"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

I’m 2x psychologist, which seems to be a slightly weaker version of a gunsmith. I can check if someone has the ability to kill, but if they have already committed a kill then I can’t tell

N1 - PHEN0M
N2 - McNightStalker

obviously neither had the ability to kill. McNighty not 100% clear but he’d have to have made the kill on N1 to not be town so I’m fairly happy just calling him town

it’s why I am pretty sure scum will have at least one member that has an extra kill ability, because it would mean they have something to claim if I catch them and it’s not a death sentence.

it’s also why I said I still think lethal could be scum immediately after he claimed

Ah ok heres the claim n usage. Imteresting weaker version , id feel better if a sk flipped but hmmm. Ok

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don’t really care about the info at this point. I wanna hit scum as we desperately need to. If we lynch someone on the basis that they provide more info and they’re town then we’re fucked

Ok this post makes me a lil less paranoid about poyboy

 

[Comrade Khan]

well ok. I wondered why I hadn't been counter claimed, turns out - the REAL cop was Magic

N1 - Sister Abigail, Union Aligned
N2 - No usage
N3 - Poyser, Union Aligned

Why did I check you? Hunch to see if you'd power wolfed. The mislynches piling up, you've been in a sense calm about them, and have played off a lot of the flips as "oh man Barry games are annoying and frustrating." Minus fuckery, I'm now comfy that your skin is clean and can rescue the game for town. The sister result has really stumped me though, as I was convinced in slot 1 that he was scum. Again, minus fuckery, that's 2 class players who can unite together. One thing is clear though, you're not s/s together.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Whos left to claim

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Poyser only 2 shots?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Was magic around or ever comment on lethal's cop claim ?

 

[Lethal]

Was magic around or ever comment on lethal's cop claim ?

I don't think he ever saw it. I'll ISO his posts.

Also, WIFOM, but I rep for Magic and not WPE? 18 posts vs 2?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don't think he ever saw it. I'll ISO his posts.

Also, WIFOM, but I rep for Magic and not WPE? 18 posts vs 2?

i mean I repped in for indi so i would not use that science only

 

[Comrade Khan]

you can iso his posts but im trying to figure out if youre lying lethal

 

[Lethal]

I like this tho. Especially the random call out of a pair in a sea of other inactive.

@Baldrick why did you pick those two to question?

His last post. It was after day flip, so my claim was out there. He had an exchange with Sister and then copped him.

The "liked this tho" was Sister's case presented on Baldy way back on Day 1.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Hi, what do you think of power scum players.

Most of these reads seem like "they've done stuff so they're Town. Whereas these people haven't or have done so poorly so they're scum".

You don't seem new so this way of hunting seems far too linear.

^^ this would give credence to magic copping abi

+1 for lethal

 

[Lethal]

Baldy Needs A Toupee

So Baldy's first four posts into this game is pretty fluffy. I know that doesn't mean a lot, but Baldy said they had a lot of experience, so I guess I'd be hoping from something a bit more from a player with that experience. When Poyser calls him out on it, he just claims its his playstyle.



Again, I would hope an experienced player wouldn't be this casual.

Posts 129 and 133 some early talk about how votes are in the wrong direction but gives no correction on where they should go or what their reads are. Post 149 Tweet calls Baldy out on not liking votes and asks for clarification but gets nothing in return. Not liking this at all.]

Posts 147 and 167 are posts I don't like because Baldy purposely draws attention to how they're 'fine' with having votes on them. This seems forced to me.



I hate this post. Poyser calls Baldrick scum and Baldrick then gives Poyser a Town read. Just feels wrong.



This is a weird callout. Why asking these two in particular? He says it's because he hasn't seen them post, but there were a few players like that at the time.

Makes me wonder as well considering I think Tommy is a bit Wolfy.



Did suss Mando. Take that for what you will.



This reads list seems forced and like he just picked names out of a hat. Doesn't even lean too hard one way or another on any of these players. Feels terrible.



Appeal to emotion? I guess he can prove his role. Heard Governor or Duelist tossed around. Doesn't mean those are Town roles.

This is the full post that Magic liked.

 

[Comrade Khan]

sadly thats pretty much all the magic posts I can go on, bummer.

 

[Lethal]

is magic gonna see what I see? there may be some hope in the world!

What was it that you saw? Cos, uh, I don't see it

 

[Comrade Khan]

What was it that you saw? Cos, uh, I don't see it

i was happy at the time because it felt like he was starting to scum read abi, which i did as well during that period