Dream Wrestlemania Card Contest

[Travis40]

It's like an Ironman match but the only way to recieve points is by submission, ive seen it done before during the Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit feud in 2001.

I remember that match, wasn't it at Backlash?

 

[The Rated R CMStar]

Yeah, I mean the "Slobber Knocker" tag you add to it. I know very well the concept of the match, and I am pretty sure it doesn't have that tag on it

 

[seX-Power]

^ Shameless self hype ftw.

 

[The Leviathan]

I just noticed that among us, only Rose put Brock Lesnar in a card lol....

 

[Kaedon]

Matt Hardy vs. Jeff Hardy - Dog Collar Match
Rey Mysterio/CM Punk/Eddie Guerrero/AJ Styles/Chris Jericho/Evan Bourne - MITB Ladder Match
Sting vs. The Undertaker - Career/Streak Match
John Cena vs. The Rock
Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle - Ironman Match
HBK vs. Samoa Joe
Steve Austin vs. Hulk Hogan
Demolition vs. The Colons vs. The British Bulldogs
Brock Lesnar vs. Ed Lewis
HHH vs. Harley Race
Steve Austin vs. Hulk Hogan

 

[straight_edge76]

WWE Championship Match
Steel Cage Match
Steve Austin (C) VS Randy Orton

Submssion Match
Bret Hart VS Sting

Fatal 4 Way Match- Who Is Mr. Wrestlemania?
Shawn Michaels VS The Undertaker VS Hulk Hogan VS The Rock

Intercontinental Championship Match
Chris Jericho (C) VS CM Punk

Clash of the Champions
Triple H VS Ric Flair

Tag Team Championship Match
Tables, Ladders & Chairs Match
The Dudley Boyz VS The Hardy Boyz

Last Man Standing Match
Batista VS Goldberg

nWo VS D-Generation X
The Outsiders VS The New Age Outlaws

Brother VS Brother
Edge VS Christian

 

[Montana]

Last day to submit....

I dont know about everyone....But I've enjoyed this thread seeing some matchups i've never thought of and different scenarios.

 

[CenaMark54]

WWE Championship Match
Hulk Hogan vs Steve Austin

World Heavyweight Championship
John Cena vs Andre the Giant

Intercontinental Championship
Bret Hart vs Randy Savage

60 min Iron Man Match
Ric Flair vs Shawn Michaels

Legend vs Legend Killer
Randy Orton vs The Rock

Money in the Bank Ladder Match
Mic Foley vs Edge vs Christian vs RVD vs Shelton Benjamin vs Jeff Hardy vs Eddie Guerrero vs Chris Jericho

Hell in a Cell
Triple H vs Killer Kowalski

WWE Tag Team Championship
The Undertaker and Kane vs Ted DiBiase and Roddy Piper

 

[Montana]

Alright folks, here are my own personel ratings...I added everything in my made, so i might have made a error for some points, however probably should be right for everyone. Some people got points taken away for not following the rules. There were a few people with more than 4 stipulations, and more than 1 multiman match. Like i said before, i took a lot into account. Match positioning, WM legacy, just about anything you could think of. The main events were were 20 points, every other match was 10 points. Which gives a maximum of 100. (which no one got) And i don't even know if a 100 is possible. Moonlight Drive won...I thought his Legends Battle Royal put him over the top. Instead of have some 2nd/3rd tier legends battle it out, he threw them all in a WM traditional Battle Royal. Good call

1) Moonlight Drive- 96/100
2) Rated CMS 94
3) Kaedon 91
3) CenaMark 91
3) Travis40 91

Xtremebadass 90
CT Styles 90
Leviathan 90

Edgehead 89
Next Big Thing 89

Airfixx 88
Mike Raw 88
Qwake 88

Matthardy 87
Straightedge76 85
Newmie 84
Peepshow 84
RoseW - 81
C4 - 81
Sex-power- 80
Evil AUstin 79
JimmyD 77
Hibee WWE Fan 69​

Jimmy D

WWE Championship Match
Goldberg vs Steve Austin

I’m not so sure I want Goldberg in my main event at WM. Remember Goldberg vs Brock (14/20)

Casket Match
Ric Flair vs The Undertaker
Would be a fun match (8/10)

I Quit Match
The Rock vs Sting

Can’t beat this 10/10

Bret Hart vs Kurt Angle vs Ted DiBiase

8/10 …Hmmm, Dibiase in there too huh?

