Crusader Kings II: A Mafia Tale GAME Thread

[Comrade Khan]

evans also had his chance to get in the thread and do something, i dont want to be heartless, but time was pressing, which was ultimately part his doing.

 

[Smart Marx]

He'd be in bed rn to be fair, right?

 

[CraigPelton]

Jeff's town and maf game have been tough to differentiate the past games I've played with him. Not willing to give him any read based on D1 play r/n.

this can’t be real lmao, he’s probably the most transparent guy

He MVP'd the last game after playing town, repping in as mafia, and being on noone's scum list. And while I had the rest of maf nailed down I hadn't even considered him as maf.

yes, but he was able to just tunnel his erroneous scum read from his previous life

that’s not opaque play by any means, which he’d be the first to admit. Your comment lacks context and feels lazy

I have played two games with him recently and neither saw me able to make definitive, good reads on him.
This is evident if you read back on previous games.
I'm not going to fabricate a read on someone for the sake of 'not looking lazy.'

Why not? Are you saying that as scum, you don’t fabricate points?

What are you even asking?

Of course I would fabricate reads as scum.

My point is that as a town player, I am not going to make fake reads just to make myself look better. That is evidently anti-town play.

Ergo, since I don't have a read on Jeff, I'm not going to make one up. Because I'm town.

Wow Ace looks really bad from this exchange. Worth noting this was like 14+ hours ago and he hasn't posted since. Odo's attention was immediately taken away by Poyser making this post:

It’s been a fucking age since I’ve seen scum Odo granted but after what I thought was a rough start he seems pretty much what I’d expect from the town him so far

What was rough about my start???

which led to an exchange between them and Ace kind of just skated lol

 

[Tweet]

He did make one non game related post in here after repping in and left it at that IIRC.

 

[Chris]

@Demo God Sky's character claim was "Horse" and she had made a good bit of horse references starting when she first called you out or about then. I really don't think she'd fake it, but there's no guarantee it's even a town character in the first place but I don't know the game at all

 

[Comrade Khan]

He'd be in bed rn to be fair, right?

yes but if he was aware enough to rep back in or ask to be, he was aware enough to know what the score was. its the responsibility you take by repping in

 

[CraigPelton]

I'd rather see what smark brings d2 than lynch him tbh since he said he would show up for it. the sky thing kind of threw everything off in terms of being able to read him cause he's obviously a bit on edge from that and probably came into the game with low motivation in the first place

 

[Chris]

He did make one non game related post in here after repping in and left it at that IIRC.

He made another saying it sucks repping in for his top scum read when she was just a VT after I asked him

 

[Smart Marx]

@Demo God Sky's character claim was "Horse" and she had made a good bit of horse references starting when she first called you out or about then. I really don't think she'd fake it, but there's no guarantee it's even a town character in the first place but I don't know the game at all

It's possible she was given a fake. But what does Horse mean in this theme? Anyone know?

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Grim Cornette

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd rather see what smark brings d2 than lynch him tbh since he said he would show up for it. the sky thing kind of threw everything off in terms of being able to read him cause he's obviously a bit on edge from that and probably came into the game with low motivation in the first place

Pretty much. Sucked the wind right out of my sails.

 

[CraigPelton]

also leaning town on lethal and mitch which is nice as they are poe fodder

odo I'm leaning town on, definitely town if ace is scum

 

[Chris]

It's possible she was given a fake. But what does Horse mean in this theme? Anyone know?

A joke trait supposedly, but the GOAT Joke trait.

 

[Chris]

also leaning town on lethal and mitch which is nice as they are poe fodder

odo I'm leaning town on, definitely town if ace is scum

What do you think is townie about Lethal?

 

[Tweet]

I'd rather see what smark brings d2 than lynch him tbh since he said he would show up for it. the sky thing kind of threw everything off in terms of being able to read him cause he's obviously a bit on edge from that and probably came into the game with low motivation in the first place

Do you have an opinion on the way he's tried to make me drag him kicking and screaming towards actually playing this game and then tried to portray it as my fault that he didn't when I refused to do it anymore?