General Chit-Chat Thread - No Spoilers

[Dirk Dickbutt]

KIF is not more valid than Meltzer

 

[Kiffy Lube]

You probably have them at 7 stars

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

5.25 Stars from WM 26

 

[Hosferatu]

5.25 out of what?

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

Okada vs Omega at WK 17 {I think} only get's a 4 Star for me

 

[Brandon]

78

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

I use the outta 5 star rating

 

[Hosferatu]

Something cannot be 5.25/5, it literally defeats the purpose of the scale

 

[Chris]

I have both those Taker/HBK Mania matches at ****3/4

So does Papa Dave

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

Meltzer gave Kenny Omega 5 5+ Star Matches

 

[Kiffy Lube]

None of their matches are better than Funk/Flair I Quit Match

 

[Hosferatu]

Metlzer invalidated decades worth of his own star ratings by breaking the scale

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

I think I can make an exception for HBK/Taker

 

[Deezy]

I don't have a scale, either I like it or I don't

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Chris, Dave and I may agree on those two but we differ in a lot of other shit