Intercontinental Title Match
Ricky Steamboat vs Shawn Michaels

9/10…Probably could have used HBK a little better.

World Tag Team Titles Match
Tables, Ladders & Chairs!
The Legion of Doom vs The Hardy Boyz

9/10 …Doesn’t get much better than this for tag matches.

Hulk Hogan vs Harley Race

5/10 …Why Harley Race?

Big Show vs Andre The Giant (The match would suck, but it'd be worth it)

7/10 Biggest match ever!

Sabu & RVD vs Rey Mysterio Jr & Billy Kidman
7/10
Overall 77/100



Hibee WWE Fan

Old Reunion Old School Hardcore Match
Rob Van Dam and Sabu vs Dudley Boyz
9/10 I like…this could be good


WWE Tag Team Championship
Motor City Machineguns vs The Rockers with Kevin Nash

8/10… Solid, but why add Nash to the Rockers?

Street Fight
Shane McMahon vs Cactus Jack
4/10 …Shane O mac is not a legend or great in my book.

Intercontinental Championship
MVP vs Kaz

3/10 …. Anyone….you could have choose anyone, and you picked MVP and Kaz.

Elimination Chamber
HHH vs Randy Orton vs Kane vs Kurt Angle vs Hulk Hogan vs Booker T
8/10 …. I don’t see the purpose of this, but good.

Ladder Match
Edge and Christian vs Hardy Boyz
7/10 …seen this at mania a few times before.


Old Fued Again
Stone Cold Steve Austin vs The Rock

7/10 …again, we’ve seen this. This is a dream/fantasy card. Use some creativity.

WWE CHampionship
Hulk Hogan vs John Cena
9/10 – I like

Match of a lifetime/Loser Retires
Sting w/ Ric Flair vs Undertaker
17/20 …Not sure why Flair is in there with Sting. I probably would have went with Cena/Hogan last. Still a good pick.

MINUS 5 points for 5 stipulation matches (Loses Leaves is a stip)
69/100


XtremeBadass

WWE Championship
“Stone Cold†Steve Austin © vs. John Cena
18/20 ….Doesnt get much better. However would Cena be as over in the Austin Era?

Intercontinental Championship
Ricky Steamboat © vs. Chris Jericho
10/10 ….Fine Matchup

World Tag Team Championship
Hardy Boyz © vs. Dudley Boyz vs. Legion of Doom vs. The British Bulldogs

9/10 …. 4 of the best, no complaints

Submission Match
Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle

10/10 Yes. I love Submission matches.

“Undefeated Streak gets taken to the Extremeâ€
Hardcore Match
Undertaker vs. Mick Foley
8/10 …I like the match, however we’ve seen Taker/Foley lots of times.

“Mr. WrestleMania†vs. “Mr. Hollywoodâ€
Grudge Match
Shawn Michaels vs. The Rock

10/10 Ding Ding Ding… I also like the Mr WM vs MR Hollywood.

“Evolution Erruptionâ€
Tag Team Match
Triple H and Ric Flair vs. Batista and Randy Orton
10/10 Nice use of the tag match

Money in the Bank Ladder Match
Rob Van Dam vs. Edge vs. Shelton Benjamin vs. Rey Mysterio vs. Christian vs. Razor Ramon vs. CM Punk vs. Mr. Perfect


10/10 Great match

“Size vs. Dominanceâ€
Grudge Match
Big Show vs. Goldberg
7/10

MINUS 3 points for 2 multiman matches (MITB, and 4 way tag match)
89/100

Mike Raw
WWE Championship:
Hulk Hogan vs Triple H
17/20 … Good match, however I don’t consider HHH on the same level as Hogan.

Triple Threat Match:
John Cena vs The Rock vs "Stone Cold" Steve Austin
10/10 Wow, this would be nuts

60 Minute Iron Man Match:
Kurt Angle vs The Undertaker
9/10 I don’t know if the Undertaker can go 60 good minutes

Singles Match:
Shawn Michaels vs Ricky Steamboat
9/10 Good stuff, although HBK could probably be used in a bigger match.

Extreme Rules Match:
Rob Van Dam vs Edge

10/10 Nice match. I think these two would well together.

Intercontinental Championship Match:
John "Bradshaw" Layfield vs "Million Dollar Man" Ted Dibiase

8/10 I like it, but I question JBL’s overall value

Singles Match:
Harley Race vs Ric Flair

7/10 …classic match, but not sure this would up the ante for WM.

