"I Wanna Play A Game" - Saw Mafia - Game Thread

[Junkette]

Don’t really see Doddsy and Rugrat aligned based on Doddsy backing off on him when he tried pushing him on day 1.

 

[Junkette]

Also like a Odo said, Lethal flipping mafia does Poyser no real favours, cause it’s pretty obvious and he was suspecting him in his first life.

 

[Evans]

can you provide a reads list please?

1. Hank
2. Ace Dalton - Didn't really branch out early game, was content discussing what was ongoing in the thread. Became more confident and more commanding as game went on. Seemed to pick up the reigns when Odo died.
3. PHEN0M Mi$ Bli$$ v2 - Still not sold by her "accidental" claim on her reads list and still find the reads list odd (basically what mine and her interaction 5-6 pages ago was about). Null, but high up the POE. The post from Phenom that Lethal shaded me on looked weird but NAI and probably just incorrect. Lethal picking up on it and trying to discredit it entirely made me think there could be something there.
5. Doddsy - Null, not great at reading Doddsy or picking up on "slimy" nuances as he's been labelled with today, will ISO.
9. Rugrat - Likely town, setup spec around the role/vote modifiers for one and that after I nudged him and we had our interaction, he was making good points. He has continued to make good points and trying to solve things as the games progressed.
10. NotBrutus - Likely town, he's been active and engaging points rather than just trolling.
11. Lethal Banks - his immediate "FUCKERY!" felt premeditated right after day was posted. He also tried to discredit me over a question to Phenom regarding the wording "current events", he tried to twist it in a way that I was being opportunistic to push him when I wasn't even shading him at all.
13. Alco Big Man v2 - You came back in with urgency and weren't afraid to get stuck into your reads / where you left off. Continuously tried to make good points. Haven't noticed any scum buddying that I saw last game from ya.
14. MitchJo Rawley Poyser v2 - Hard to explain but his behaviour has felt different since he came back in, but there's also been inactivity. High up my POE.
15. Raidokken - mostly setup spec and his posts around CP. Not sure why he was so adamant about CP being town but with his EXPERT DISTANCING SKILLS, it's hard to ignore that WIFOM situation.
16. Kajuh - A lot of his posts feel coached, man was dropping "been sussed all day" (or something to this effect containing the word sus) which came across WAY TOO naturally for a new player.

 

[RDK]

I haven’t played with you as scum yet, and this game feels vastly different to your town game in Heroes. You can’t really compare the two.

Let’s say I’m town and i’m wrong and you’re town, who do you have in my slot.

Cause if it’s a 3 man team I can see it being Lethal/Poyser v2/Rugrat with Doddsy as the SK. I don’t really see Doddsy as mafia especially if you flip scum.

I'm basically working from 100 pages behind. It would be impossible to replicate my town game here as I don't have a good feel for what's been going on. Perhaps that's why my scum team is a little disjointed.

I don't think Hank and Poyser are together. Doddsy MAYBE but I haven't minded him at all reading back. Ace and Brutus have felt fairly genuine. Big Man might be worth considering but he hasn't pinged me. Kajuh is very EH, there was one post that I thought seemed a little advanced for his level but then why would scum tell him to do that if it would just make him look coached. Also the claim situation made him more likely town.

 

[Kajuh]

14. MitchJo Rawley Poyser v2 - Hard to explain but his behaviour has felt different since he came back in, but there's also been inactivity. High up my POE.

16. Kajuh - A lot of his posts feel coached, man was dropping "been sussed all day" (or something to this effect containing the word sus) which came across WAY TOO naturally for a new player.

I feel the same way about Poy. He was posting so much and most times made a lot of good points as V1 and then his V2 posts just lack substance and feel fake.

I said sus because all the cool kids say it in Among Us and Among Us is the only experience I have with these types of games lol

 

[Rugrat]

@Tweet

there's been a lynch I think

 

[RDK]

1. Hank
2. Ace Dalton - Didn't really branch out early game, was content discussing what was ongoing in the thread. Became more confident and more commanding as game went on. Seemed to pick up the reigns when Odo died.
3. PHEN0M Mi$ Bli$$ v2 - Still not sold by her "accidental" claim on her reads list and still find the reads list odd (basically what mine and her interaction 5-6 pages ago was about). Null, but high up the POE. The post from Phenom that Lethal shaded me on looked weird but NAI and probably just incorrect. Lethal picking up on it and trying to discredit it entirely made me think there could be something there.
5. Doddsy - Null, not great at reading Doddsy or picking up on "slimy" nuances as he's been labelled with today, will ISO.
9. Rugrat - Likely town, setup spec around the role/vote modifiers for one and that after I nudged him and we had our interaction, he was making good points. He has continued to make good points and trying to solve things as the games progressed.
10. NotBrutus - Likely town, he's been active and engaging points rather than just trolling.
11. Lethal Banks - his immediate "FUCKERY!" felt premeditated right after day was posted. He also tried to discredit me over a question to Phenom regarding the wording "current events", he tried to twist it in a way that I was being opportunistic to push him when I wasn't even shading him at all.
13. Alco Big Man v2 - You came back in with urgency and weren't afraid to get stuck into your reads / where you left off. Continuously tried to make good points. Haven't noticed any scum buddying that I saw last game from ya.
14. MitchJo Rawley Poyser v2 - Hard to explain but his behaviour has felt different since he came back in, but there's also been inactivity. High up my POE.
15. Raidokken - mostly setup spec and his posts around CP. Not sure why he was so adamant about CP being town but with his EXPERT DISTANCING SKILLS, it's hard to ignore that WIFOM situation.
16. Kajuh - A lot of his posts feel coached, man was dropping "been sussed all day" (or something to this effect containing the word sus) which came across WAY TOO naturally for a new player.

WRT Poyser I think his behaviour actually switched mid-first life into second life so I don't think it's alignment indicative

 

[Evans]

I said sus because all the cool kids say it in Among Us and Among Us is the only experience I have with these types of games lol

I can buy this

also anyone?

 

[Junkette]

Impossible to replicate your town game here?

 

[RDK]

Impossible to replicate your town game here?

not everything is a slip ffs. I want to replicate my town game as town so people know i'm town and so that I can be as effective as possible, relax

 

[Big Man]

 

[Junkette]

not everything is a slip ffs. I want to replicate my town game as town so people know i'm town and so that I can be as effective as possible, relax

Well this was more of a reaction then I expected.

 

[RDK]

What do you read me? You're worse at reading me than anyone so that should be helpful for people

 

[RDK]

haza must be scum because he isn't defending his friend!!!

 

[Big Man]

What do you read me? You're worse at reading me than anyone so that should be helpful for people

so why did you vote me earlier for misreading you?