General Chit-Chat Thread: A New Beginning

[Chris]

I justified it as "yeah Arthur wouldnt see it as a high priority, it's a risk and it's just Micah"

 

[Grim]

Red Dead Revolver is Canon to the series, and yes, Red Harlow is Gramps.

Actually it's already been confirmed that Revolver is Canon to the other games cuz you do discover Red's childhood home in RDR2

 

[Chris]

Oh I don't agree about the uncle theory or at least that sounds crazy to me rn but yeah I see no reason it can't be canon

 

[Chris]

Actually it's already been confirmed that Revolver is Canon to the other games cuz you do discover Red's childhood home in RDR2

I agree with this too, they say "no it was just an Easter egg" and people say red's home was farther West but that was 20 years before revolver so it's logical red went west after

 

[Chris]

I don't like that rockstar themselves tries to say that era isn't canon when there's no logical reason it can't be lol it's not like they're saying it so they can ignore canon for storylines, it literally all fits still

 

[Grim]

Oh I don't agree about the uncle theory or at least that sounds crazy to me rn but yeah I see no reason it can't be canon

I buy into the theory largely because Uncle A. Keeps a cloth around his hand, which Red did too because it's burned and scarred, and B.) Uncle is one of the only characters who not only talks shit to Dutch to his face, but doesn't back down when Dutch threatens him, meaning Uncle probably knows that Dutch sees him as a threat too.

 

[Chris]

Man that's just a sad end for Red tho

 

[Chris]

I'll give you that we don't know his name so it's not like I can say no for sure lol

 

[Chris]

I don't want Red to die from Lumbago on John's porch man

 

[Chris]

So i don't subscribe

 

[Grim]

Yeah if Red actually is Uncle he at least lived a good life

 

[Chris]

Do you know the story of 2 or have you not finished?

 

[Chris]

Bc personally anyone that lived through that it's hard for me to say they had a good life, his life after with John at least mostly was

 

[Chris]

Man I'm just thinking back to like the chapter 2 and 3 camps when everyone was so happy and what becomes of them all

 

[Grim]

What's crazy too is that Revolver takes place in the 1860s, while Jack Marston is an adult by the late 1910s. Since Jack is Canon in the GTA universe (being referenced in V), it means we have a straight universe that runs from the 1860s all the way to the modern day