I laughed hard, and then figured a Flying Headbutt like that actually looks like it hurts more than a Spear, haha. But yeah, if you're able to botch a move as simple as a Spear in every match... well, he's called Botchista for a reason.
But besides badly-executed Spears, idk, after seeing him put DB over clean in the ME of WM I haven't minded Batista ever since. Him in Evolution as Hunter's lackey was the perfect spot for him, but I can't say I'll miss him. At this point I don't mind him, so if he stays, great. If he leaves, great, I'd also be fine with him never ever coming back.