Tag Team Match:
The Hardyz Boyz (Jeff and Matt) vs The Hart Foundation (Bret and Jim)

10/10, two of the best tag teams ever. I think this would be a good mix of styles.

Steel Cage Match:
William Regal vs Jerry "The King" Lawler[/
8/10…This could work.

88/100

Sex-power

WWE Championship- Ironman Match
Eddie Guerrero vs Chris Benoit

14/20….Neither of these were really big names, so from a drawing prespective, this main event doesn’t stack up well.


Intercontinental Championship
Chris Jericho vs Hulk Hogan
7/10 …Hogan and the Intercontinental Championship?!?


WWE Tag Team Championship
The Dudleyz vs The Legion of Doom
9/10 two of the best tag teams ever, however would this be a great match?


Women's Championship
Trish Stratus vs Lita vs Mickie James vs Beth Phoenix

7/10 filler

Money In The Bank Ladder Match
Razor Ramon vs Shawn Michaels vs Edge vs Christian vs Jeff Hardy vs Matt Hardy vs Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair

9/10 ….why is ric flair in here?

Grudge Match
The Undertaker vs Sting
10/10 , this would be a big money match.


Hardcore Match
Cactus Jack vs Terry Funk

7/10…its alright, Terry Funk isn’t much of a draw.

Grudge Match
John Cena vs Andre the Giant

9/10 works for me.

Grudge Match- 3 Stages of Hell
The Rock vs Stone Cold Steve Austin
8/10….we’ve already seen this 3 times at mania.

80/100…I think match positioning hurt you here.

RatedCMS
WWE Championship/B]
Edge w/Lita vs Randy Savage w/ Mrs. Elizabeth

18/20…This could work, Savage is the face I’m assuming? I question Edge’s drawing ability as well.


"Kill" the Legend
Randy Orton vs Stone Cold

10/10 , Kill the legend, I like.

"Respect" the Legend
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan

10/10 I like the theme on this one as well. This would be epic.

Finally, Rock has come back to do the one he never has done...end the Streak
The Rock vs The Undertaker

10/10 interesting.

Submission Match
Kurt Angle vs Bret Hart

10/10, you can’t pass up on this match. Especially a I quit match.

The Match that wasn't meant to happen...
No Holds Barred
DX vs nWo
Triple H and Shawn Michaels vs Scott Hall and Kevin Nash

10/10 This fued could have been epic.
WWE Tag Team Championship

Tables, Ladders and Chairs...Oh My!
Miz and Morrison (c) vs Hardy Boyz vs Dudley Boyz vs Chris Jericho and Christian

9/10 Jericho + Christian? I didn’t they teamed very much.

IC Title Match
Rey Mysterio (c) vs Eddie Guerrero

9/10, This would be a good match

CM Punk vs Chris Benoit
8/10 real good match, but seems like a minor let down from the previous matches.

94/100 Real good score. Only used 3 stipulations. I would imagine this would be tough to beat.

PeepShow

1. Money In The Bank Ladder Match:
Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart vs. Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon vs. Jimmy Snuka vs. Ricky Steamboat vs. Eddie Guererro vs. Chris Benoit

10/10 …Nice mix of wrestlers.

2. Intercontinental Title Match:
Chris Jericho (c) vs. Mr. Perfect

9/10…Interesting…I’m assuming your using Jericho as the face, coming in the belt.

3. Classic Legends Tag Match:
Ric Flair and Roddy Piper vs. Randy Savage and Dusty Rhodes

10/10 cool tag match

4. Hardcore Title Match:
Mankind (c) vs. Raven

7/10 Raven????

5. The Icon vs. The Deadman:
Sting vs. The Undertaker

10/10

6. Tag Team Title Match (TLC):
Edge and Christian (c) vs.The Dudley Boyz vs. The Hardy Boyz

8/10

7. Battle of the Giants:
Andre The Giant vs. The Big Show

8/10

8. Fatal 4 Way "Attitude Era" Match:
Stone Cold vs. The Rock vs. Triple H vs. Kurt Angle

10/10

9. WWE Title match
Hulk Hogan (c) vs. John Cena

18/10

Minus 6 points for 3 multiman matches

84/100

MattHardy

WWE Championship: Stone Cold Steve Austin vs The Rock

16/20 ….we’ve seen this 3 times before at Mania.

