Documenting Every Wrestler's Win-Loss Rate At WrestleMania

[Bobby Barrows]

This is just a goofy little series I'm working on where I go through every single WrestleMania and document the win-loss records of every single wrestler to ever have a match at the Showcase of the Immortals. The results *may* surprise you. Not only that, on this post here, I'll have a record of every wrestler from best win-loss record to worst. So without further ado, let's get it on!
​

Current Standings (W-L-D/NC) *^v~ = Raise/Lower/Stagnant:

Hulk Hogan (3-0)/100% ^
Ricky Steamboat (3-0)/100% ^

Mr. T (2-0)/100% ~

Dory Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Terry Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Fabulous Moolah (1-0)/100% ~
Corporal Kirchner (1-0)/100% ~
Wendi Richter (1-0)/100% ~
Honky Tonk Man (1-0)/100% ^
Butch Reed (1-0)/100% ^
Danny Davis (1-0)/100% ^
Harley Race (1-0)/100% ^
Rick Martel (1-0)/100% ^
Tom Zenk (1-0)/100% ^
Haiti Kid (1-0)/100% ^
Little Beaver (1-0)/100% ^

Andre The Giant (2-1)/66% v
Nikolai Volkoff (2-1)/66% ^
Iron Shiek (2-1)/66% ^

Randy Savage (1-1)/50% v
Jake Roberts (1-1)/50% v
Davey Boy Smith (1-1)/50% v
Dynamite Kid (1-1)/50% v
Bret Hart (1-1)/50% ^
Jim Neidhart (1-1)/50% ^
Hillbilly Jim (1-1)/50% ^

Roddy Piper (1-2)/33% ^
Greg Valentine (1-2)/33% ^
King Kong Bundy (1-2)/33% v
Tito Santana (1-2)/33% v
Junkyard Dog (1-2)/33% v

Brutus Beefcake (1-1-1)/33% ^

David Sammartino (0-0-1)/0% ~
Billy Jack Haynes (0-0-1)/0% v

Don Muraco (0-1-1)/0% v
Paul Orndorff (0-1-1)/0%
Hercules (0-1-1)/0% ^

Leilani Kai (0-1)/0% ~
Barry Windham (0-1)/0% ~
Mike Rotunda (0-1)/0% ~
Matt Borne (0-1)/0% ~
SD Jones (0-1)/0% ~
Buddy Rose (0-1)/0% ~
Velvet McIntyre (0-1)/0% ~
Uncle Elmer (0-1)/0% ~
Jimbo Covert (0-1)/0% ~
Bill Fralic (0-1)/0% ~
Russ Francis (0-1)/0% ~
Ernie Holmes (0-1)/0% ~
Harvey Martin (0-1)/0% ~
William Perry (0-1)/0% ~
Tony Atlas (0-1)/0% ~
Ted Arcidi (0-1)/0% ~
Bob Orton (0-1)/0% v
Little Tokyo (0-1)/0% v
Lord Littlebrook (0-1)/0% v
Koko B. Ware (0-1)/0% v
Jacques Rougeau (0-1)/0% v
Raymond Rougeau (0-1)/0% v
Haku (0-1)/0% v
Pedro Morales (0-1)/0% ~
Bruno Sammartino (0-1)/0% ~
Danny Spivey (0-1)/0% ~

Brian Blair (0-2)/0% v
Jim Brunzell (0-2)/0% v
Big John Studd (0-2)/0% ~

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

The only important one is Snooki 1-0


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Kidding this is awesome


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Bobby Barrows]

March 31st, 1985
Madison Square Garden
New York City, New York

(Win-Loss-No Contest/Draw)

Tito Santana (1-0) Defeats The Executioner (0-1)

King Kong Bundy (1-0) Defeats Special Delivery Jones (0-1)

Ricky Steamboat (1-0) Defeats Matt Borne (0-1)

Brutus Beefcake (0-0-1) and David Sammartino (0-0-1) Go to a Double DQ

Junkyard Dog (1-0) Defeats Greg Valentine (0-1)

