Death Note Mafia - Game Thread

[PHEN0M]

You guys want my Banez vote or will it be scummy of me to vote him now without catching up fully on the game? Asking for a friend.

 

[Evans]

Ok.... but your thoughts here don’t make sense. You think a scum team with theme knowledge would tell him to forego claiming a character that the host gives as a safe fake?

I'm not sure how my point doesn't make sense, at all. Scum mates with no theme knowledge based off a character claim that would likely be scum aligned is fine.

How do you know it's a fake? He could have gone and just claimed his actual character which would be odd sure but the tap out is weirder

There's always the chance he's town but you're sure he's scum right?

 

[Roy Mustang]

You guys want my Banez vote or will it be scummy of me to vote him now without catching up fully on the game? Asking for a friend.

Up to you. I think Banez has given up but I'd recommend catching up tbh to make your own judgement

 

[Poyser]

who dont you like on it and why

Well not a big fan of evans’ vote for one, that much should be obvious

just seems like it built too easily tho

 

[Alco]

You guys want my Banez vote or will it be scummy of me to vote him now without catching up fully on the game? Asking for a friend.

Very nice of you to ask this in my stead <3

 

[PHEN0M]

Yeah wasn’t sure if he was nailed to a wall here, happy to move it along if so.

 

[Poyser]

I'm not sure how my point doesn't make sense, at all. Scum mates with no theme knowledge based off a character claim that would likely be scum aligned is fine.

How do you know it's a fake? He could have gone and just claimed his actual character which would be odd sure but the tap out is weirder

There's always the chance he's town but you're sure he's scum right?

It doesn’t make sense because your reason for saying it’s a poor claim is based solely on the character he claimed and not the role or how the character ties to the role which makes it seem like you’re full of shit tbh. How many games have you played? And in how many of them have scum just claimed their actual character? This isn’t a real thought you would have. If it’s a fake character given by the host then it says nothing about the scum team

 

[Smart Marx]

Well not a big fan of evans’ vote for one, that much should be obvious

just seems like it built too easily tho

Weren't you saying earlier people were sitting on their hands?

I agree there's some questionable votes near the end, but couldn't those be scum knowing the lynch is inevitable and getting on it?

 

[Poyser]

I feel like if he is scum (which I am fairly sure he is), he needs a talking to post-game for tapping out like this.

What makes you fairly sure he is scum out of interest?

 

[Poyser]

Weren't you saying earlier people were sitting on their hands?

I agree there's some questionable votes near the end, but couldn't those be scum knowing the lynch is inevitable and getting on it?

Could be ya, that’s why I’m not gonna change course. I think banez is scum but I think the wagon is gonna be interesting to analyse whether I’m right or wrong here

 

[RDK]

Well not a big fan of evans’ vote for one, that much should be obvious

just seems like it built too easily tho

Chris' vote just now seemed a little worked but I haven't read any of the game so don't know his progression I'd have to read back at some point

 

[Evans]

It doesn’t make sense because your reason for saying it’s a poor claim is based solely on the character he claimed and not the role or how the character ties to the role which makes it seem like you’re full of shit tbh. How many games have you played? And in how many of them have scum just claimed their actual character? This isn’t a real thought you would have. If it’s a fake character given by the host then it says nothing about the scum team

Yeah but it is a real thought. I didn't pay much attention to the role. Ryuk's role in the series is diverse enough to fit multiple roles that could be in this game so it's a redundant point. Ryuk would also fit perfectly as a bodyguard, mason, any investigative role based on his actions working with Light.

The stand out from the claim is the character and his likely alignment.

 

[Tweet]

Banez probably Cereal Griller the way nobody is objecting to this wagon but he also doesn't seem town.

 

[Smart Marx]

Banez probably Cereal Griller the way nobody is objecting to this wagon but he also doesn't seem town.

There was some talk of indy earlier and he gives the death notes out, right? Could fit.

 

[Evans]

There was some talk of indy earlier and he gives the death notes out, right? Could fit.

yes he could also fill this role