Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Comrade Khan]

so seriously though Haza, why are you playing openly scummy, you're being quite passive aggresively antagonistic in trying to get me annoyed. how come?

 

[Smart Marx]

bad analysis

its improbable but not because of luck, rather because tpein wud be taking HUGE risk assuming the real cop does not cc him. unless we r speculating town has no real cop and its tpeins fake claim. in that event fk this game

I’m saying out of all the players in the game that he/they could’ve chosen to role cop they choose ace marvel of all people and just happen to role cop the insane cop?

But, yeah, his play around the cc is also interesting because he put a spotlight on himself and some he knew was a cop and didn’t fear another cc from a different cop

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Red Dragon @Ekkologix comment on this please.

Why would a mafia role cop become privy to a part of a player’s role that they themselves are not aware of?

youre asking a question only the host would know , I have absolutely no way of knowing what a potential juice rolecop would or would not see on their result

 

[Ekkologix]

@Red Dragon @Ekkologix comment on this please.

Why would a mafia role cop become privy to a part of a player’s role that they themselves are not aware of?

yes i show hidden stuff in rolecops

 

[Smart Marx]

or as i said above, there is NO realcop AND tpein is ALSO a town insane variant wtv cop. which is also sadly a possibility we have to look at since its clear this game is not a traditional one

I don’t think it’s going to be the same one that Ace was but there’s a very strong chance he might be one of those other two weird variance for sure. Juice might have hoped Ace and Company would solve their own roles and reverse engineer results afterwards.

 

[Comrade Khan]

youre asking a question only the host would know , I have absolutely no way of knowing what a potential juice rolecop would or would not see on their result

so the answer is i dont know, you would have to ask juice

 

[Ekkologix]

every host is different, generally the polarity shows in rolecop by default

u can ask juice to double check

 

[Mandalorian]

1 - because theres other things to look at quite clearly and theres a ton of mechanical moving parts. you cant just take tpeins word, theres no reason to actually 10% believe that, so im not sure where u getting this from

2- ive explained multiple theories about pein already, dont think i need to repeat them. also how could i possibly be going after him at night? i went for him hard during day phase, then mchenry flipped town and ace got killed and we saw his flip. i obviously had way of knowing either of these things would happen so quite clearly im going to have a more open mind on what possibly happened. but ya, i did call for peins head and called him a liar when he originally accused me. this notion i didnt go after him at all is quite false and there was multiple exchanges u clearly omitted to read or acknowledge.

im not turning myself from anything either, im directly answering your post. ive also explained why looking elsewhere, such as in your direction, is obviously better. none of what you said actually makes me scum or dismisses any point ive made on the game state. this is vey disingenuous and skipping quite a few details in thread, not to mention ignoring a large bulk of my phase 2 and night phase posts.

I’m not saying that you’re not answering questions. You are very forthcoming actually, which is good because you aren’t hiding.

I’m not being disingenuous. I’m asking you about your approach and why it is the one you’re taking. If someone does to me what you SHOULD be saying has been done to you, I’m going scorched earth to get that fucker out. That’s the point I’m trying to make here. You’re saying that Pein isn’t your top choice tomorrow when he absolutely should be if you’re telling the truth.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don’t think it’s going to be the same one that Ace was but there’s a very strong chance he might be one of those other two weird variance for sure. Juice might have hoped Ace and Company would solve their own roles and reverse engineer results afterwards.

thjis part i can put stock into, simply by the wording on Ace's flip (take a look urself)

 

[RDK]

so seriously though Haza, why are you playing openly scummy, you're being quite passive aggresively antagonistic in trying to get me annoyed. how come?

You're overreacting.

I'm not being aggressive or antagonistic in the slightest. Point me to any instance where I've been either...

I'm following info, you're copped scum, it's not that deep

You don't like it, that's not my problem.

 

[Ekkologix]

I’m saying out of all the players in the game that he/they could’ve chosen to role cop they choose ace marvel of all people and just happen to role cop the insane cop?

But, yeah, his play around the cc is also interesting because he put a spotlight on himself and some he knew was a cop and didn’t fear another cc from a different cop

can u reach a conclusion on this

is tpein town or scum?
is jeff town or scum?

 

[Smart Marx]

can u reach a conclusion on this

is tpein town or scum?
is jeff town or scum?

Probably both town.

 

[Smart Marx]

I certainly don’t think Jeff is going to be a scam.

 

[Mandalorian]

youre asking a question only the host would know , I have absolutely no way of knowing what a potential juice rolecop would or would not see on their result

Right. So why is Pein being a role cop even being peddled as a theory if there’s no certainty over whether he’d know the truth about Ace’s role?

Say he didn’t learn he was inverse and he just thought Ace was a normal cop - Ace gave a mafia result on a town player. Pein would know that we were heading for a mislynch. I just can’t see the play to case any shadow of doubt over Ace’s claim in that circumstance, because then Ace himself would have likely been on the chopping block next.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I’m not saying that you’re not answering questions. You are very forthcoming actually, which is good because you aren’t hiding.

I’m not being disingenuous. I’m asking you about your approach and why it is the one you’re taking. If someone does to me what you SHOULD be saying has been done to you, I’m going scorched earth to get that fucker out. That’s the point I’m trying to make here. You’re saying that Pein isn’t your top choice tomorrow when he absolutely should be if you’re telling the truth.

well i kind of did that i na sense, but you're also kind of not taking into context that during the phase we also had a guilty result on Mchenry via Ace.and again, I DID rage on him, go look. thats why im saying it looks disengenious to me, because i did slap him for it. but now we have info in front of us that's weird af, so it would not be good town play to rage and say tpein must die above all. analysis and proper thought needs to be invested. i also have other scum reads and the 3 user Info to consider. I can appreciate going postal on tpein, which i did, but im not going to simply ONLY rage at him. certainly not right now either during the night phase, what purpose would that serve.

the reality is there's some outs for him being town as much as it pisses me off, I have no choice to accept that with the information currently available.