"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Wiseman]

Doesn’t make sense tho. If this is what he was doing, would he not have said that in defence of himself when he’s being attacked by people for it? Lol

you’ve literally just made up a motivation for him, one which he never even thought of himself. I don’t get it

If he said he did it just to ruffle feathers it discounts his entire list. Granted, him saying he was just confused when it came to naming one of the people isn't much better.

 

[Poyser]

If he said he did it just to ruffle feathers it discounts his entire list. Granted, him saying he was just confused when it came to naming one of the people isn't much better.

He discounted his entire list himself already lol

 

[Ekkologix]

Well, to say this game is easy to follow working 12 hour days and having about 2 hours to read it at night would be an understatement.

Never the less, I'll lay out the few thoughts I have thus far.

I'll first say that I understand why Sayer's play is getting the suss alarm for a number of people is cause well it does every game. The list he made on day 1 without a doubt has a number of red flags. Personally, my thoughts are that Sayer put a lot of the people with the alignments he did to ruffle feathers and see if he could hook anyone with his, virtual, baseless thoughts. With that said though, I don't think he's scum. Do I think he's town, not entirely, feels more like Indy more so than anything if there is any in this game.

I also think that, with assuming if smark was the NK that it was so they could plant it on Sayer. After he was grilling her so much about a list of the entire roster of people. I believe the Sayer train that could happen today is definitely something to look at if he does flip town.

I also will say that with the amount of posts that have happened in just one day and one night phase has allowed mafia to just sit back and let town just duke it out for the time being. (Yes I can see the irony with the fact that I'm just coming around to posting)

My only real decent read one way or the other is I feel Man has to be town. Not sure he would throw out the info of being watcher, throw out a name right away and have it turn on him that easily if that person is lynched that day. With that, I'll have to trust his watcher claim and go with the duel.

Beyond that I feel best about RD, Craig and Wang from the things I remembered throughout. Aside from that, well I'm really not sure.

My aim is to do my damnest to keep up but until tomorrow night (as tomorrow night is the start of my "weekend") it'll be sleep and work for the most part.


duel winner Baldrick

so u town read all active posts?

 

[RDK]

unvote

be back later or tmr

 

[Ekkologix]

My scum mates thought of it. Give Ace some credit mate

u r in no position to be joking

 

[Wiseman]

so u town read all active posts?

That's far from what I said. I said who I felt best about and such. I really suspect pretty much anyone until there is a really good reason not to.

 

[Poyser]

That's far from what I said. I said who I felt best about and such. I really suspect pretty much anyone until there is a really good reason not to.

Unless it’s your mate captain holt who to town read in spite of having a really good reason not to

 

[Ace Marvel]

u r in no position to be joking

I would have suggested fruit vendor that gets redirected

 

[Wiseman]

Unless it’s your mate captain holt who to town read in spite of having a really good reason not to

I also said he could be Indy.

 

[Poyser]

I also said he could be Indy.

 

[Ace Marvel]

PGO is the kind of claim that protects you from being checked killed.
If town, then mafia has to waste day kill power to get rid of holt.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Stalker guy said I only suss him because he suss me, I never said he was scum.

he is gone after me saying that. Just a wild thought.

 

[Captain Holt]

u r in no position to be joking

Right. Im sorry, sir. Wont happen again, sir. No joy or laughter, sir.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I didn't mean to say anything by it really, you know me, I get a snarky comment, I respond in kind

If ur town u should make a read list we can use

 

[Ekkologix]

That's far from what I said. I said who I felt best about and such. I really suspect pretty much anyone until there is a really good reason not to.

so then u dont town read all active players? who do u twon read in them?

the names u listed include cp and wang r inactive and u said they look good

so to summarize you think town is duking it out while mafia is hiding, but also town read 2 of the inactive players yet not scum read all of the active ones

is it fair to call u out for being vague? can u make a read list and include all the players town to scum in it?