If X were a Title: tracking the lineage of some strange stipulations

[Mitch Buchannon]

When did each of these happen? Gonna do another one in the meantime

Molly - WM XX
Bischoff - Taboo Tuesday 2004
Vince - WM 23


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I found 1 other instance where a Slammy Award was won through a match:
Who is the rightful "Diva of the Year" Slammy Award winner for 2010?

Spoiler: Who holds Diva of the Year?

2010-12-13 Michelle McCool - wins a battle royal on WWE Raw, claiming the award
2011-01-11 Beth Phoenix - beats McCool on WWE SmackDown
2011-03-20 Layla - beats Phoenix at a WWE live event
2011-04-12 Kelly Kelly - beats Layla on WWE SmackDown
2011-05-22 Brie Bella - beats Kelly at WWE Over the Limit
2011-06-17 Beth Phoenix (2) - beats Brie at a WWE live event
2011-08-05 Kelly Kelly (2) - beats Phoenix at a WWE live event
2011-08-29 Brie Bella (2) - beats Kelly on WWE Raw
2011-09-09 Kelly Kelly (3) - beats Brie at a WWE live event
2011-10-02 Beth Phoenix (3) - beats Kelly at WWE Hell in a Cell
2011-12-01 Kelly Kelly (4) - beats Phoenix at a WWE live event
2011-12-18 Beth Phoenix (4) - beats Kelly at WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders, and Chairs
2011-12-19 Alicia Fox - beats Phoenix on WWE Raw
2012-02-07 Beth Phoenix (5) - beats Fox on WWE SmackDown
2012-04-03 Nikki Bella - beats Phoenix on WWE SmackDown
2012-04-29 Layla (2) - beats Nikki at WWE Extreme Rules
2012-09-16 Eve Torres - beats Layla at WWE Night of Champions
2012-09-25 Layla (3) - beats Eve on WWE Superstars
2012-09-28 Eve Torres (2) - beats Layla at a WWE live event
2012-12-09 Layla (4) - beats Eve at WWE Tribute to the Troops (dark)
2012-12-30 Tamina Snuka - beats Layla on WWE SmackDown
2013-01-11 Kaitlyn - beats Tamina at a WWE live event
2013-03-05 Tamina Snuka (2) - beats Kaitlyn on WWE SmackDown
2013-03-08 Kaitlyn (2) - beats Tamina at a WWE live event
2013-04-15 Nikki Bella (2) - beats Kaitlyn on WWE Raw
2013-10-22 AJ Lee - beats Nikki on WWE SmackDown
2013-11-06 Brie Bella (3) - beats AJ at a WWE live event
2014-04-06 AJ Lee (2) - beats Brie and 12 others at WWE WrestleMania XXX
2014-04-07 Paige - beats AJ on WWE Raw
2014-05-19 Alicia Fox (2) - beats Paige on WWE Raw
2014-05-26 Emma - beats Fox on WWE Raw
2014-08-04 Cameron - beats Emma on WWE Superstars
2014-09-15 Naomi - beats Cameron on WWE Raw
2014-09-23 Paige (2) - beats Naomi on WWE Main Event
2014-09-26 Natalya - beats Paige at a WWE live event
2014-10-28 Paige (3) - beats Natalya on WWE Main Event
2014-11-02 Alicia Fox (3) - beats Paige at a WWE live event
2014-11-10 Paige (4) - beats Fox on WWE Raw
2014-11-12 AJ Lee (3) - beats Paige and Nikki in a Triple Threat match at a WWE live event
[in the same match, AJ won the services of Brie...]
2020-05-12 Bayley (9) - beats Charlotte on WWE SmackDown

Bayley Dos Straps, the Baddest Woman on the Planet, master of Brie Bella... is also the Diva of the Year for 2010!

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Bayley so great she is Diva of the Year from a year she wasn't even there.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

It's occurred to me that if I do this, I definitely have to do every "X vs. Hair" match in the future, and every "X vs. Mask" match at that. I'm really setting myself up here. Thanks @Moscow Mitch for nothing, as we investigate:
Who owns Vince McMahon's hair?

Spoiler: Who owns Vince's hair?

2007-04-01 Bobby Lashley - beats Umaga in a Donald Trump's Hair vs. Vince McMahon's Hair match at WWE WrestleMania 23
[2007-05-26 Lashley gets the Viagra, immunity, etc.]
2020-06-07 Randy Orton (4) - beats Edge at WWE Backlash

21. Meanwhile:
Who owns Eric Bischoff's hair?

Spoiler: Who owns Bisch's hair?

