Don't Call It a Comeback! Mafia '26 (Game Thread)

[Chris]

Tbh with so few players having these roles that make the game easier seems like overkill

This is a very minimal role game tho like i said. Most I played almost everyone had a role and somewhere very wacky that I'm glad we most likely don't have to worry about this game lol

 

[Chris]

Why are you so sure it’s not Blaze then? Not being combative I just wanna hear it

Well now I'm 100% on him bc I don't think he wouldn't lie about being doc in any universe

But before I said he would be great if grim flipped scum which is what I was hoping but for the town grim flip, I said I still thought his play was townie but it was just a vibes read and had the doc thing not came out I wouldn't be clearing him by any means today, he would just be higher than a few others on my town list.

I'd probably have had him below you as a town read before the doc but he's above you now with it if that makes sense

 

[Professor Booty]

Yeah the roles thing is obviously not on traitors so its new to me

 

[Chris]

If you're asking why I was sure about grim over blaze, I wasn't. I just felt a lot better about blaze so I had to make a choice there. I didn't have anyone else I thought should have been with my reads at the time

 

[Professor Booty]

Well now I'm 100% on him bc I don't think he wouldn't lie about being doc in any universe

But before I said he would be great if grim flipped scum which is what I was hoping but for the town grim flip, I said I still thought his play was townie but it was just a vibes read and had the doc thing not came out I wouldn't be clearing him by any means today, he would just be higher than a few others on my town list.

I'd probably have had him below you as a town read before the doc but he's above you now with it if that makes sense

I take it from your experience with him you don’t feel he’d pull this card as a red herring?

 

[Chris]

Yeah the roles thing is obviously not on traitors so its new to me

Im assuming these two are all we have barring Mafia having some role themselves

Doc protects a guy from a kill, if they target who Mafia targets, cop learns alignment of one person each night

 

[Chris]

I take it from your experience with him you don’t feel he’d pull this card as a red herring?

I don't think really anyone would that I've played with to put it into more perspective. It's super rare and usually blows up anyway

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah I'm not scum lol I busdrove myself with brett.

Id be worried about Chris being a liar but I saw Brett claimed doc and protected him and we have no kills over night. So the only way Chris is lying is if both him and blaze are scum together and both lying. No one has counter claimed either so that seems unlikely

 

[Professor Booty]

Cop one seems fuckin wild to have in this small of a game

 

[Comrade Khan]

don't really have an issue with role usage by Chris, he kind of telegraphed he'd cop me yesterday by his read . Logical usage .

 

[Chris]

A bus driver in this game?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Cop one seems fuckin wild to have in this small of a game

If I was scum I would be bummed out with a cop and a doc for sure unless scum is powered up too.

 

[Chris]

Cop one seems fuckin wild to have in this small of a game

It's the most standard role along with doc idk what to tell you

 

[Professor Booty]

Yeah I'm not scum lol I busdrove myself with brett.

Id be worried about Chris being a liar but I saw Brett claimed doc and protected him and we have no kills over night. So the only way Chris is lying is if both him and blaze are scum together and both lying. No one has counter claimed either so that seems unlikely

Yeah that’s what I said earlier if one is then the other is although highly unlikely

 

[Comrade Khan]

A bus driver in this game?

*Shrug* I've given up a long time in making sense of anyone's balancing lol. But yeah , that's what my role says