Also, I want to point out that the second link was bad. The choices you had were obvious pin-pointing on which character you would get.
Like, one of them had "Is it a butt?" which is obvious for Troy.
Just checked it out, and yeah it's terrible. I'd say I have no idea why I thought it was decent but I'm pretty sure I choose it just because I love the way the results are formatted, how you're given a percentage for each character. Those results are very useful, as I normally like to take several of these to get the general consensus of online tests. With percentages I can do averages which helps that out.
My only real gripe with this test is that I wasn't really familiar with the works of most of those actors they put down since I rarely watch movies (and yet I keep getting Abed) so I was kind of forced to go with Chevy Chase. I mean, I could've gone with Ken Jeong but Pierce was consistently funny throughout the entire show, Chang was not.
BTW, I'm watch S2E12 right now.
Just watched that one. Great episode. Can't wait to rewatch Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, I believe that's episode 14, so I'm close.
*Edit*
Oh, and can't believe it slipped my mind, Dolph's your sig is glorious.