KingMaker I Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Noted.

she/he sounds outwardly scummy, however i feel like she/he would avoid saying some of the stuff she/he is saying as scum. almost openly invitingthe wrong kind of attention. Look at me!
its terrible logic from me there. HAhaha... i wasnt joking about my Wooden Spoon caliber play but oh well All Hail The King (for today!)

a Kingmaker claim from someone out there to narrow down POE would help at this point if its one of the top suspects just fyi

if possible, I'd like to hear other people's #1 suspect not named Rugrat + Jeff OR Sky (claimed PR), as those two seem to be near consensus Top 2 names popping up. been hearing most often (in a nutshell, other than general play) -> Rugrat for his/her push on Barry (?), etc., and Jeff for his play as King.

as a footnote, too bad about the inactives ... if they win as scum then whatever, it happens

tl;dr <Jeff, Rugrat, ???> so i can make a top 3 for ppl to focus on and get this show on the road?

If we believe sky :

Barry, buffy or juice (i guess?)
If we dont believe sky :
Sky, rugrat, who cares

I've liked sky 's reaction to the suss, so i don't think we should lynch her. Ontop of that if shes truthful mp would die, and im getting town vibes the way hes playing as king.

Barry also coming on strong consistently and coming at smark is a good thing. I think my read there was misguided, a d i liked that he didnt back off.

Buffy has been playing the im goin to catch up card a lot, and hasnt done anything of note. Thats a safe lynch imo.

Juice is a no show so low-risk move as well

 

[Smart Marx]

i implied i was reading u as lean town with my bad reasoning. Just curious whos your #3 suspect? if not Jeff or Rug

and like Char said to me earlier, town/scum metas are able to be manipulated.

im just trying to POE for my own sake not necessarily for King shot ... iim most likely to shoot within the top suspects, but would prefer a #3 option even if its just to see where people are leaning fwiw. i feel like at this point one of them HAS to be resolved because both are that heavily suspected. at the same time, tomorrow could turn into 3 vs 5 if 3 scum left and missed shot today. if its a miss today, just gotta hope for clutch consecutive scum lynches with town kings.

tl;dr prefer a 3 player pool if possible

Barry always thinks that and he’s wrong. At least most of the time. Some people have loose metas that aren’t as strict so use them guidelines, but other people have strong tells they can’t or don’t shake. Just like I knew Barry was town before he was killed the first time and I know Barry is town now. In fact, one of his tells face away exactly what I wanted to know about Barry.

Your reasoning is actually spot on about me. I would never openly make shady moves as scum and in fact I’d have buddies Sky when others were shading and especially came to her defense as the Kingmaker.

I’m strongly leaning Jeff or Rugrat. My other suspension is either you or Big Man since I’ve ruled out Sky and Barry now and wouldn’t go either direction.

I also don’t think Big Man is the play today.

My only other suggestion is see what Buddy flips.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Barry always thinks that and he’s wrong. At least most of the time. Some people have loose metas that aren’t as strict so use them guidelines, but other people have strong tells they can’t or don’t shake. Just like I knew Barry was town before he was killed the first time and I know Barry is town now. In fact, one of his tells face away exactly what I wanted to know about Barry.

Your reasoning is actually spot on about me. I would never openly make shady moves as scum and in fact I’d have buddies Sky when others were shading and especially came to her defense as the Kingmaker.

I’m strongly leaning Jeff or Rugrat. My other suspension is either you or Big Man since I’ve ruled out Sky and Barry now and wouldn’t go either direction.

I also don’t think Big Man is the play today.

My only other suggestion is see what Buddy flips.

I mean, if you're scum and you know someone is town, it's pretty easy to just say, "they're playing to their town meta guys" as an excuse to not pursue them.

 

[Smart Marx]

Wait, who else is playing this game?

Town
Sky
Barry
Myself

Scum
Jeff
Rugrat

Scum leans
MP
Big Man (mostly think he’s not tho)

Who’s left?

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean, if you're scum and you know someone is town, it's pretty easy to just say, "they're playing to their town meta guys" as an excuse to not pursue them.

It is, but then you look and see that person is playing their own town meta and you can rule that out entirely.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'd like to hear why you think I'm scum Smark, outside of this loose parrot of " I don't like how you played as king because you lynched someone I said was town" bullshit

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean, if you're scum and you know someone is town, it's pretty easy to just say, "they're playing to their town meta guys" as an excuse to not pursue them.

Trust me when I said I’ve read you well.

Hence I’m not entertaining going for you again.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd like to hear why you think I'm scum Smark, outside of this loose parrot of " I don't like how you played as king because you lynched someone I said was town" bullshit

Lynching obvious town is bad enough in my book.

 

[Worst Player Ever]

Who’s left?

Buffy and Juice

 

[Comrade Khan]

Lynching obvious town is bad enough in my book.

But he was only obvious town to you dipshit

 

[Smart Marx]

Because as far as I know, before you


But he was only obvious town to you dipshit

All you have to do is play any game with Barry in the last year and it’s obvious, dill hole.

 

[Smart Marx]

Even if you dumbasses can’t read Barry being obvious town Barry, maybe listen to the guy who reads him like a book. Just a thought.

 

[Buffy]

I'm trying! who should i "execute" today?

Obviously not me since that would be a waste of a execution.

 

[Smart Marx]

Buffy and Juice

Either of these could be worth just getting info, but I’d lean on Buffy since he’s here and not given us much.

 

[Worst Player Ever]

Buffy and Juice

And Alco. My bad.