Iron Sheik (1-0) & Nikolai Volkoff (1-0) Defeat Barry Windham (0-1) and Mike Rotunda (0-1)

Andre The Giant (1-0) Defeats Big John Studd (0-1)

Wendi Richter (1-0) Defeats Leilani Kai (0-1)

Hulk Hogan (1-0) and Mr. T (1-0) Defeat Paul Orndorff (0-1) and Roddy Piper (0-1)

​

Current Standings:

Hulk Hogan (1-0)/100%
Mr. T (1-0)/100%
Wendi Richter (1-0)/100%
Andre The Giant (1-0)/100%
Iron Shiek (1-0)/100%
Nikolai Volkoff (1-0)/100%
Junkyard Dog (1-0)/100%
Ricky Steamboat (1-0)/100%
King Kong Bundy (1-0)/100%
Tito Santana (1-0)/100%
Brutus Beefcake (0-0-1)/0%
David Sammartino (0-0-1)/0%
Paul Orndorff (0-1)/0%
Roddy Piper (0-1)/0%
Leilani Kai (0-1)/0%
Big John Studd (0-1)/0%
Barry Windham (0-1)/0%
Mike Rotunda (0-1)/0%
Greg Valentine (0-1)/0%
Matt Borne (0-1)/0%
SD Jones (0-1)/0%
Buddy Rose (0-1)/0%

 

[Kiffy Lube]

This could get rather interestin', lookin' forward to the progression of this thread.

 

[Chris]

Mr T.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

April 7, 1986
THREE WHOLE ASS VENUES
New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles

(Win-Loss-No Contest/Draw)

Don Muraco (0-0-1) vs. Paul Orndorff (0-1-1) Ends in Double Countout

Randy Savage (1-0) Defeats George Steele (0-1)

Jake Roberts (1-0) Defeats George Wells (0-1)

Mr. T (2-0) Defeats Roddy Piper (0-2) By DQ

The Fabulous Moolah (1-0) Defeats Velvet McIntyre (0-1)

Corporal Kirchner (1-0) Defeats Nikolai Volkoff (1-1)

Andre The Giant (2-0) Wins A Battle Royal
(Featuring The Hart Foundation(0-1), Jimbo Covert (0-1), Bill Fralic (0-1), Russ Francis (0-1), Ernie Holmes (0-1), Harvey Martin (0-1), William Perry (0-1), Ted Arcidi (0-1), Tony Atlas (0-1), The Killer Bees (0-1), Hillbilly Jim (0-1), The Iron Sheik (1-1), King Tonga (0-1), Pedro Morales (0-1), Bruno Sammartino (0-1), Danny Spivey (0-1), and Big John Studd (0-2))

Davey Boy Smith (1-0) and Dynamite Kid (1-0) Defeat Brutus Beefcake (0-1-1) and Greg Valentine (0-2)

Ricky Steamboat (2-0) Defeats Hercules Hernandez (0-1)

Adrian Adonis (1-0) Defeats Uncle Elmer (0-1)

Dory Funk (1-0) & Terry Funk (1-0) Defeats JYD (1-1) & Tito Santana (1-1)

Hulk Hogan (2-0) Defeats King Kong Bundy (1-1)
​

Current Standings (W-L-D/NC) *^v~ = Raise/Lower/Stagnant:

