Don't Call It a Comeback! Mafia '26 (Game Thread)

[Chris]

Just looked at the rules again and didn't see clarification unless I'm blind. But I did more the sample PM of vanilla townie and Mafia goon, I'm kinda basing all my chips that the Mafia team is just two goons bc if they have roles that can really fuck with blaze and I tonight even if we get Jean out and he's scum lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

Like what happens if Jeff and Brett tie today

I'd assume no lynch

 

[O-Blaze]

Did you figure out the maths on if we can be wrong bc when I tried to it seemed very dire as in we have to get it right today and tomorrow but I was hoping someone would come in to tell me how I did it wrong

Well we can almost basically confirm it was 5-2 right?

Now 4-2

If we get Jean wrong its 3-2 where a night kill makes it 2-2 if they get it off.

So we be looking at a possible 2-2 tomorrow if we were wrong....but if so we know for sure Brett is scum.

So its possible I think to be wrong. But I still am not sure if its worth it.

 

[Chris]

Then you should lynch Brett my brother

Not when I don't think we have a bus driver lol

 

[Chris]

I'd assume no lynch

Me too, basically town loss in a tie then bc Mafia can kill at night

 

[Comrade Khan]

Just looked at the rules again and didn't see clarification unless I'm blind. But I did more the sample PM of vanilla townie and Mafia goon, I'm kinda basing all my chips that the Mafia team is just two goons bc if they have roles that can really fuck with blaze and I tonight even if we get Jean out and he's scum lol

I mean do you really believe town has 3 roles claimed and scum have none? That would be pretty wack

 

[O-Blaze]

The way I see it is it's 4-2. If we're wrong today then 3-2 and then mafia kills so 2-2 and we can't win a vote

If we get it right then it's 4-1, Mafia kills and it's 3-1. For tomorrow if we get it wrong then it's 2-1 and Mafia kills so 1-1 and that's game. So we have to get it right both days

Wait yeah I didn't consider that the person wouldn't even vote their own teammate in a 2-2

 

[Comrade Khan]

Not when I don't think we have a bus driver lol

Well town does

 

[Chris]

Well we can almost basically confirm it was 5-2 right?

Now 4-2

If we get Jean wrong its 3-2 where a night kill makes it 2-2 if they get it off.

So we be looking at a possible 2-2 tomorrow if we were wrong....but if so we know for sure Brett is scum.

So its possible I think to be wrong. But I still am not sure if its worth it.

I wouldn't say we can confirm it but I think it's by far most likely scenario so I'm happy to operate on it now. And either way I think Jean is copped scum lying about bus driver so voting him out is beneficial even if we're wrong about the split. But yeah I think 2-2 tomorrow is impossible even if Brett is known to be scum, why wouldn't scum just out themselves and force a stalemate

 

[Chris]

Well town does

 

[Comrade Khan]

Wait yeah I didn't consider that the person wouldn't even vote their own teammate in a 2-2

I wouldn't say that as a definite , Brett's teammate should hammer him if they wanna try to look good tomorrow

 

[Chris]

I like that I copped you and you also tried to kill me so we're both cowards really

 

[Professor Booty]

I don’t see Sky being so nuts she’d have all these roles with 7 people playing. You’re all lying

 

[Comrade Khan]

Are you not town lol

 

[Chris]

I wouldn't say that as a definite , Brett's teammate should hammer him if they wanna try to look good tomorrow

Yeah it's why the game wouldn't end bc they technically could keep up the theatrics but that would really be only for fun no? Like they could just stalemate and win