Best Horror Movie Killer Bracket

[Lady Redfield]

Note to self, pay more attention to the Smark Wars threads...

Just keep voting for Freddy Krueger, that’s all you need to do.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Just keep voting for Freddy Krueger, that’s all you need to do.

Listen to Cat, she knows the way

 

[Kiffy Lube]

The Thing should have beat Michael Myers, don't get your hopes up.

 

[Marty McFourth]

The Thing should have beat Michael Myers, don't get your hopes up.

Agree to disagree there, as I think Michael winning was the correct outcome

 

[Lady Redfield]

The Thing should have beat Michael Myers, don't get your hopes up.

boy, don’t you dare

 

[Chris]

Bracket updated! Second round will be up tomorrow

 

[Chris]

The Elite 8 is set, only ones outside of the top 8 seeds are Pinhead (justice bc I bumped him down to 9 to add "Scary Movie killer" points to Ghostface I'm thinking), and 10 seeded Dracula so no real cinderellas here but I didn't expect any lol Also JUST realized that unless there's an upset this round one of the final four matches will be....Freddy vs Jason

 

[Marty McFourth]

The Elite 8 is set, only ones outside of the top 8 seeds are Pinhead (justice bc I bumped him down to 9 to add "Scary Movie killer" points to Ghostface I'm thinking), and 10 seeded Dracula so no real cinderellas here but I didn't expect any lol Also JUST realized that unless there's an upset this round one of the final four matches will be....Freddy vs Jason

I rooted for Freddy in the movie

 

[Alexa]

If Michael wins then I have lost faith in the IWC.

 

[Chris]

If Michael wins then I have lost faith in the IWC.

He was the number one seed lol....not mine though

 

[Smart Marx]

If we actually separated Michaels from the different timelines, I could vote for him, but I hate all his versions after 1998 so I can’t do it.

 

[Chris]

If we actually separated Michaels from the different timelines, I could vote for him, but I hate all his versions after 1998 so I can’t do it.

I mean by my logic I think you can personally do that. I haven't seen A LOT of the sequels for A LOT of horror series so I can't even factor them in myself lol I'm mostly voting on peak + a little bit of overall impact and then a lot of simply how cool I think they are lol

 

[Chris]

But I think Leatherface should win regardless so I wouldn't deter you from voting in that direction

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean by my logic I think you can personally do that. I haven't seen A LOT of the sequels for A LOT of horror series so I can't even factor them in myself lol I'm mostly voting on peak + a little bit of overall impact and then a lot of simply how cool I think they are lol

I don’t even mean not liking sequels or anything.

Rob Zombie’s Michael Myers is a different character from any of the ones that follow John Carpenter’s first one and to me the Michael from the new trilogy is also a completely different character from Halloween 2 and any sequels that follow that film since OG Michael was pretty defined by the blood relationship he had with Laurie. Michael that chases after a girl he met 40 years ago because she dropped off a key is not my thing.

Btw this is just me ranting about not liking all the Halloween retcons that are useless. Not knocking the tournament at all. I just don’t like Michael anymore.

 

[Smart Marx]

But I think Leatherface should win regardless so I wouldn't deter you from voting in that direction

You have my vote when Leatherface meets Mike