Graphics Battle: Extreme Rules 2021 Poster

[Chris]

Judges should be able to reasonably critique as well as just picking which looks cooler btw

Then I'm probably not the best man for the job

 

[Death By Looch]

 

[RDK]

Then I'm probably not the best man for the job

That wasn't aimed at you btw. Just a note that if we you're going to have judges for a contest they should be able to critique the pieces, might as well just have a poll and let everyone vote otherwise if ygm

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Then I'm probably not the best man for the job

Same

 

[Marty McFourth]

That wasn't aimed at you btw. Just a note that if we you're going to have judges for a contest they should be able to critique the pieces, might as well just have a poll and let everyone vote otherwise if ygm

I don't mind either way. Smark is good at critque, Nimrod is knowledgeable on graphics, you and Jeff have given me good feedback. It really just comes down to who wants to critically review them.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I don't think you need to be super knowledgeable about the graphic process to be critical. I'm not either. It's just picking out what you like/dislike about a piece of work and looking at it bit more closely. For example, some of my image and text choices I feel have been bad on my posters. So that is a flaw you could pick out.

 

[PeepShow]

Yeah, I think the best option would be to just send each of our pieces to a third party (someone like Smark, or a higher up that doesn't participate) and and then they post each of them in a new thread and opens it up with an anonymous poll to everyone on the forum to vote and give their thoughts and feedback, however detailed it might be.

So we have:
1. PeepShow
2. The Fourth Wall
3. Yer Best Pal

If anyone else wants to join over the duration of the contest you're more than welcome. What's the deadline going to be? Sunday at midnight EST? You want it open until the PPV?

 

[Death By Looch]

If anyone else wants to join over the duration of the contest you're more than welcome. What's the deadline going to be? Sunday at midnight EST? You want it open until the PPV?

Extreme Rules is on September 26, so I'd suggest to have joining in open til the 11th, then deadline to make it is the 18th, which gives the judges a week and places can be revealed on the 25th, the day before the actual PPV.
Just fanning it out so it can "breathe".

 

[Smart Marx]

I wouldn't mind being a judge if one is needed.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Extreme Rules is on September 26, so I'd suggest to have joining in open til the 11th, then deadline to make it is the 18th, which gives the judges a week and places can be revealed on the 25th, the day before the actual PPV.
Just fanning it out so it can "breathe".

This sounds good to me. Gives us plenty of time to make them, and hopefully some more people join in the fun.

 

[Doom]

I'll have to pass on the graphics contest. I know I'm the favorite to participate, but there's too much on my mind right now for me to compete.

I'm so sorry everyone.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I'll have to pass on the graphics contest. I know I'm the favorite to participate, but there's too much on my mind right now for me to compete.

I'm so sorry everyone.

Is judging off the table as well? You're quite knowledgeable on the subject.

Sorry to hear that Nimrod. Hope things get better soon.

 

[PeepShow]

No worries Doom.

So yeah, we've got three people so far. Anyone else is open to join until the 11th, and the deadline to submit is the 18th. Who is open to taking the submissions and posting the thread on the 25th?

 

[Doom]

Is judging off the table as well? You're quite knowledgeable on the subject.

Sorry to hear that Nimrod. Hope things get better soon.

I can still be a judge.

 

[PeepShow]

Just a reminder that you have a few days left to enter if you're interested in getting in on this. Deadline to enter is the 11th and submissions are due by the end of the day on 18th with voting starting on the 25th.