Hulk Hogan (2-0)/100% ^
Mr. T (2-0)/100% ^
Andre The Giant (2-0)/100% ^
Ricky Steamboat (2-0)/100% ^
Randy Savage (1-0)/100% ^
Dory Funk (1-0)/100% ^
Terry Funk (1-0)/100% ^
Fabulous Moolah (1-0)/100% ^
Jake Roberts (1-0)/100% ^
Corporal Kirchner (1-0)/100% ^
Davey Boy Smith (1-0) ^
Dynamite Kid (1-0) ^
Wendi Richter (1-0)/100% ~
King Kong Bundy (1-1)/50% v
Tito Santana (1-1)/50% v
Junkyard Dog (1-1)/50% v
Nikolai Volkoff (1-1)/50% v
Iron Shiek (1-1)/50% v
David Sammartino (0-0-1)/0% ~
Don Muraco (0-0-1)/0% v
Brutus Beefcake (0-1-1)/0% v
Paul Orndorff (0-1-1)/0% v
Leilani Kai (0-1)/0% ~
Barry Windham (0-1)/0% ~
Mike Rotunda (0-1)/0% ~
Matt Borne (0-1)/0% ~
SD Jones (0-1)/0% ~
Buddy Rose (0-1)/0% ~
Velvet McIntyre (0-1)/0% v
Hercules (0-1)/0% v
Uncle Elmer (0-1)/0% v
Bret Hart (0-1)/0% v
Jim Neidhart (0-1)/0% v
Jimbo Covert (0-1)/0% v
Bill Fralic (0-1)/0% v
Russ Francis (0-1)/0% v
Ernie Holmes (0-1)/0% v
Harvey Martin (0-1)/0% v
William Perry (0-1)/0% v
Brian Blair (0-1)/0% v
Jim Brunzell (0-1)/0% v
Tony Atlas (0-1)/0% v
Ted Arcidi (0-1)/0% v
Hillbilly Jim (0-1)/0% v
Haku (0-1)/0% v
Pedro Morales (0-1)/0% v
Bruno Sammartino (0-1)/0% v
Danny Spivey (0-1)/0% v
Big John Studd (0-2)/0% v
Greg Valentine (0-2)/0% v
Roddy Piper (0-2)/0% v

 

[Chris]

Mr. T 2-0

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Awesome thread, I will surely follow this.

The only important one is Snooki 1-0


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I was there! I WAS THERE!

 

[Bobby Barrows]

March 29, 1987
The Silverdome
Pontiac, Michigan

Rick Martel (1-0) & Tom Zenk (1-0) Defeat Don Muraco (0-1-1) & Bob Orton (0-1)

Billy Jack Haynes (0-0-1) & Hercules (0-1-1) Go To Double Countout

Haiti Kid (1-0), Hillbilly Jim (1-1), & Little Beaver (1-0) Defeat King Kong Bundy (1-2), Little Tokyo (0-1), & Lord Littlebrook (0-1)

Harley Race (1-0) Defeats JYD (1-2)

Brutus Beefcake (1-1-1) & Greg Valentine (1-2) Defeat Jacques (0-1) & Raymond (0-1) Rougeau

Roddy Piper (1-2) Defeats Adrian Adonis (1-1)

Danny Davis (1-0), Bret Hart (1-1), & Jim Neidhart (1-1) Defeat Tito Santana (1-2), Davey Boy Smith (1-1), & Dynamite Kid (1-1)

Butch Reed (1-0) Defeats Koko B. Ware (0-1)

Ricky Steamboat (3-0) Defeats Randy Savage (1-1)

The Honky Tonk Man (1-0) Defeats Jake Roberts (1-1)

Iron Sheik (2-1) & Nikolai Volkoff (2-1) Defeat Brian Blair (0-2) & Jim Brunzell (0-2)

Hulk Hogan (3-0) Defeats Andre The Giant (2-1)
​

Current Standings (W-L-D/NC) *^v~ = Raise/Lower/Stagnant:

