Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[Rugrat]

I'm not sure on Tweet myself tbf

 

[Rugrat]

Tweet's main input has been sussing me, then Big Man (confirmed town) and Poyser (confirmed town). Regardless of your opinion on myself, he's wrong on at least 2/3

 

[Tweet]

I'd like Jeffs reasons in particular, him saying he doesn't care for what I have to say is already pretty dumb.

 

[Rugrat]

I'd like Jeffs reasons in particular, him saying he doesn't care for what I have to say is already pretty dumb.

In your opinion would that make him bad town or scum?

Also question to Annie Wan, was Smark active in the previous game where he was scum?

 

[RDK]

Day continues...

Vote Count

Smark (1) - RR
Tweet (3) -Poyser, Jeff, PHEN0M
Jeff (1) - Tweet

Vote count corrected

 

[Doddsy]

Not going to get involved in this for a little bit, personal stuff. If you need to rep me out then feel free, I will try get involved maybe tomorrow or the day after if not

 

[Rugrat]

Not going to get involved in this for a little bit, personal stuff. If you need to rep me out then feel free, I will try get involved maybe tomorrow or the day after if not

I hope whatever it is resolves itself

 

[Tweet]

Tweet's main input has been sussing me, then Big Man (confirmed town) and Poyser (confirmed town). Regardless of your opinion on myself, he's wrong on at least 2/3

Wrong, I never sussed Poyser, I sussed the people who gave him easy town reads for what I perceived to be less than convincing reasons. Also Poyser was clearly wrong himself about Big Man and that guy simply spunked his role and killed himself before any of us could really correct on that read. You're trying to portray those reads as way more of a black and white thing than they actually were.

Wrt yourself I thought your immediate response to getting sussed and voted were hella defensive but I also can't make sense of you pushing Smark as scum after he's given us his usual town opening. Leaning towards town/town at this stage.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

Also question to Annie Wan, was Smark active in the previous game where he was scum?

Given this question I don't think Rugrat realizes this is my town meta.

Anyone that wants to answer this for Rugrat, that would probably help.

Also, unvote. I don't think I was still voting Rugs, but unvote.

 

[Tweet]

Also I've pretty much already spelled out that Jeff giving easy early town reads to strong players is something of a red flag and not something he usually does as town. Sure, he was correct about Poyser being town but herp derp there's an obvious explanation for that.

 

[Rugrat]

Given this question I don't think Rugrat realizes this is my town meta.

Anyone that wants to answer this for Rugrat, that would probably help.

Also, unvote. I don't think I was still voting Rugs, but unvote.

A lot of people can be high activity as either alignment, afaik it was your meta, but idk if it changed as it's not impossible for that

 

[Rugrat]

Wrong, I never sussed Poyser, I sussed the people who gave him easy town reads for what I perceived to be less than convincing reasons. Also Poyser was clearly wrong himself about Big Man and that guy simply spunked his role and killed himself before any of us could really correct on that read. You're trying to portray those reads as way more of a black and white thing than they actually were.

Fair response

 

[Kross Rhodes]

A lot of people can be high activity as either alignment, afaik it was your meta, but idk if it changed as it's not impossible for that

This and your previous post have numerous contradictions.

That first part of your post would be fair if there wasn't already 2 years of my meta to look back on.

 

[Rugrat]

This and your previous post have numerous contradictions.

That first part of your post would be fair if there wasn't already 2 years of my meta to look back on.

There is no contradiction, let alone multiple

I haven't played much the last year and I don't recall any scum game you've played at all. Going by second hand info your meta is active as town and less active as scum. There's a much more relevant of your play than second hand info the previous game, from which you may have changed your meta.

 

[Tweet]

Every game I hope Smark finally starts deviating from his well established meta of being able to be read like an open book on activity alone, but until I actually find evidence that he's deviated I'll read him as I always have. In other words solid town lean so far.