Intercontenential Title: Randy Savage vs Randy Orton

10/10…This would be a fun fued to see.

nWo vs DX: Triple H and Shawn Michaels vs Scott Hall and Kevin Nash

10/10…. Fun matchup

Hulk Hogan vs Bret Hart w/ Ric Flair Guest Ref

10/10…one of those matches you wished happened back in the day.

Hell in a Cell: The Undertaker vs Sting

10/10

Hardy Boyz vs Dudley Boyz vs Edge and Christian vs RVD and Sabu: TLC Match for Tag titles.

9/10 …RVD + Sabu 

Big Show vs Bam Bam Bigelow

7/10 … Hmmm, idk how good of a match they would have.

Shane McMahon vs Mick Foley Hardcore Rules

6/10…Ughhh Shane o Mac.

Chris Jericho and Kurt Angle vs Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit

9/10 Decent…would be a great wrestling match.

87/100… some real matches, and a couple duds (to my taste)


Travis40

Opener
Rey Mysterio vs. Ricky Steamboat

9/10 …two of the biggest faces ever. So there would need to be a title on the line here to make it a ten.

Tag Team Championships
Edge and Christian vs. Dudleyz

8/10 Average…could have used a stipulation to make this sound a little better.

Money in the Bank Ladder Match
Randy Savage vs. Eddie Guerrero vs. Scott Hall vs. Jimmy Snuka vs. Shawn Michaels vs. RVD

10/10 …Lots of Snuka love around here.

Last Man Standing
Andre the Giant vs. Undertaker

8/10 …. Would be a slow, but good match.

IC Championship
Mr. Perfect vs. Owen Hart

8/10 …doesn’t scream special, but good.

Submission Match
Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle

10/10 Awesome.

The Rock vs. Ric Flair

9/10 …The buildup would be incredible…idk how well Rock and Flair’s chemistry would be. Rock isn’t much of a mat wrestler.

Steel Cage Match
Ultimate Warrior vs. Randy Orton

9/10 ….Hmmm I like it, not sure why.

Main Event
WWE Championship
Hulk Hogan vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin

20/20…The two biggest icons ever.

91/100



Moonlight Drive

WWE Championship
Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Hulk Hogan (c)

20/20

John Cena vs The Rock

10/10 …Today’s modern day dream match

Three Stages Of Hell - First Fall: Singles, Second Fall: Steel Cage, Third Fall: I Quit
Shawn Michaels vs Bret Hart

10/10 this would be nuts.

Legend vs Legend Killer
Randy Orton vs Randy Savage

10/10 these guys would have a great fued.

Hell in a Cell
Undertaker vs Mick Foley

9/10 ….HIAC II…interesting

WCW Cruiserweight Revival
Chris Jericho & Chris Benoit vs Eddie Guerrero & Rey Mysterio

9/10 Jericho and Benoit on a team?

WWE Tag Team Championship
E & C (c) vs The Road Warriors

8/10 two tag matches in a row.

The Ultimate Challenge Part II
Intercontinental Championship
The Ultimate Warrior (c) vs Batista

10/10

Legends 20-Man Battle Royal
Ricky Steamboat vs Iron Sheik vs Sting vs Kurt Angle vs Bruno Sammartino vs Jimmy Snuka vs Roddy Piper vs Andre the Giant vs Dusty Rhodes vs Mr. Perfect vs Owen Hart vs Terry Funk vs Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair vs Big Show vs Harley Race vs Jake The Snake vs Ted DiBiase vs Rick Rude vs Davey Boy Smith

10/10

96/100 …Impressive card. Doesn’t get much better imo.


C4

Main Event WWE Championship
The Undertaker vs. Triple H (c) vs. The Rock


17/20…Good match…never been too fond of triple threat main events

Steel Cage
Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Shawn Michaels

10/10….Nice use of stipulation.

Battle of the ages-
Hulk Hogan vs. Ric Flair

10/10 ….Icon vs Icon….historic match here

John Cena and Shane McMahon vs. Randy Orton and Jeff Jarrett

6/10 nooooo. Seems a far fetched.

Christian Cage w/ Mr.McMahon vs. Edge w/ Eric Bischoff

9/10, not sure if this needs Vince/Eric.


Four way TLC Tag Team Championships
Mankind and Terry Funk
The Dudley Boyz
Tommy Dreamer and the Sandman
John Morrison and The Miz

7/10 …Ehh, Sandman, Terry Funk, where’s Sabu/RVD

Money in the Bank
Jeff Hardy vs. Bret Hart vs. AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle vs. Ultimate Warrior vs. Rey Mysterio.

