"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Ace Marvel]

I know showtime was not really playing, but SA?

 

[RDK]

Are you actually caught up Haza because questioning McHenry using Lethals vote count seems like a tremendous waste of time considering the current direction and what hes already revealed today...

what did he reveal that would change anything im saying, im not seeing it?

He can use it twice, if anything this would make him more trigger happy no?

 

[John McHenry]

McHenry your stance on Tweet here is obviously the most pressing matter. You were bold enough to entrench yourself in the camp of his winning the duel but not enough to save him using your shot?

It was very early on I was confident he was town. But not confident enough to save him against virtually everyone else. As I said flat out saving him I felt like it'd have killed him and I both. I had the weird thought he'd been framed based on his actions, before then (and it probably helps I don't really know roles so I can make anything up and assume it can apply) then after he was killed scum would point at me for saving him. Ironic cause now you point at me for not saving him lol

 

[Sister Abigail]

I think I’d prefer to lynch WPE here just for the sure hit if I’m honest

I don’t hate baldrick being lynched either as I think he is probably scum. But I’m just sure WPE is

You trying to steer me away from a second mate?

 

[Poyser]

You trying to steer me away from a second mate?

Huh

 

[Ace Marvel]

Magic was still in game after Lethal first claim cop.
Wouldn’t the smart thing be to check the fake cop?

 

[Ace Marvel]

CP claimed VT

 

[RDK]

It was very early on I was confident he was town. But not confident enough to save him against virtually everyone else. As I said flat out saving him I felt like it'd have killed him and I both. I had the weird thought he'd been framed based on his actions, before then (and it probably helps I don't really know roles so I can make anything up and assume it can apply) then after he was killed scum would point at me for saving him. Ironic cause now you point at me for not saving him lol

But scum would only point at you for saving Tweet if Tweet was scum. You're saying you were confident he was town, so the logic doesn't really track

 

[Comrade Khan]

what did he reveal that would change anything im saying, im not seeing it?

He can use it twice, if anything this would make him more trigger happy no?

I mean sure if thats not his role/hes lying about usage to look better. You would likely need to go back and see his actual posts throughout the phase and compare them to see what he is saying now. likely your best bet to see if it adds up or not . but yes, it was the 2 shot thing that just would obviously never exist for scum. clearly thats irrelevant if you think hes making it all up, tho

 

[RDK]

I mean sure if thats not his role/hes lying about usage to look better. You would likely need to go back and see his actual posts throughout the phase and compare them to see what he is saying now. likely your best bet to see if it adds up or not . but yes, it was the 2 shot thing that just would obviously never exist for scum. clearly thats irrelevant if you think hes making it all up, tho

I'm just trying to work through his reasoning for the decisions he's made and they're not really adding up to me tbh

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm just trying to work through his reasoning for the decisions he's made and they're not really adding up to me tbh

I mean Ive done no legwork but I didnt really have an issue with him not using the shot and going against town. if youre saying they still voted them to lose and didnt seem to bothered by it at the time tho, and now he is saying he was, then sure, you have a good point id say

 

[Ace Marvel]

Claims
Poyser - Psychologist
John - Modified Governor
Lethal V 2.0 Cop
Baldrick - Duelist (used)
SA - Something

Jeff Indi something that keeps changing

VT
CP
ACE
RDK

Death roles
Jeff V1 Desperado
Ekko JK
Mando Watcher
Switch Arsonist
Holt PGO
Phemon Faith Doctor

VT
Lethal V1
Tweet
One

Mafia
Tommy Jammer/Strongman

 

[Sister Abigail]

If Lethal is our Cop, pretty wild to think I've had a blue check on me this whole fucking game and I've had to go what I've gone through.

 

[John McHenry]

But scum would only point at you for saving Tweet if Tweet was scum. You're saying you were confident he was town, so the logic doesn't really track

That's true but that's assuming I wasn't gone after first for the save. It could have gone down in either order.

 

[Comrade Khan]

If Lethal is our Cop, pretty wild to think I've had a blue check on me this whole fucking game and I've had to go what I've gone through.