don't, I would go rogue.

I second Jeff, though. Tweet is sounding pretty rational, too.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Would not oppose Rugrat as king, actually. The reads list where he didn't straight up dismiss any of the players he knows well shows an interest in helping town come to a decision.

Rest of my "OK with them being king list" is kind of the obvious combo of Smark/Jeff/Tweet

 

[Tweet]

Who would you currently trust atm

Smark, Big Man, Alco would be on top of my list, a slight tier below that would be you, Rugrat, Ace, Sky and Barry. These aren't town reads or anything, just people who I know and who I trust to fulfill those criteria I mentioned. Rugrat can be a troll sometimes, Ace can just not appear at all, Sky and Barry have potential to be trigger happy and you sometimes get enraged and lose your composure.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Fuck me, Smark has 41 posts. He really is playing to his town meta.

 

[Tweet]

And yeah I'd put myself into that first group of people who would never go rogue.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Smark, Big Man, Alco would be on top of my list, a slight tier below that would be you, Rugrat, Ace, Sky and Barry. These aren't town reads or anything, just people who I know and who I trust to fulfill those criteria I mentioned. Rugrat can be a troll sometimes, Ace can just not appear at all, Sky and Barry have potential to be trigger happy and you sometimes get enraged and lose your composure.

reasonable. don't think I've ever gone full rogue as town (usage wise) but I can at least understand where that sentiment would come from, so fair enough.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Would not oppose Rugrat as king, actually. The reads list where he didn't straight up dismiss any of the players he knows well shows an interest in helping town come to a decision.

Rest of my "OK with them being king list" is kind of the obvious combo of Smark/Jeff/Tweet

I would, I personally didn't rate his list very high at all. It felt thrown together hastily tbh

edit: not saying I necessarily disagree with his choices, my issue was more in the way he laid it out. also big man is active, or maybe he's not, idk shtick. I generally don't buy that shit, similar to how I don't really buy Sky's "i forgot smark was active as town".

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I would, I personally didn't rate his list very high at all. It felt thrown together hastily tbh

I don't know about that, doesn't feel as low effort as you say

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don't know about that, doesn't feel as low effort as you say

agree to disagree, then. it was rather simplistic imo, and looked like forced effort from a guy who generally gives 0 fucks about day 1.

 

[Tweet]

I rate Rugrats list slightly town, activity and composure and being agreeable are good criteria by which to choose the first king and the list makes sense in that regard, but putting that together is something anyone can do as any alignment. While I don't think that list tells any lies about the players involved in order to nudge the kingmaker into making scum king, I also don't think there's a huge amount of value in scum being made king d1.

 

[Worst Player Ever]

so much for the supposed demise of mafia here according to discord ppl... RIP email notifications, turned them off