8/10 Another multiman man? Why is the Warrior in a ladder match?

Minus 6 for 3 multi man matches

81/100



Next Big Thing

WWE Championship
Hulk Hogan vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin

20/20 Big main event

Intercontinental Championship
Mr. Perfect vs. Chris Benoit

9/10 should be a fine mat wrestling match

Tag Team championship
Road Warriors vs. The Steiner Brothers

9/10 two of the best tag teams, I don’t think there’s been a good matchup between these two. Only a DQ one/Flaky finish short match. ( At least that I remember)

The Rock vs. John Cena

10/10

Shawn Michaels vs. Randy Savage

10/10

Ricky Steamboat vs. Bret Hart

9/10…Good wrestling match

The Ultimate Warrior vs. Sting

8/10….former tag partners collide.

Chris Jericho vs. Jake the Snake Roberts

6/10 ….. too much of the same. Singles match after singles match. No stips.

89/100 ….real good score, but could have used some stips, and something to make these matches mean more. A little more on the creative side.


Qwake


WWE Championship
Stone Cold Vs HHH

17/20…It’s too bad we never got this match at mania. I feel HHH never properly was established because of a lack of major singles matches from WM 15-20.

Rock's Comeback
Chris Jericho Vs The Rock

8/10 …We’ve already seen Rock/Jericho a few times before.

Tag Team Championships - TLC Match
Hardy Boyz Vs E & C

9/10 Seen it before.

Last Man Standing
Shawn Michaels Vs The Undertaker

9/10 Good use of stipulations, but we’ve already seen this match too.

Money in the Bank
Booker T Vs Eddie Guerrero Vs Rob Van Dam Vs Kurt Angle Vs Chris Benoit Vs Rey Mysterio

8/10 two ladder matches on one card? That’s against the bookers rules.

2/3 falls - Legend Vs Legend Killer
Bret Hart Vs Randy Orton

10/10 two out of three falls…I like.

Special Attraction
Hulk Hogan Vs Ric Flair

10/10

IC Title Match
Mr Perfect Vs Owen Hart

7/10

88/100….Played it safe. Could have used some more original matches.


RoseW

WWE Championship:
Randy Orton Vs Brock Lesnar

15/20…. Not that big of a draw. Maybe if it was like WWE title vs UFC title.

World Heavyweight Championship - Hell In A Cell - Loser Retires:
Undertaker Vs HBK

9/10 Not so sure I want either guy to retire.

The Rock Vs John Cena

10/10

IC Championship:
Kurt Angle Vs Sting

8/10 interesting call here. We’ve seen this a few times in TNA.

HHH Vs Ric Flair

9/10 student vs. teacher. Good stuff.

Tag Team Championship:
Jeff and Matt Hardy Vs Edge and Christian

8/10 …no stip?

Goldberg Vs Hulk Hogan

6/10 Goldberg??!??

Hardcore:
Mick Foley Vs Sabu

8/10 ….This could be a good match, although Idk how good the foley/sabu chemistry would be. That’s why this isn’t higher.

Batista Vs Eddie Vs Chris Benoit

8/10 …seems random.


81/100 …..a couple small tweaks and this could have been a lil better.


Edgehead

Intercontinental Championship
Angle vs. Benoit vs. Eddy G. vs. Brian Danielson - 30 minute ironman

10/10

Tag Team Championship
Briscoes vs. Motor City Machine Guns -

8/10…Would be a great match, however neither team has really established themselves in the big leagues.

WWE Championship
Shawn Michaels vs. Triple H

19/20 ….odd placement of the title match. Good Friends, better enemies.

Undertaker vs. Cena

9/10 …would be better if Cena never lost at Mania.

Dudleys vs. Hardy Boys – TLC

9/10 safe bet.

World Championship
Edge vs. Randy Orton

8/10 decent matchup

Rock vs. Stone Cold - No Holds Barred

9/10 Nice use of stip.

Ric Flair vs. Sting
10/10


Bret Hart vs. British Bulldog

7/10 odd pick for WM.

89/100 Pretty solid card.



Airfixx

Hell In A Cell: All or nothing retirement match for the vacant WWE Championship featuring the tournament finalists...

