"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Sister Abigail]

Poyser is probably Town.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Probably vibing Lethal as Town as well.

 

[Sister Abigail]

@Ekkologix @Tweet

Are you guys Town? Please be honest with me, I'll know.

 

[Sister Abigail]

vote lynch jeff

YEET

Vote Red Dragon

 

[Ekkologix]

Can you people let me have my moment and see what other say about Red Dragon gosh.

ABORT MISSION

Real claiming day vig 101

An outed vig is fodder and no longer useful = vanilla.

not a day vig as that is usually hard to stop since mafias abilities r mostly night ones usually

Ace Marvel posts vibe fake easygoing to me

what r u suggesting we do about it?

I have reasons that I was also skeptical of Jeff’s claim immediately, but I want to hear more from him. He’s seemingly disappeared.

well u gotta ask him questions if u want to hear from him. he already claimed and is the top poster at the time. this is just lazy

 

[Sister Abigail]

I have read the thread a few times throughout the day and some last night here are some of the thoughts going through my head.

I don't see how anyone thought SA was being aggressive in any ffashion. I felt SA was merely asking questions to see how people would respond to get better reads.

I felt Jeff was not all over the place and all over the thread which he does have the most posts but pretty sure most games I have played he was scum and seemed to be posting alot more a d I don't recall him being as defensive as he was in the reading back I did as he has done today and don't recall him ever claiming this early or on day 1 in any other games I have played here in the past.

I initially felt good about Smark early on he has seemed to get somewhat defensive with Sayer (Holt) about reads has me questioning him. Feel somewhat emotional at times.

Man- stuck on the claim with Jeff and him mentioning he was a day vig and thinking he was saying he was going to kill whomever was on his vote train was weird and then arguing with Poyser didn't help him out any.

Baldy- his play has been weird and I always think he is scum in games so I will lean nuetral on him.

Sayer (Holt)- not as abrasive as usual and seems to be trying to gain info through conversation and asking questions.

I have liked the read back from Ecko and CP as well and Magic as well no lean any direction as of yet.

Lethal- I think is probably town. He has been bringing up some positive points and asking Sayer why he didn't submit a reads list when asking smark for one.

Ace Marvel- Seemed calm and collected so probably town.

Tommy- nueteral. Seems like a confused newbie.

John (mcstalker) - neutral

Tweet- I don't mind what I have read so far seemed to be asking questions but aggravated with ecko.

OJ- came in to start the game not sure he has said anything since- neutral.


Pretty sure I have missed some players that have posted.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

If Wang is Wolf, I'll suicide.

 

[Smart Marx]

not a day vig as that is usually hard to stop since mafias abilities r mostly night ones usually


what r u suggesting we do about it?


well u gotta ask him questions if u want to hear from him. he already claimed and is the top poster at the time. this is just lazy

I asked him many questions, lol.

 

[Ekkologix]

However he did open the day by asking who wants to die, so clearly he planned to claim it early here before coming in

ive done many of these breadcrumbs as scum. it really does not benefit town to hint ur role because uhhh scum can find the hint easier than town since scum is generally entering the game with a mindset to hunt power roles while town's mindset is hunting scum. also scum are a group of players working together. if one town found the hint, good for him only. if one scum found the hint then the entire team does. its essentially always anti town to breadcrumb this way and is just a mean to cover his tracks later when he claims. i gotta say im not impressed with how u r handling this jeffs claim btw poyser. it seems like u r soft defending him

 

[Sister Abigail]

Switchblade probably Town as well.

 

[Ekkologix]

One vote cuz all of this, let's make it happen again

vote Jeff

werent u defending him earlier?

@Red Dragon are you a one-shot and do you have limitations?

You don’t need to say what limitations or how many shots if it’s more than one.

nah he needs to come clean
strip claim
full claim everything

 

[Smart Marx]

werent u defending him earlier?


nah he needs to come clean
strip claim
full claim everything

There’s one of those questions you claimed I was too lazy to ask.

 

[Smart Marx]

werent u defending him earlier?


nah he needs to come clean
strip claim
full claim everything

Also, why do you want scum to have full knowledge of a potential town power role?

 

[Ekkologix]

it's mostly the case. Like I'll be a big bitch if I have a super strong town role and ill refuse to claim. but I wouldn't get bored and claim off 1 as scum, id have some sort of plan. plus i wasnt in any real trouble, just as I said, didn't feel like spending the day arguing and was getting annoyed lol.

instead of this can u provide some legacy reads on those who either voted u or suspected u or discussed ur claim one way or another pls

 

[Sister Abigail]

My apologies but I think your list is full of garbage. Some of those leans are just . Of note, how is Wang a town lean? He’s done nothing but answered rudimentary questions. What are your mafia vibes based off? What is Baldrick’s town game for those who haven’t played with him before?

Why do you think this is a shitty list?

 

[Ekkologix]

he gets so mad as town though , but ya, it's certainly different? I dunno, I unvoted because I was expexting scum him to be PISSEd and then he wasnt

did u really expect him to be pissed? ur vote had 0 fire behind it. he can brush it off easily