Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[CraigPelton]

Hmm I don't really buy the Doddsy claim

 

[Marty McFourth]

Doddsy's role does make plenty sense. Although I wonder if it even would have worked on Night 2 either as I lost my roles on that one after being shot.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Hmm I don't really buy the Doddsy claim

It's most likely real unless he came up with an incredible fake, I'd give him props for that, it can't be janitor which is what I was speculating.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Obviously doesn't help at all either way. I'm fine giving him time to catch up later though and seeing what he brings, no point lynching now or anything

Sure, I guess.

Are you voting Tweet? I would not be opposed to that

 

[Marty McFourth]

Unvote
Vote Tweet

I'd be fine with Big Man too, but already a vote on this one. It also accomplishes the same goal for me as I reckon either of them could be scum, but I would not expect them to be aligned.

I don't really buy CP's claim but no reason to rush day through

 

[CraigPelton]

It's most likely real unless he came up with an incredible fake, I'd give him props for that, it can't be janitor which is what I was speculating.

Why is it most likely real? Sounds like a very narrow role and highly unlikely that he happened to target his roles intended target, but that you also were ascetic that night, and now he has no role left to prove. Sounds like a highly convenient claim to me for me scum.

 

[CraigPelton]

Poyser really had nothing to say about Doddsy except asking benign questions that help establish his claim

 

[Marty McFourth]

Why is it most likely real? Sounds like a very narrow role and highly unlikely that he happened to target his roles intended target, but that you also were ascetic that night, and now he has no role left to prove. Sounds like a highly convenient claim to me for me scum.

I'm not disagreeing that it seems mighty convenient, I'm just saying he claimed it pretty fast after I claimed and it seems to check out. If he came up with that on his own and that fast for a fake, I'd be impressed. I do find it odd how he managed to land it on me (the right character) at random.

I would not be comfortable lynching him right now, but it's probable it's a fake he thought up.

 

[CraigPelton]

I'm not disagreeing that it seems mighty convenient, I'm just saying he claimed it pretty fast after I claimed and it seems to check out. If he came up with that on his own and that fast for a fake, I'd be impressed. I do find it odd how he managed to land it on me (the right character) at random.

I would not be comfortable lynching him right now, but it's probable it's a fake he thought up.

I don't see what's so impressive about it if he already had his character and role sorted and then sees you claim the doctor with an ascetic use already

 

[Marty McFourth]

I don't see what's so impressive about it if he already had his character and role sorted and then sees you claim the doctor with an ascetic use already

Perhaps it's because I'm dogshit at fake claiming so wouldn't think to already have a fake in mind where you have to give The Doctor the sonic screwdriver. How would he know that character was a Weak JOAT or would need it?

 

[CraigPelton]

I’m getting serious scum vibes from Chris tbh. Really reminds me of his play in WWE Jobbers Mafia when he was scum, not to mention he hadn’t really been on me but nonchalantly said he’d be good with going with me. He’s one to look out for that’s for sure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What was his play like in that game?

 

[CraigPelton]

Perhaps it's because I'm dogshit at fake claiming so wouldn't think to already have a fake in mind where you have to give The Doctor the sonic screwdriver. How would he know that character was a Weak JOAT or would need it?

I'm confused, you know for a fact that there's a sonic screwdriver in the game that helps your role?

 

[Marty McFourth]

Not gonna lie everytime Poyser likes one of my posts I feel like he's playing me as scum and laughing at how easy it is to get me to follow him.

If CP isn't scum, I would not feel as comfortable with Poyser actually.

 

[CraigPelton]

Okay, I'm going to claim as I'm a Vanilla Townie now.

I am The Doctor.

My role was Weak JOAT. I had three abilities X-Shot that I could randomly gain to use (Asetic, Inspire and Jailkeeper) after every odd day phase

I was also buletproof and would lose all my abilities if I was shot at. That just happened last night.

You gave scum so much info they didn't need here lmao

 

[Marty McFourth]

I'm confused, you know for a fact that there's a sonic screwdriver in the game that helps your role?

No, I did not know that. There was no mention to anything like that in my PM or being able to be strengthend. I was just a Weak JOAT that got X-Shot roles randomly.

I'm just saying Doddsy must have theme knowledge/be smart to think up that type of claim and claim it so fast afterwards if it's fake. Meaning he'd already pre-planned it when he didn't know I was a Weak JOAT before I claimed.