Undertaker Vs Stone Cold Steve Austin [35min]

20/20 …Interesting, as a booker it might not be a smart idea, but huge match none the less.


Team Team Championship handicap match:

Degeneration-X. (HBK & HHH) w/New Age Outlaws & Chyna Vs
N.W.O. (c) (Hogan,Hall & Nash) w/Syxx & Eric Bischoff [45min]

9/10 Not sure if he needed to be handicap with everyone at ringside.

Grudge Match(*): ‘The Peoples Champ’ Vs ‘The Dr. Of Thuganomics’

The Rock Vs John Cena [20min]

10/10

4-Way elimination submission match:

Kurt Angle Vs Chris Benoit Vs Bret Hart Vs William Regal [40min]

10/10

DDT vs RKO challenge (Victory can only be gained by means of the wrestler's respective finnisher):

Jake ‘The Snake’ Roberts Vs. Randy Orton [15min]

8/10 …I guess this could be good, however not sure these guys are both worthy of a spot here.

Battle Of The Bling:

'Nature Boy' Ric Flair vs ‘The Million Dollar Man’ Ted Dibiase [15min]

9/10 …Battle of the Bling….Whooooo

2/3 Falls: Intercontinental Championship match:

Randy Savage Vs Mr. Perfect (c) [35min]

8/10 …For some odd reason I don’t think these guys would have as good as chemistry as one would think. I guess I don’t see savage as a real mat technician


Bam Bam Bigelow & Big Van Vader Vs The British Bulldogs [15min]

8/10 I’m glad someone used Vader, however I don’t recall Vader in tag teams very much.


Chris Jericho Vs Ricky Steamboat [20min]

9/10

Minus three for too many stipulations.

88/100 …Pretty solid card. You were going strong until the bottom couple matches. I think Snake vs Orton could have been a good opener.

CT Styles


WWE Championship
Shawn Michaels vs. Ric Flair

18/20 …don’t get me wrong. This would have been big…however Flair vs HBK doesn’t exactly jump out at ya.

John Cena vs. Hulk Hogan

10/10 Superman vs Superman

Randy Orton vs. The Rock
9/10 .. Good matchup, maybe could have used a stip to spice this up a little.

WWE Tag Team Championship
TLC Match
The Hardy Boyz vs. Edge and Christian

9/10 Solid stuff.

Intercontinental Championship
Chris Jericho vs. Owen Hart

8/10 I like it, but feels a little average.

Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle vs. Chris Benoit
9/10…it would be good, but benoit isn’t really needed.

Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero
8/10 a good match for WM to showcase, however idk about on a dream card.

Street Fight
Vince McMahon vs. Bret Hart

10/10 Yes…that’s awesome

'Stone Cold' Steve Austin vs. The Undertaker

9/10….I’m giving this a 9 out of 10 because one of these guys has to lose. Sure Austin would lose, but I don’t think Austin should lose at mania unless it’s a Huge match.

90/100 ….Good card. The card was simple, but worked. I think using the four stipulations could have made it a little better.


Leviathan

WWE Championship - Anything Goes
Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Rock

17/20 …Good, but we’ve already seen it 3 times at mania, probably could have put these guys in fresh matchups we’ve never seen before.

Sting vs. Shawn Michaels

10/10 …Nice…I was using this match in Beer’s booking contest as my main event of sorts. Or that big match under the main event. My story was Sting brought the NWA championship to the WWE, and traded it in for a title shot. (it’s a long story)

Intercontinental Championship - Fatal Four Way
Randy Orton vs. Razor Ramon vs. Ricky "the Dragon" Steamboat vs. Mr. Perfect

10/10 Good stuff.

Bret Hart vs. Edge

8/10…Good, but I could see this being a average match. It wouldn’t stick out with the other matches on the dream card.

Submission Match:
Ric Flair vs. Kurt Angle

10/10

Million Dollar Championship

Ted Dibiase vs. Triple H
10/10 , Nice use of a “Other†historic belt. Surprised no one else used it. The Min/Max and other stuff was actually there to help.

John Cena and Batista vs. Ultimate Warrior and Hulk Hogan

7/10….Idk. Last time Warrior was booked in a tag match he held up the company for more money. I don’t think Hogan/Warrior are on that good of terms. I just these matches would have been better in singles.

Casket Match
The Undertaker vs. Roddy Piper

8/10 Roddy piper is like a WM jobber to me. He’s not, but he’s never really been full time enough for a BIG match, past like WM 3.

