GFX League Trial Card: Ryan vs. Andy vs. BDC

[Andy]

Ryan's Submission:

Andy's Submission:

BDC's Submission:

For the time being, we won't operate using scoring, especially since this is a trial match, but it may be incorporated if we get the actual league going.

At this time, just post which gets your vote and comment as to why it gets your vote; essentially, Rate/Hate & vote.

No Flaming!
​

 

[Gotcha b*tch]

I vote for BDC. I think all the images of the people are positioned nicely. It's a little rough around the edges, for example Heath Slater's leg ends abruptly but overall I like it.

 

[BDC]

Yeah, I JUST noticed that and Kaval has a white aura. I had erased all the others like that...thanks, man.

 

[Ryan]

Good luck guys.

 

[Prodigy]

I vote with Ryan. Sig looks the most proffesional, no offence to the others but I think his is the most appealing.

 

[Vivido]

I'll give my vote to Ryan, pretty solid sig, the other two are good also, although I find the PWA one a little boring, just a whole lot of guys slapped on there around some words. My vote would of gone to Andy but I find the txt pretty hard on the eyes, in saying that it could be due to my very poor eyesite, but yeah that killed it for me.

 

[Andrew]

Picking Andy here.

 

[Heisenberg]

I'm picking Ryan here, it has a good style to it although I'm not really a fan of the colors used but oh well I guess it works.

 

[The_King]

This one's between Andy and Ryan for me.
Ryan: It's pretty good. A bit too 'flowery' for my taste lol, but it works. For the most part, it flows well. The effects work, and it has a fitting mood. Only problems I have are the boring font choice, and that the center image seems to get "swallowed" by all the colors and effects. Probably give it around a 7.8. Good work!
BDC: Just not a fan, sorry! The logo needs an outline of some sort, and the forever text just doesn't work. I'd suggest going for more consisent lighting on all the PSDs and being very careful with placement (Slater's leg hanging, The Joker's chest being exposed, DH Smith's leg). Decent banner!
Andy: Already told you my thoughts. Good work. Probs give it a 7.3.

My vote goes to Ryan.

 

[Defiant]

Ryan - I could have liked this but I thik you went overboard. The colours are uncomfortably strong and the middle area looks clustered. That said, You've done a great job at greating a flow with the render positioning.

Andy - I'll get the negatives out of the way. There's a bit too much red, there's no lighting or depth where there really should have been, the size is akward and the text is so big that it clutters with the render. That said, you took a risk doing the mirror-background thing but I really like how it turned out. It creates a nice flow that enhances the render. The size is my only real complaint, but this is probably the easiest on the eyes out of the 3.

BDC - I'm not really sure what you were going for here. Nothing really works for me and I just don't have anything to say about it.

My vote goes to Andy

 

[PHX]

Andy takes this imo as I just think it is the best one out of these overall. Not really a fan of the BDC one just too much going on in it to dig it and Ryan's I kind of agree with Defiant as it has potenital but seems kind of cluttered.

 

[Deuce]

My vote goes to Andy.