"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[John McHenry]

can we get more votes on holt? r we sure majority is reached actually?

Believe it's 13

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Believe it's 13

I skimmed through the posts starting with Grim's count (2:08 EST), and saw 12. I obviously may have missed one, but either way, I think we're at majority.

 

[Ace Marvel]

22/2 = 11 + 1 = 12

 

[John McHenry]

I skimmed through the posts starting with Grim's count (2:08 EST), and saw 12. I obviously may have missed one, but either way, I think we're at majority.

SA voted Sayer I believe Grim had it as sayer and not holt?

 

[Ekkologix]

The PGO role seems like the perfect fake if you manage to not get lynched then. Town won't visit you in fear of being shot, and if someone accuses you of a killing you could always say that you might have been visited and the shot went off. If someone tells me Desperado + PGO role is a common thing in games I'll rethink my vote, but for now I'll

Vote Lynch Holt

i dont like that he found it necessary to attach this reasoning here with the vote

also oneiros lots of ur posts have this "i'll rethink" or "i'll look back" and its getting too repetitive for my liking

 

[RDK]

i dont like that he found it necessary to attach this reasoning here with the vote

also oneiros lots of ur posts have this "i'll rethink" or "i'll look back" and its getting too repetitive for my liking

Too showy?

 

[Ekkologix]

Doddsy looks horrible around Holt regardless of flip IMO, don't really buy his defense of him at all as being genuine

tell me more about this i must've missed it

 

[Ekkologix]

Okay I been thinking.

Holt needs to die.
There will always be paranoia around him, and if it’s town mafia will never kill there.
Then if Tweet in some bizarre scenario is telling the truth or even if mafia has a role that can make people visit someone. Mafia has an extra kill with Holt, they will just force a villa to visit.
And finally Holt said he is a low poster and has been confusing players, generally thats not the worst thing in the world, but if he survives and doesn’t get more involved, is troublesome for town in the long run.

if he is just mafia then, we just killed mafia. Simple

yeah he has to go or the game cannot properly progress forward as he will remain suspected forever lol

 

[RDK]

tell me more about this i must've missed it

He came out and defended Holt by basically saying sometimes he forces reads as town when pressed just to get people off his back. Which is fair and well but it's also diluting the actual reasons Holt is being lynched so it doesn't really work as a defense

 

[John McHenry]

Vote Count:

Marvel (2) - TP, Doddsy
Holt (11) - Poyser, RD, Marvel, Ekko, McHenry, Lethal, Wang, Oneiros, Mando, Sister, Haza
SA (1) - Sayer

Duel Count:

Baldrick (12) - Ekko, Poyser, RD, Man, Nom, RDK, Tommy, Sister, Wang, Lethal, Doddsy, OldJay
Tweet (3) - Holt, McHenry, WorstPlayerEver

12 to lynch

This is the post I was refferring too. Sayer is actually voting for Holt. Phoenix ended up voting holt. Which is why I got my 13 but I'm just adding to Lethals list. Not an official list

 

[Ekkologix]

I forgot he mafia vibed oldjay too who hadn’t made any game related posts at that point lmao

oldjay can be scum too

 

[Ekkologix]

22/2 = 11 + 1 = 12

we shud put more votes in case of vote silences or w.e

 

[Ace Marvel]

we shud put more votes in case of vote silences or w.e

I honestly think is just Barry not being around lol.
I'm already voting.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

This is the post I was refferring too. Sayer is actually voting for Holt. Phoenix ended up voting holt. Which is why I got my 13 but I'm just adding to Lethals list. Not an official list

"Sayer is actually voting for Holt."

Sayer=Holt, no?

 

[Ace Marvel]

"Sayer is actually voting for Holt."

Sayer=Holt, no?

Yes I think, Holt is voting Sister Abigail