Hardcore Match
Jeff Hardy vs. Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka

10/10 …that would be a cool match.

90/100 Good card, I think the dream tag match hurt you a little bit though.


Evil Austin

WWE Championship match
Triple H vs. Rick Flair

17/20 …you lose points for spelling ric flair wrong.

Shawn Michaels vs. Sting

10/10
John Cena vs. Ultimate Warrior
8/10…Not that I think Warrior would have chemistry with many, I certainly don’t think he would with Cena.

The Rock vs. Bret Hart
10/10

Tag Team Championships
Leigen of Doom vs. Brothers of Destruction.
9/10 Interesting match, I like.

Chris Jericho vs. Rob Van Dam

8/10 two of my favorites and a damn good match, but this wouldn’t stand out on a dream card.

Owen Hart vs. Eddie Guerrero
8/10 again big match, but it wouldn’t really stand out.

Intercontinental Championship matchup
Ultimate Submission Slobber Knocker match
Chris Benoit vs. Mr. Perfect

7/10 Lame name. Perfect wasn’t a big submission wrestler either.

Kane vs. Vader

0/10 you can’t have the same guy wrestle twice….

79/100….Kane booked twice hurt the card. Plus a few “average†matches that needed some spicing up.


Newmie

Andre The Giant vs. The Big Show

8/10 some might like.

Tag Team Match:
Legion of Doom vs. The Steiner Brothers

8/10….not for the tag titles?

TLC Tag Team Title Gauntlet Match (Basically, the first 5 matches are decided by pinfall, with the use of Tables ladders and Chairs allowed, and the sixth and final decider is a Ladder Match with the Tag Titles hanging above the ring):
The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz vs. Edge and Christian vs. The New Age Outlaws vs. Kane and Rob Van Dam vs. Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio vs. Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit

9/10 …never been a big fan of gauntlet matches.

Submission Match:
Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle

10/10

The Rock vs. Randy Orton

9/10 Only cause I think there are slightly better dream matches the rock could be in.

60 Minute Iron Man Match:
Owen Hart vs. Shawn Michaels

6/10 Why is there a 60 minute iron man match in the middle of the show. The fans are going to fall asleep and go to the bathroom and all that other stuff. If you going to do 60 minutes, it better be at the end of the show.

Intercontinental Championship Match:
Mr. Perfect vs. Randy Savage
8/10 seems like a trend on the last few post with this match.

King of the Hell in a Cell Match:
Hell in a Cell
The Undertaker /w Paul Bearer vs. Triple H /w Stephanie McMahon

9/10….Is Paul Bearer and Stephanie inside or outside the cage? Probably a ten 10 if you didn’t mention them. I do like the King of the HIAC idea though.

WWE Championship "Through the Eras" Match:
Ric Flair vs. Hulk Hogan vs. "Stone Cold" Steve Austin vs. John Cena

20/20

Minus 3 for two Multiman matches.

84/100. I couple minor spots that could be improved. The 60 minute Iron match in the middle of the show hurt.

Kaedon

Matt Hardy vs. Jeff Hardy - Dog Collar Match
10/10 …Don’t like the WM buildup…but these two in dog collars would be great. Nice use of stipulation.
Rey Mysterio/CM Punk/Eddie Guerrero/AJ Styles/Chris Jericho/Evan Bourne - MITB Ladder Match
10/10…Nice use of high flyers, and mat wrestlers in MITB
Sting vs. The Undertaker - Career/Streak Match
10/10
John Cena vs. The Rock
10/10
Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle - Ironman Match
10/10
HBK vs. Samoa Joe
6/10 WTF happened here. You got HBK, the HeartBreak kid….and you pick Joe? Im sorry, you were on such a roll. It would be a great match, but HBK isn’t on the same level as Joe.
Steve Austin vs. Hulk Hogan
20/10 …back to the good stuff. ( I’ll assume you meant this was the main event, since you had it on here twice)
Demolition vs. The Colons vs. The British Bulldogs
6/10 …The colons in a tag match, I think you forgot to put the tag belts on the line.
Brock Lesnar vs. Ed Lewis
9/10 Hell Yeah. Dig him up.

HHH vs. Harley Race

9/10 this works. Maybe mentioned teacher vs student match.

91/100….You booked a great show. I either loved the match, or hated it, and there were two matches I wasn’t really liking.