2004-10-19 Eugene - beats Bischoff in a Hair vs. Hair match at WWE Taboo Tuesday
2004-11-01 Gene Snitsky - beats Eugene in a Hardcore match on WWE Raw
2005-01-09 Kane - beats Snitsky at WWE New Year's Revolution
2005-03-21 Batista - beats Kane in a Lumberjack match on WWE Raw
[Batista is the current holder of all the stuff, btw]
2020-06-07 Randy Orton (5) - beats Edge at WWE Backlash

22. I'll do the Molly Holly one in a separate post, hopefully.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

ORTON IS A GOD!

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Okay.
Who owns Molly Holly's hair?

Spoiler: Who holds Molly's hair?

2004-03-14 Victoria - beats Molly Holly in a Title vs. Hair match at WWE WrestleMania XX
2004-05-03 Gail Kim - beats Victoria on WWE Raw
2004-05-15 Victoria (2) - beats Kim, Jazz, and Molly Holly in a Fatal Four-Way match at a WWE live event
2004-06-13 Trish Stratus - beats Victoria, Kim, and Lita in a Fatal Four-Way match at WWE Bad Blood
2004-12-06 Lita - beats Trish on WWE Raw
2005-01-09 Trish Stratus (2) - beats Lita at WWE New Year's Revolution
2006-04-02 Mickie James - beats Trish at WWE WrestleMania 22
2006-08-14 Lita - beats Mickie on WWE Raw
2006-09-17 Trish Stratus (3) - beats Lita at WWE Unforgiven
2011-03-14 Vickie Guerrero - beats Stratus in a No Disqualification match on WWE Raw
2011-09-12 Kelly Kelly - beats Guerrero on WWE Raw
[Kelly was at the time, the reigning Diva of the Year 2010, so...]
2020-05-12 Bayley (9) - beats Charlotte on WWE SmackDown

Bayley's fast becoming the women's Randy Orton.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

While we're on hair:
Who owns Sami Callihan's hair?

Spoiler: Who holds Sami's hair?

2018-07-22 Pentagon Jr. - beats Sami Callihan in a Mask vs. Hair match at Impact Slammiversary XVI
2018-08-12 Sami Callihan - beats Penta in a Mexican Deathmatch on Impact Wrestling
2018-08-25 Josh Alexander - beats Callihan in a Steel Cage match at Impact/DWW One Night Only: Bad Intentions
2018-10-06 Evil Uno - beats Alexander at IWS British Strong Style
2018-11-03 Cecil Nyx - beats Uno at Queen Street Entertainment
2018-11-29 James Stone - beats Nyx, Vaughn Vertigo, and Urban Miles in a Four-Way match at Lutte07 Volume 2
2019-01-05 Sebastian Suave - beats Stone and Kevin Blanchard in a Three-Way match at FLQ/SMASH Cold Wars
2019-02-02 Kevin Bennett - beats Suave and Carter Mason at Impact/SMASH Brace for Impact
2019-02-09 Anthony Baines - beats Bennett at REVENGE The Revenge Rumble
2019-03-23 Kevin Bennett (2) - beats Baines and Aaron Draven in a Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match at REVENGE Luck is for Losers
2019-03-31 Mike Bailey - beats Bennett at SMASH Louder Now!
2019-04-05 Marko Estrada - beats Bailey at UCW/NSPW Standing 8 Tournament
2019-06-21 Josh Alexander (2) - beats Estrada and 4 others in a Six-Way Elimination match at C4 Crossing the Line 12: Set It Off
2019-06-29 Jay Freddie - beats Alexander at ESW Temperature Rising
2019-07-31 Brandon Thurston - beats Freddie on BEYOND Uncharted Territory
2019-10-26 Sebastian Suave (2) - beats Thurston at BTPW Trick 'r Treat
2019-12-15 Cody Deaner - beats Suave at SMASH Remix You a Merry Christmas
2020-07-19 Cousin Jake - beats Deaner on Impact Wrestling
2020-08-07 Joey Janela - beats Jake at Warrior Wrestling 9
2020-09-02 Chris Jericho - beats Janela on AEW Dynamite
2020-09-05 Orange Cassidy - beats Jericho in a Mimosa Mayhem match at AEW All Out
2020-09-23 Brodie Lee - beats Cassidy on AEW Dynamite
2020-10-07 Cody Rhodes - beats Lee in a Dog Collar match on AEW Dynamite
2020-11-07 Darby Allin - beats Cody at AEW Full Gear
2021-05-12 Miro - beats Allin on AEW Dynamite
2021-09-29 Sammy Guevara - beats Miro on AEW Dynamite
2021-12-22 Cody Rhodes - beats Guevara on AEW Rampage
2022-01-26 Sammy Guevara - beats Cody in a Ladder match on AEW Dynamite
2022-03-09 Scorpio Sky - beats Guevara on AEW Dynamite
2022-04-15 Sammy Guevara - beats Sky at AEW Battle of the Belts II
2022-04-27 Scorpio Sky - beats Guevara on AEW Dynamite
2022-07-06 Wardlow - beats Scorpio Sky on AEW Dynamite
2022-11-19 Samoa Joe - beats Wardlow and Powerhouse Hobbs at AEW Full Gear
2023-01-04 Darby Allin - beats Joe on AEW Dynamite
2023-02-01 Samoa Joe - beats Darby on AEW Dynamite
2023-03-05 Wardlow - beats Joe at AEW Revolution
2023-03-08 Powerhouse Hobbs - beats Wardlow in a Falls Count Anywhere match on AEW Dynamite
2023-04-19 Wardlow - beats Hobbs on AEW Dynamite
2023-06-17 Luchasaurus - beats Wardlow on AEW Collision
2023-09-23 Christian Cage - beats Luchasaurus and Darby on AEW Collision
2023-12-30 Adam Copeland - beats Christian at AEW World's End
2023-12-30 Christian Cage - beats Cope at AEW World's End
2024-03-20 Adam Copeland - beats Christian in an I Quit match on AEW Dynamite

