Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[PHEN0M]

For science?

 

[Shawn]

Yeah I don't think this guy is a real miller

Then lynch me. But admit that you're terrible at this game when I flip town.

 

[Sky]

"nah, I'm obvtown, you're just bad" is a bad defence

Unvote
Vote Shawn

 

[Tweet]

This isn’t what you said though, you said you disagree with giving me early town reads

which struck me as odd because I’m pretty sure you’ve read me town early more than once lol

I don't necessarily disagree with people giving you early town reads, I said the ones you were getting were generous, you're not the kind of player who should be getting town reads for stringing two coherent sentences together. I also said it's something town Jeff doesn't usually do which makes me think something's up with him in particular. Sky also gave you an early town read which is sorta null by comparison, she gave Doddsy an early town read last game for early activity so that's just whatever.

 

[Shawn]

Then lynch me. But admit that you're terrible at this game when I flip town.

If I'm investigated, I'll return an "unfavorable result"

 

[Rugrat]

No it’s much more likely he’s town that thinks you might be scum (probably wrong but hey ho) and is pushing you because he’s going for a scum read rather than scum who got into hot water for voting you and then goes back to voting you when it’s more than obvious nobody else thinks you’re scum. There’s just no strategy there whatsoever unless he’s literally going for the too bad to be scum town reads, and that’s highly unlikely

You are dense. I'll put it into simple terms

I make case on Player A. It's clearly a creditable case as nobody has discredited it.

Player B is persistantly defending Player A, accusing me of OMGUS despite having no actually issue with the case, just saying it should be blindly

Why the fuck shouldn't I think he is scum?

Too bad to be town? lol fuck off.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

That explanation you gave seems based on exactly one game I can recall (Raccoon City Mafia), I don't think you can present that as a general case for "Poyser does this as scum and since he doesn't do it here he isn't scum".

I remember him going hard after more than once but ur prob the better person to find data. I stand by my early town read though esp that as I said, i see no reason for him to come to skys defence with only 1 vote on her if hes scum. If she flips town down the line, his defence doesnt really buy him that many town points worth the gamble, and if she were to flip scum hed just be attaching himself to her and look like shit. Its just not worth it.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

"nah, I'm obvtown, you're just bad" is a bad defence

Unvote
Vote Shawn

I think you're town, but I'm not liking your vote moving. Are you really gonna vote for the miller on day 1?

 

[PHEN0M]

Don’t let sky rattle you Shawn.

 

[Shawn]

"nah, I'm obvtown, you're just bad" is a bad defence

Unvote
Vote Shawn

Voting me because I thought I saw something that I didn't is a terrible reason. Your logic, literally, makes no sense.

 

[Sky]

I think you're town, but I'm not liking your vote moving. Are you really gonna vote for the miller on day 1?

Is he miller though?? His question-dodging, inconsistent story, and jumping to the non-defenses is suggesting otherwise.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

You are dense. I'll put it into simple terms

I make case on Player A. It's clearly a creditable case as nobody has discredited it.

Player B is persistantly defending Player A, accusing me of OMGUS despite having no actually issue with the case, just saying it should be blindly

Why the fuck shouldn't I think he is scum?

Too bad to be town? lol fuck off.

Putting Smark's entire saga with you aside, is there any other reason to think Smark is scum?

 

[Poyser]

If I'm investigated, I'll return an "unfavorable result"

Well

good luck if scum flip orange

 

[Poyser]

You are dense. I'll put it into simple terms

I make case on Player A. It's clearly a creditable case as nobody has discredited it.

Player B is persistantly defending Player A, accusing me of OMGUS despite having no actually issue with the case, just saying it should be blindly

Why the fuck shouldn't I think he is scum?

Too bad to be town? lol fuck off.

How’s your reading comprehension buddy

I’m saying it would be dumb to do as scum

I mean... unless you’re offended because you ARE scum?

 

[Rugrat]

Putting Smark's entire saga with you aside, is there any other reason to think Smark is scum?

He has an awful lot of certainty you are town despite the early stage of the game going to the point of blindly batting away any questions. Why shouldn’t I be suspicious of him?

Who are the only players who can know you are town