Hulk Hogan (3-0)/100% ^
Ricky Steamboat (3-0)/100% ^
Mr. T (2-0)/100% ~
Dory Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Terry Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Fabulous Moolah (1-0)/100% ~
Corporal Kirchner (1-0)/100% ~
Wendi Richter (1-0)/100% ~
Honky Tonk Man (1-0)/100% ^
Butch Reed (1-0)/100% ^
Danny Davis (1-0)/100% ^
Harley Race (1-0)/100% ^
Rick Martel (1-0)/100% ^
Tom Zenk (1-0)/100% ^
Haiti Kid (1-0)/100% ^
Little Beaver (1-0)/100% ^
Andre The Giant (2-1)/66% v
Nikolai Volkoff (2-1)/66% ^
Iron Shiek (2-1)/66% ^
Randy Savage (1-1)/50% v
Jake Roberts (1-1)/50% v
Davey Boy Smith (1-1)/50% v
Dynamite Kid (1-1)/50% v
Bret Hart (1-1)/50% ^
Jim Neidhart (1-1)/50% ^
Hillbilly Jim (1-1)/50% ^
Roddy Piper (1-2)/33% ^
Greg Valentine (1-2)/33% ^
King Kong Bundy (1-2)/33% v
Tito Santana (1-2)/33% v
Junkyard Dog (1-2)/33% v
Brutus Beefcake (1-1-1)/33% ^
David Sammartino (0-0-1)/0% ~
Billy Jack Haynes (0-0-1)/0% v
Don Muraco (0-1-1)/0% v
Paul Orndorff (0-1-1)/0%
Hercules (0-1-1)/0% ^
Leilani Kai (0-1)/0% ~
Barry Windham (0-1)/0% ~
Mike Rotunda (0-1)/0% ~
Matt Borne (0-1)/0% ~
SD Jones (0-1)/0% ~
Buddy Rose (0-1)/0% ~
Velvet McIntyre (0-1)/0% ~
Uncle Elmer (0-1)/0% ~
Jimbo Covert (0-1)/0% ~
Bill Fralic (0-1)/0% ~
Russ Francis (0-1)/0% ~
Ernie Holmes (0-1)/0% ~
Harvey Martin (0-1)/0% ~
William Perry (0-1)/0% ~
Tony Atlas (0-1)/0% ~
Ted Arcidi (0-1)/0% ~
Bob Orton (0-1)/0% v
Little Tokyo (0-1)/0% v
Lord Littlebrook (0-1)/0% v
Koko B. Ware (0-1)/0% v
Jacques Rougeau (0-1)/0% v
Raymond Rougeau (0-1)/0% v
Haku (0-1)/0% v
Pedro Morales (0-1)/0% ~
Bruno Sammartino (0-1)/0% ~
Danny Spivey (0-1)/0% ~
Brian Blair (0-2)/0% v
Jim Brunzell (0-2)/0% v
Big John Studd (0-2)/0% ~

 

[Chris]

Roddy got his first win. Also Steamboat Kinda forget he's even on the first two even though his '85 match is one of the better ones

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Steamboat up there with Hogan... for now.

 

[Chris]

When the Jericho match hurts Steamboat's ranking in 20 years

 

[Bobby Barrows]

When the Jericho match hurts Steamboat's ranking in 20 years

Steamboat's ranking gonna hurt as soon as next show.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

March 27, 1988
Boardwalk Hall / "Trump Plaza"
Atlantic City, New Jersey

Battle Royale
Bad News Brown (1-0) defeats Bret Hart (1-2), Nikolai Volkoff (2-2), Boris Zhukov (0-1), Jim Neidhart (1-2), B. Brian Blair (0-3), Jim Brunzell (0-3), Danny Davis (1-1), George Steele (0-2), Harley Race (1-1), Hillbilly Jim (1-1), Jacques Rougeau (0-2), Raymond Rougeau (0-2), Paul Roma (0-1), Jim Powers (0-1), Junkyard Dog (1-3), Ken Patera (0-1), Ron Bass (0-1), Sam Houston (0-1), Sika (0-1)

Ted DiBiase (1-0) d. Jim Duggan (0-1)

Don Muraco (1-1-1) d. Dino Bravo (0-1)

Greg Valentine (2-2) d. Ricky Steamboat (2-1)

Randy Savage (2-1) d. Butch Reed (1-1)

One Man Gang (1-0) d. Bam Bam Bigelow (0-1)

Jake Roberts (1-1-1) and Rick Rude (0-0-1) went to Time-Limit Draw

Ultimate Warrior (1-0) d. Hercules (0-2-1)

Andre The Giant (2-1-1) and Hulk Hogan (3-0-1) went to Double DQ

Ted DiBiase (2-0) d. Don Muraco (1-2-1)

Randy Savage (3-1) d. Greg Valentine (2-3)

Intercontinental Championship
Brutus Beefcake (2-1-1) d. Honky Tonk Man (1-1) by DQ

Haku (1-1), Tama (1-0) & Bobby Heenan (0-1) d. Davey Boy (1-2), Dynamite Kid (1-2) & Koko B. Ware (0-2)

