Sorry man, everything seems wrong with this one.
The main PSD is an average choice (though I havent seen any other choices so...) and he effects on it dont look too good. The lighting around his face and darkness around his body seems very weird.
The bg, and bg pics are bad, imo. The bg itself really ruins it though, it doesnt seem to suit Dusty Rhodes. It looks like you have embossed (?) a pic of Dusty on the left, and that looks shocking. Then the consistency of the sig is ruined as you have a normal picture of him on the right, just blended into the pic. It doesnt look that good having two different types of bg pics, if you know what Im trying to say.
The small quote and "bar" at the bottom looks rather nice, though I think a plain bg wouldve worked better than a gradient into that brown colour.
Sorry again man, you do some nice work, but this is definetly closest to the bottom of the list.