Straightedge 76

WWE Championship Match
Steel Cage Match
Steve Austin (C) VS Randy Orton

16/20, Orton hasn’t even Main eventing a real mania yet. (until later today)

Submssion Match
Bret Hart VS Sting

10/10 nice use of stip. This probably would have been a 8 if not.

Fatal 4 Way Match- Who Is Mr. Wrestlemania?
Shawn Michaels VS The Undertaker VS Hulk Hogan VS The Rock

10/10 cool concept.

Intercontinental Championship Match
Chris Jericho (C) VS CM Punk

9/10 nice match.

Clash of the Champions
Triple H VS Ric Flair

10/10 I think I just like the title.

Tag Team Championship Match
Tables, Ladders & Chairs Match
The Dudley Boyz VS The Hardy Boyz

9/10 basic.
Last Man Standing Match
Batista VS Goldberg

6/10 BORING, BORING. I believe these two guys were involved in the only matches where the fans were chanting boring.

nWo VS D-Generation X
The Outsiders VS The New Age Outlaws

7/10 I don’t know if you want the NAO on a dream card.
Brother VS Brother
Edge VS Christian

8/10…didn’t they announce they weren’t really brothers?

85/100 ….The card is probably better than the score indicates.

Cenamark 54

WWE Championship Match
Hulk Hogan vs Steve Austin

20/20

World Heavyweight Championship
John Cena vs Andre the Giant

8/10 could be good. Not sure how easily Hogan vs Andre could be duplicated with cena.

Intercontinental Championship
Bret Hart vs Randy Savage

10/10 this should have happened at some point.

60 min Iron Man Match
Ric Flair vs Shawn Michaels

8/10 ….why 60 minutes in the middle of the card. Ric Flair and HBK would be great though.

Legend vs Legend Killer
Randy Orton vs The Rock

9/10 …Lol The Rock is a legend killer?

Money in the Bank Ladder Match
Mic Foley vs Edge vs Christian vs RVD vs Shelton Benjamin vs Jeff Hardy vs Eddie Guerrero vs Chris Jericho

10/10 Nice use of Foley.

Hell in a Cell
Triple H vs Killer Kowalski

8/10 Hell Yeah Killer Kowalski.

WWE Tag Team Championship
The Undertaker and Kane vs Ted DiBiase and Roddy Piper

8/10 this would work.


91/100 good card.Nice use of the wrestlers.

 

[Next Big Thing]

89/100 ….real good score, but could have used some stips, and something to make these matches mean more. A little more on the creative side.

I personally disagree with that. With such talented workers, you don't need to add a silly stip to the match. I'm not just talking about my card either. Looking through the thread, I seen many great match ups with a stip added on when it didn't need one. The best match I have ever seen was Steamboat vs. Savage, and that is great proof that two extremely talented guys don't need to have stips added on to their match.

 

[Montana]

Well... At looking at the grading, all your matches had good scored except for Chris Jericho vs. Jake the Snake. ...I felt you could have added a little something to that match to standout a little more against the other matches on the show. I said from the start i would be a critical grader, and if you have 8 regular singles matches, just by adding a stip would have more variety to the show, rather than armdrags and headlocks. I was also looking at the overall show.

 

[PeepShow]

7/10 Raven????

I fail to see what's so confusing about that. Raven was one of the better if not best hardcore wrestler of all time and had the most reigns as hardcore champion of all time. Him going up against the hardcore legend only seemed fitting imo.

Still a cool concept you had here and one of the better threads I've seen on this forum in a while. Good job.

 

[Next Big Thing]

Well... At looking at the grading, all your matches had good scored except for Chris Jericho vs. Jake the Snake. ...I felt you could have added a little something to that match to standout a little more against the other matches on the show. I said from the start i would be a critical grader, and if you have 8 regular singles matches, just by adding a stip would have more variety to the show, rather than armdrags and headlocks. I was also looking at the overall show.

I'm not complaining because of how you graded my card, because to be honest, it really doesn't matter to me what you think of it. I'm just saying that with the majority of the match ups that I have seen people make in this thread, a stip isn't necessary and in many cases can take away from what the performers are capable of doing.

 

[edgehead09]

dang..i didnt kno the card had to be in like order of apperance..might not of read good enough..O and watch Summerslam 1992 about Bulldog vs. Bret

 

[Mr.Carter]

A match that would've been great (but obviously will never happen is:

Bryan Danielson vs Chris Benoit vs Bret Hart vs Kurt Angle