CM Punk Sig

[Enigma22]

You managed to lie twice in one post. Soldier is not as good as WS (No Offence Soldier) A WS isn't the gfx god that people think he is here.

he said gfx mod. not god. lol. big difference

and i think he did a great job on this sig but it isnt a 10/10
i give it a 9/10 tho. great job bro

 

[Untouchable]

^^...........u deserve 2 be shot....learn to rate.^^....god i hate people who cant rate.

horrible sig really dont like it sorry, basically what butters said on my account is correct...

 

[S0LD1ER]

frankly i think your ^^^ sig is shit, looks like all you did was take and cut the bottom part of the survivor series poster and put a border on it, do you still think your the shit becuz you know how to make a border?

 

[Enigma22]

whats wrong with the way i rated anyways?

i gave my opinion and thats what ur supposed to do. u are allowed to give good ratings if u think they deserve it. its the raters opinion.

 

[Untouchable]

......1st to soldier....4 a start i made the whole thing so there...its the edge psd but not from the poster...its part of my custom cover...and i dont think its great either...but i haven't put that in the showcase. that sig isnt good ok?...you do not deserve 10/10, 9/10 or even 8/10...its really not good....

EDIT: also your sig is much worse than mine.

what ever your name is...cbf 2 scroll...whats wrong with the way you rate is how high you rate...u can not seriously think that that sig is just about perfect...tbh...no one on this forum from pieces i've seen posted here has deserved a 9/10...you have to put it in context with other gfx.

......i hope i have answered all of your questions


also like to say....MTG i agree with your comment

 

[S0LD1ER]

i agree with you when you say mines not worth a 10/10, 9/10, or 8/10 personally i know i can do better and if i was to rate the work of mine i would say 5/10

 

[Untouchable]

thats what im trying to say.....people need 2 b harder on there rates...it will help people push themselves 2 do better.

 

[Spity94]

so waty i miss...nah i know wat i missed

anyways,ill give yo a 7/10,yes a 7/10,its a decent sig for my liking

 

[Wrestling Station]

this thread is starting to go out of hand.. its not HIAT..
For everyones knowledge, im not the best, not the worst.. something in between.. so dont talk trash about me, nor other GFXers.. Yes i do agree that people here dont know how to rate in a good way, not a big deal, what the most important thing in this section is the actual feedback and advice. Thats what really matters and could benefit the Gfxer to improve.

Thats all.

 

[Untouchable]

please can we make it so that people have to state reasons because many people are coming on and just going "thats sweet 10/10" or summut like that..and its awful they're just doing it to seem nice and to up their posts.

 

[Wrestling Station]

^yes i've discussed that before with an admin, but due to my grandma's death, i had to be off for like a week, then things came back to this.. but im going to start giving warnings and/or infractions for this.

Please people, read the rules of the showroom. Next time i promise that penalties will be given.

 

[Fatal 55]

Before we start, i'm not trying to up my post's, i couldn't care less, i just want to give my opinion on the sig.

First off, i don't like that style 2 much, a few months ago everybody lost all creativity & started to copy whoever thought of that kind of sig... This is as though your starting that trend again, maybe not, but i just don't like the three boxed/split sigs... Never have.

The font isn't "Horrible" as Untouchable said IMO, but there could be a little more work done to it.

The main trouble i have is the PSD... The whole Grayscale/Faint Blue doesn't look that effective & there seems to be no blending at all, wether it be faded Blur or just normal Blending. If there is, it's very minimal!

I'm not bashing the sig or anything like others have said but i just think those three things you could work on & it could get better. As for a rating, i don't rate GFX like others do because it's hard to put an exact number on it & also it's impossible to please everybody wether the rating be high or low. So don't expect special treatment as i'll leave my feedcak as it is.

Keep up the good work, there are a few improvements to be made & good luck with your next one!

 

[Untouchable]

^yes i've discussed that before with an admin, but due to my grandma's death, i had to be off for like a week, then things came back to this.. but im going to start giving warnings and/or infractions for this.

Please people, read the rules of the showroom. Next time i promise that penalties will be given.

ok, i think it will help the GFX section alot tbh.

and fatal about the post count i wasnt talking about anyone in particular i just think some people are.