Extreme Rules 2021 Poster (Poll)

[PeepShow]

Please vote on which poster you like more. Voting will remain open for a full week. The winner can choose the next battle topic if they wish to do so.

The Fourth Wall

PeepShow

 

[Chris]

This is tough, such different concepts leaning towards Peep, I like how e everything fits inside the X over the while poster like that and how the demon is in it but regular Finn on the outside

 

[RDK]

Pretty close in fairness.

Text let TFW down I think seems oddly placed and no attempt was really made the blend in the ER render. I do really like the poster though and the business actually is appealing to me but maybe feels more like a summerslam poster? I wouldn't mark you down for that though.

For peepshow I prefer the text and actually think it's the best part of the design. Though I'd have lost the head of the table and balor club logos, don't think they were necessary. I'm really attracted to the center of this poster but the rest feels kinda bland to me and I wonder if thats the darkness/grunginess of it. The superstar renders just aren't appealing to me even if they fit with the flow of the design quite nicely.

I'm voting TFW by a shade here. I think both are pretty good work but one just appeals to me more aesthetically.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Great work Peep. I like your text choice and logo blending. I agree with Haza about mine just being slapped on basically, it's always the hardest part for me, so it's good you have that nailed down. I think it looks good. This was fun, but I would have loved to see more people trying their hand at it, always time for that in the future

 

[PeepShow]

Though I'd have lost the head of the table and balor club logos, don't think they were necessary

Yeah, I added those in last minute. That area just looked too empty and wanted something there. Ended up hurting in the end. Oh well, you live and learn

Thanks for the feedback.

 

[RDK]

Yeah, I added those in last minute. That area just looked too empty and wanted something there. Ended up hurting in the end. Oh well, you live and learn

Thanks for the feedback.

I wonder if it would have looked better if you had copied the blending options you used on the Roman and demon fin renders that are purple on the X, may have looked a little more balanced and overcluttered if they were subtler like that

 

[PeepShow]

About 36 more hours to vote. Lets get more than 6 votes on this!