(edit 2024-10 for OP cleanup)

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Who would be the 24/7 Champion, if it were only defended in actual matches?

Spoiler: Who holds the not-24/7 Title?

2019-05-20 Titus O'Neil - becomes the first champion on WWE Raw
2020-04-27 AJ Styles - beats O'Neil and 6 others in a Gauntlet match on WWE Raw
2020-05-10 Otis - beats AJ and 4 others in a Money in the Bank Corporate Ladder match at WWE Money in the Bank
2020-10-25 The Miz - beats Otis at WWE Hell in a Cell
2020-10-26 Drew McIntyre - beats Miz on WWE Raw
[2020-11-16 Drew captures the E-Crown]

(edit 2024-10 for OP cleanup)

This would be a lot more interesting if Titus weren't so bizarrely strongly booked for a lower-carder

 

[Hidden Blaze]

I need Randy Orton vs Bayley ASAP.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Spoiler: NOAH Go Forward

2020-06-21 Kotaro Suzuki - beats Hayashi at NOAH Go Forward

Kotaro Suzuki is now the lineal W-1 Champion and Mayor of DILLIGAF.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Someone suggested this a while ago.
Who is the rightful leader of nWo's B-Team?

Spoiler: Who holds the leadership?

1999-04-05 Stevie Ray - wins a battle royal on WCW Monday Nitro
1999-04-15 Diamond Dallas Page - beats Stevie on WCW Thunder
[DDP held Goldberg's streak...]
1999-11-21 Bret Hart (2) - beats Benoit at WCW Mayhem

 

[Leon TrotSky]

More hair!
Who owns Adrian Adonis' hair?

Spoiler: Who holds Adonis' hair?

