"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Smart Marx]

Ohh you noted it have you? Care to tell me what you thought of it?

(Cause ya see I'm scummy af and really really worried about what people think of me)

Keep reading. I've already done this dance with Poyser.

See, no stretching. I'm already tapping out.

 

[Smart Marx]

Anyways, it's 3am. Y'all have fun.

 

[Tweet]

Do you have any feelings on Smark's alignment currently?

You're correct that his little comment towards me was weak sauce but a big part of me thinks he wouldn't bother with that as scum and be more preoccupied with blending in and not stepping on anybodys toes. Plus his point that nothing much was going on at the time is pretty accurate, I felt the same way about the thread. His interaction with you rn strikes me as genuine as well, so currently I lean town.

 

[Tweet]

Idk, I think it's time to try and get this game out of the muck

vote Sister Abigail

 

[Baldrick]

Christ that catchup was heaven after the champ games where I woke up to 500+ posts every single morning

I kinda liked Jeff's entrance, though he disappeared fast so Im not really gonna give him a cookie for it, but it's encouraging! Seemed comfortable
Like I said I think Tweet trying to figure out who that guy was is *slightly* rand>town because I don't really see him giving a shit as scum. Felt to me like he was at least putting some time into figuring out who the guy was

Sister Abigail is my first proper townlean, thought they had a strong entrance and tried to cut through the bullshit

Not really liking Baldrick's entrance and seemed like he was just trying to make inane conversation for the sake of it. That question to Jeff was a load of nothing lol, what was he asking if he was "hunting"? Dude literally just asked how many games you'd played before

vote baldrick

Smark has been pretty underwhelming as well, inb4 "OMG I DONT DO ANYTHING ON D1 YOU SHOULD KNOW THIS"

Welcome to my play style

 

[Poyser]

You're correct that his little comment towards me was weak sauce but a big part of me thinks he wouldn't bother with that as scum and be more preoccupied with blending in and not stepping on anybodys toes. Plus his point that nothing much was going on at the time is pretty accurate, I felt the same way about the thread. His interaction with you rn strikes me as genuine as well, so currently I lean town.

Kinda feel the same about his interaction with me tbh. Really wish he'd have found that game he was talking about though

 

[Poyser]

Idk, I think it's time to try and get this game out of the muck

vote Sister Abigail

Huh this is like the literal last place I'd have voted right now lmao

What are you seeing there?

 

[Poyser]

Welcome to my play style

Ok but you didn't answer my question

What exactly were you asking him? Like what did you mean "hunting early" and what exactly would people be "biting on" lol?

 

[Baldrick]

Ok but you didn't answer my question

What exactly were you asking him? Like what did you mean "hunting early" and what exactly would people be "biting on" lol?

Just probing back. When you admit you want to know peoples level of experience to know how to handle them is a bit pointless when things change up all the time anyway...unless there are those that just do the same old thing game in, game out and are easy to hook in.

 

[Tweet]

Huh this is like the literal last place I'd have voted right now lmao

What are you seeing there?

I think I remember SA being more on the no-nonsense side as town and a post or two out of them struck me as bit too amiable when I read them so this is my best hunch atm

 

[Poyser]

Just probing back. When you admit you want to know peoples level of experience to know how to handle them is a bit pointless when things change up all the time anyway...unless there are those that just do the same old thing game in, game out and are easy to hook in.

Pretty sure it would be so he knows whether you’re a total newbie or not? Like surely you can see how you’d have different expectations of the thought processes of someone that’s playing their first or second game vs someone who’s played 50?

i don’t really get what you mean by “do people usually bite this early” though? Like what would they be biting on? Answering the question? Lying? Refusing to answer? What constitutes biting when you’ve been asked how many games you’ve played

 

[Poyser]

I think I remember SA being more on the no-nonsense side as town and a post or two out of them struck me as bit too amiable when I read them so this is my best hunch atm

See “no-nonsense” is pretty much exactly how I’ve seen them so far in this game. See the post where they asked baldrick (I think) if they’re looking for a soft landing. About as no nonsense as you can get lol

fancy pointing to the posts that made you feel otherwise?

 

[Baldrick]

Pretty sure it would be so he knows whether you’re a total newbie or not? Like surely you can see how you’d have different expectations of the thought processes of someone that’s playing their first or second game vs someone who’s played 50?

i don’t really get what you mean by “do people usually bite this early” though? Like what would they be biting on? Answering the question? Lying? Refusing to answer? What constitutes biting when you’ve been asked how many games you’ve played

The thought process shouldn't change, it should stay the same.

Who says none of us who have answered the question have lied about the amount of games we've played it? All part of the perception isn't it?

My currently feeling is the votes layed down so far are in the wrong direction, especially as we have a few people who haven't contributed to the discussions yet.

 

[Tweet]

Ah a newbie, makes more sense. Sure, if you'd like to call me out, you should. What do you think about my game has been suspicious so far?

It was this one but in hindsight my reasoning doesn't hold up. I was just glancing over it and the first sentence looked like he was easing off on a newbie out of the blue but if I actually read it properly he doesn't ease up but asks a followup question.

Thank you for being so helpful. If I'm not mistaken, is this not your first post of the game?

This one as well, looked like "thanks for answering me, have a nice day" but really isn't.

Tl;dr this game is 9 pages old and already I'm not reading properly
If anything I could accuse SA that he's not come to any conclusions yet but that's not really his fault if people aren't answering his questions

unvote

 

[Mandalorian]

The thought process shouldn't change, it should stay the same.

Who says none of us who have answered the question have lied about the amount of games we've played it? All part of the perception isn't it?

My currently feeling is the votes layed down so far are in the wrong direction, especially as we have a few people who haven't contributed to the discussions yet.

Whilst I’ll admit that my vote on OJ was purely because of him having appalling Community knowledge, interested to see why you’re feeling that it’s the wrong direction with so little to go off, Baldy?

Smark’s vote on OJ also seemed to be the product of him showing me how people vote on WS and the difference between how we used to do it on WC.