2008/2009 > Any year of his WWE career tbh. And that includes when he won the Undisputed title.
Absolutely!
I wasn't overtly fussed about his return, but bwoy and I glad he did - He has been at the centre of virtually everything I've really rated since he came back... Rey/Y2J, Y2j/HBK/Batista, his rediculously good performances on the mic against the legends on the road to WM25, 'The Return Of The Dragon', not to mention the one that got away; the awesomeness that was to be Edge & Jericho undisputed tag champs reign. Also thought they cut his return program with JBL prematurely short... They had good heat with that fued and the mic work would have been gold!
@ CenaMark: I've read those comments of Vinces numerous times over the years, but I've always felt they just used him as a scapegoat bearing in mind Jericho was just filling in due to the delay in HHH's return from his first quad injury. As MS says, they didn't truly give him the ball:
*He wasn't built up in preperation for his reign.
*The finishes to the majority of his matches (inc the wins at Vengeance01) were so flakey they felt like poor examples of the kind of booking that made JBLs world title reign in 04 so awesome.
*Save for WM18, his title defenses were all just repeats of the main programs he'd just been through during the Invasion storyline (SCSA & Rock)
*Get's to drop the belt in the most predictable WM ME since Hogan faced Sgt. Slaughter AND in a fued which was more about HHH vs Steph than HHH vs Jericho & the title.
I don't see where/when exactly he had his chance to shine.
Going back to the Undisputed Championship schtick, like a lot of these one time shots (The Invasion, first undisputed champ etc, not bringing DX back to fued with NWO, opting for Rock/Hogan over Austin/Hogan @ WM18.... Dare I say, Undertaker's WM streak too?), WWE don't do the simple thing and end up pissing away something sweet on some hastily conceived scheme.