"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Tweet]

I have my reasons.

This game

 

[Poyser]

so u see his action as scummy. i see no reason to try and wifom him as not scum tweet there. he could have simply messed up

I didn’t really see him as scummy in a bubble no, I disagreed with his read and challenged him on it. It’s a bit of a meta read but I just didn’t really see scum tweet backing down from his read after a little challenge. He’d be too self conscious about it and would be worried that it’d make him look bad. I’d expect him to double down and defend his read or at the very least do some kind of “agree to disagree” post

 

[Poyser]

page 11 so far

leaning town
poyser
magic
baldrick

town side of null / indie
smark
abigail

leaning scum
red
tweet
mandalorian

Why magic town?

 

[Ekkologix]

Is this buddying?

really x lmao

 

[Poyser]

Vote Tweet

I’d rather go this direction. Let Jeff prove himself.

Jeff has already claimed so it would be a vote to lynch.

Considering what you’ve been heavily implying, I do find it interesting that you’d be hesitant to lynch Jeff, combined with the fact that you don’t really read him town lol. What’s your thought process?

 

[Poyser]

poyser/mando interaction is very boring and needlessly verbose and feels t/t

Hey now, he was being needlessly verbose not me

cuz he probably scum

 

[Tweet]

@Poyser, these were some of the posts that I thought seemed a little aggressive for the earliest stage of the game.



Trying to ID new people early seems like a scummy thing to do. Assuming they could keep rookies around longer since they won't know what they're doing. Not a bad strategy I guess, but tipping that hand seems scummy to me.




I thought these were real votes, which seems so reckless to me. Later, there was some conversation about them not being genuine votes, just discussing how voting here compared to WC.

I don't think that's what was said. Kinda seems like Man is posturing a bit.

I'm not entirely sure if you believe what you're saying here. I thought that if nothing else, it was obvious that the second vote wasn't intentional.

 

[Smart Marx]

Considering what you’ve been heavily implying, I do find it interesting that you’d be hesitant to lynch Jeff, combined with the fact that you don’t really read him town lol. What’s your thought process?

Ace back down from what I thought he was softing so it gives Jeff a little bit more wiggle room.

 

[Poyser]

town

showtime obviously
ekko (or survivor idc)
smark
baldrick
mando
poyser
sister abigail
ace marvel

scum

tweet
maybe jeff but probably not bussing each other

This post is what made me realise it for some reason but I also have liked ekko’s catch up so far

why’ve you got baldrick as town?

 

[Smart Marx]

This post is what made me realise it for some reason but I also have liked ekko’s catch up so far

why’ve you got baldrick as town?

Glad I’m not alone and thinking Ekko is doing pretty good right now.

 

[Poyser]

i fail to see that question as genuine. abigail has been nothing but passive in the early game. obviously to me seems u arent interested in abigails alignment, but instead u ask what makes him feel reserved.

i love to see u show us where that question coming from. do u think abigail is not reserved?

How was Abigail passive in the early part of the game at all?

 

[Poyser]

Am I wrong in this but did anyone actually say Abigail was being reserved?

As far as I can remember, it was just Sayer saying that I was?

Yea, he did clarify that he meant you and not abigail

that said I can’t remember if he answered why he thought abigail was most sus lol

 

[Captain Holt]

Not sure I like what Im seeing from Smark.

This whole "I give my reads on my time... " shit then answering cryptically with "I have my reasons"....

Werent you the one whp said the more people talk, the better?

 

[Comrade Khan]

what about tweet lol

at this point seems to me u both r scum. u r CLEARLY hard ignoring tweet and he is hard ignoring u outside of ur distancing posts to him that he obviously ignored and u never cared to bring back

whatever you say

 

[Poyser]

this is ur first game with abigail correct? he can get alot more aggro than this.

did hold play with abigail before. seems like he made a wild guess of how reserved/aggro abigail can get.

given that red has played with abigail before it makes there question about what makes them reserved seem even worst because he shud know how aggro abigail can get in day 1

I have played with abigail before yes but I don’t recall them being particularly aggressive