1987-03-29 Roddy Piper - beats Adrian Adonis in a Hair vs. Hair match at WWF WrestleMania III, and with the help of Brutus Beefcake and 90,000 screaming Pipermaniacs packing the Silverdome, cuts the Adorable One's hair off
1990-02-16 Rick Rude - beats Piper at a WWF live event
1990-02-18 Roddy Piper (2) - beats Rude in a Steel Cage match at a WWF live event
1990-03-03 Rick Rude (2) - beats Piper at a WWF live event
1990-03-08 Big Boss Man - beats Rude in a Steel Cage match at a WWF live event
1990-04-13 Jake Roberts - beats Boss Man at WWF/NJPW/AJPW Wrestling Summit
1990-09-09 Mr. Perfect - beats Roberts at a WWF live event
1990-11-09 Texas Tornado - beats Perfect at a WWF live event
1990-11-19 Mr. Perfect (2) - beats Tornado on WWF Superstars
1990-11-21 Texas Tornado (2) - beats Perfect at a WWF live event
1990-12-15 Ted DiBiase - beats Tornado at a WWF live event
1991-01-20 Texas Tornado (3) - beats DiBiase at a WWF Live event
1991-06-15 The Warlord - beats Tornado at a WWF live event
1991-07-18 Jim Duggan - beats Warlord at a WWF live event
1991-08-08 Sgt. Slaughter - beats Duggan in a Bootcamp match at a WWF live event
1991-08-12 Jim Duggan (2) - beats Slaughter in a Bootcamp match at a WWF live event
1991-08-31 Irwin R. Schyster - beats Duggan at a WWF live event
1991-09-07 Bret Hart - beats IRS at WWF King of the Ring
1992-01-17 The Mountie - beats Hart at a WWF live event
1992-01-19 Roddy Piper (3) - beats Mountie at WWF Royal Rumble
1992-03-22 Ric Flair - beats Piper in a Steel Cage match at a WWF live event
1992-03-25 Roddy Piper (4) - beats Flair at a WWF live event
1992-04-05 Bret Hart (2) - beats Piper at WWF WrestleMania VIII
1992-08-29 British Bulldog - beats Hart at WWF SummerSlam
1992-10-27 Shawn Michaels - beats Bulldog on WWF Saturday Night's Main Event
1992-11-25 Bret Hart (3) - beats HBK at WWF Survivor Series
1993-04-04 Yokozuna - beats Hart at WWF WrestleMania IX
1993-04-04 Hulk Hogan - beats Yoko at WWF WrestleMania IX
1993-06-13 Yokozuna (2) - beats Hogan at WWF King of the Ring
1993-08-23 Lex Luger - beats Yoko at USWA A Matter of Pride
1994-08-21 Yokozuna (3) - beats Luger at a WWF live event
1994-08-25 Undertaker - beats Yoko in a Casket match at a WWF live event
1995-06-25 Mabel - beats Taker at WWF King of the Ring
1995-07-30 Razor Ramon - beats Mabel at a WWF live event
1995-08-27 Shawn Michaels (2) - beats Razor in a Ladder match at WWF SummerSlam
1996-03-03 Bret Hart (4) - beats HBK in a Lumberjack match at a WWF live event
1996-03-31 Shawn Michaels (3) - beats Hart in a 60-Minute Iron Man match at WWF WrestleMania XII
1996-11-17 Sycho Sid - beats HBK at WWF Survivor Series
1997-01-19 Shawn Michaels (4) - beats Sid at WWF Royal Rumble
1997-12-11 Triple H - beats Michaels on WWF Raw
1997-12-11 Undertaker (2) - beats HHH in a Casket match on WWF Raw (dark)
1998-01-18 Shawn Michaels (5) - beats Taker in a Casket match at WWF Royal Rumble
1998-03-29 Steve Austin - beats Michaels at WWF WrestleMania XIV
1998-06-28 Kane - beats Steve Austin in a First Blood match at WWF King of the Ring
1998-06-29 Steve Austin (2) - beats Kane on WWF Raw
1998-11-15 Mankind - beats Austin at WWF Survivor Series
1998-11-15 The Rock - beats Mankind at WWF Survivor Series
1998-11-20 Steve Austin (3) - beats Rock, Kane, and Taker in a Fatal Four-Way match at a WWF live event
[1999-03-28 Austin beats Rock at WrestleMania XV, and becomes King of Kings, which can only mean...]
2020-06-07 Randy Orton (7) - beats Edge at WWE Backlash

 

[Hidden Blaze]

My god LOL

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Remember King Haku? He didn't actually win a King of the Ring, but was awarded the crown that Harley Race had picked up from his 1986 win. It passed on to Hacksaw Jim Duggan when he beat Haku, to Randy Savage when he beat Duggan... and was abandoned after "Macho King"'s 1991 loss to the Ultimate Warrior. Are you thinking what I'm thinking?
Who is the current 1986 King of the Ring?

Spoiler: Who holds the crown?

1991-03-15 Randy Savage - his last win with the crown, a Steel Cage match vs. Warrior at a WWF live event
1991-03-24 Ultimate Warrior - beats Savage in a Retirement match at WWF WrestleMania VII
1998-10-25 Hulk Hogan - beats Warrior at WCW Halloween Havoc
[1999-01-04 Hogan wins the Fingerpoke of Doom and takes up Goldberg's Streak...]
1999-11-21 Bret Hart (2) - beats Benoit at WCW Mayhem

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Ngl. I thought it be Orton


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk