Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Tommy Bedlam]

So we've got Gip and Tweet as Indy. (2)

Town generally believes that Lethal and McDonalds are scum. (2)

We have no clue on Wang whatsoever. (1)

That would leave Me, SA, Pein, and SB as town? (4)

Just thinking out my numbers and making a post so I can revisit it.

 

[Sister Abigail]

If we myslynch town and then serial killer shoots a townie of course but if I was scum and I’m faking being watcher the SK is gonna shoot me tonight so mafia would not be able to win tomorrow is the whole point.

Way too risky.

But you can see how this logic might also make me believe that you're scum lying about being Watcher in order to create a mislynch and end the game, yeah?

 

[Sister Abigail]

So we've got Gip and Tweet as Indy. (2)

Town generally believes that Lethal and McDonalds are scum. (2)

We have no clue on Wang whatsoever. (1)

That would leave Me, SA, Pein, and SB as town? (4)

Just thinking out my numbers and making a post so I can revisit it.

That's probably the breakdown. Three Mafia, one Survivor, one SK, four Town.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Or five Town.

 

[Smart Marx]

But you can see how this logic might also make me believe that you're scum lying about being Watcher in order to create a mislynch and end the game, yeah?

Mafia faking that is suicide for the SK can then shoot me at night. Killing that chance to win.

I also have to hope none of the remaining players have either a watcher or a tracker role because if they do, I’m fucked at that point. I get the paranoia though.

I do it a lot in later games, too.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Right. I have zero read on Wang outside of meta reading that he didn't post much in the American Revolution game when I was scum with him and he didn't post much. But this is even less activity, which makes it really hard for me to read anything on him.

 

[T-Pein™]

So we've got Gip and Tweet as Indy. (2)

Town generally believes that Lethal and McDonalds are scum. (2)

We have no clue on Wang whatsoever. (1)

That would leave Me, SA, Pein, and SB as town? (4)

Just thinking out my numbers and making a post so I can revisit it.

yeah.
Something like that.
now we are just deciding who to lynch 1st.
lethal or mchenry.

either one ok with me.
rather lethal 1st.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Alright. So we need to try to have a calm, rational conversation about choosing between McStalker and Lethal.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Did anyone read my iso and think that I was going after Lethal because of personal reasons?

 

[Tweet]

Frankly I'm not thinking about the future too much. The info heavily points towards either Smark or McHenry being scum, FoS on anyone who tries to push anyone else today

 

[Sister Abigail]

Just felt his reaction was way over the top and then he peaced.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

We can do this.

Pein wants to go Lethal. I think SA does as well.

I would lean towards trusting SB and going after McHenry, and obviously, he wants to go that way as well.

I know that I can't watch anybody tonight, follow anybody, frame anybody, shoot anybody, nothing. I'm as vanilla as it gets. I'm willing to put my vote where it can do the most good.

 

[Smart Marx]

Did anyone read my iso and think that I was going after Lethal because of personal reasons?

I don’t think your case on him is for personal reasons but I will say you shouldn’t have told him retire that was a bit too much and hopefully you can make up for that in post.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I don’t think your case on him is for personal reasons but I will say you shouldn’t have told him retire that was a bit too much and hopefully you can make up for that in post.

This. I think you had game reasons for wanting to get rid of him, but then you told him to quit playing. As someone who isn't all that good at this, I would take that a pretty shitty thing to say. Unlike him, I would probably tell you to get fucked and continue playing, but people respond in different ways.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I don’t think your case on him is for personal reasons but I will say you shouldn’t have told him retire that was a bit too much and hopefully you can make up for that in post.

It really was said tongue in check, with me thinking he was scum and not believing in the change of his reads. But I understand why he'd be upset.