Randy Savage (4-1) d. One Man Gang (1-1)

WWF Tag Team Championship
Ax (1-0) & Smash (1-0) d. Rick Martel (1-1) & Tito Santana (1-3)

WWF Championship
Randy Savage (5-1) d. Ted DiBiase (2-1)
​

Current Standings (W-L-D/NC) *^v~(*) = Raise/Lower/Stagnant/New Entry:

Mr. T (2-0)/100% ~

Ax (1-0)/100% *
Smash (1-0)/100% *
Dory Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Terry Funk (1-0)/100% ~
Fabulous Moolah (1-0)/100% ~
Corporal Kirchner (1-0)/100% ~
Wendi Richter (1-0)/100% ~
Bad News Brown (1-0)/100% *
Ultimate Warrior (1-0)/100% *
Tom Zenk (1-0)/100% ~
Haiti Kid (1-0)/100% ~
Little Beaver (1-0)/100%~

Randy Savage (5-1)/83% ^

Hulk Hogan (3-0-1)/75% V

Ricky Steamboat (3-1)/75% v

Ted DiBiase (2-1)/66% *
Iron Shiek (2-1)/66% ~

Brutus Beefcake (2-1-1)/50% ^
Andre The Giant (2-1-1)/50% v

Nikolai Volkoff (2-2)/50% v

One Man Gang (1-1) 50% *
Harley Race (1-1)/50% v
Haku (1-1)/50% ^
Hillbilly Jim (1-1)/50% v
Rick Martel (1-1)/50% v
Honky Tonk Man (1-1)/50% v
Butch Reed (1-1)/50% v
Danny Davis (1-1)/50% v

Greg Valentine (2-3)/40% v

Jake Roberts (1-1-1)/33% v

Roddy Piper (1-2)/33% ~
King Kong Bundy (1-2)/33% ~
Davey Boy Smith (1-2)/33% v
Dynamite Kid (1-2)/33% v
Bret Hart (1-2)/33% v
Jim Neidhart (1-2)/33% v

Tito Santana (1-3)/25% v
Junkyard Dog (1-3)/25% v

Don Muraco (1-2-1)/25% ^

David Sammartino (0-0-1)/0% ~
Billy Jack Haynes (0-0-1)/0% ~
Rick Rude (0-0-1)/0% *

Paul Orndorff (0-1-1)/0% ~

Leilani Kai (0-1)/0% ~
Barry Windham (0-1)/0% ~
Mike Rotunda (0-1)/0% ~
Matt Borne (0-1)/0% ~
SD Jones (0-1)/0% ~
Buddy Rose (0-1)/0% ~
Velvet McIntyre (0-1)/0% ~
Uncle Elmer (0-1)/0% ~
Jimbo Covert (0-1)/0% ~
Bill Fralic (0-1)/0% ~
Russ Francis (0-1)/0% ~
Ernie Holmes (0-1)/0% ~
Harvey Martin (0-1)/0% ~
William Perry (0-1)/0% ~
Tony Atlas (0-1)/0% ~
Ted Arcidi (0-1)/0% ~
Bob Orton (0-1)/0% ~
Little Tokyo (0-1)/0% ~
Lord Littlebrook (0-1)/0% ~
Pedro Morales (0-1)/0% ~
Bruno Sammartino (0-1)/0% ~
Danny Spivey (0-1)/0% ~
Bam Bam Bigelow (0-1)/0% *
Dino Bravo (0-1)/0% *
Jim Duggan (0-1)/0% *
Sika (0-1)/0% *
Sam Houston (0-1)/0% *
Ron Bass (0-1)/0% *
Ken Patera (0-1)/0% *
Boris Zhukov (0-1)/0% *

Hercules (0-2-1)/0% v

Jacques Rougeau (0-2)/0% v
Raymond Rougeau (0-2)/0% v
Koko B. Ware (0-2)/0% v
Big John Studd (0-2)/0% ~
George Steele (0-2)/0% v

Brian Blair (0-3)/0% v
Jim Brunzell (0-3)/0% v