Barry Presents: an Oversimplified MAFIA Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

I mostly thought it was odd that N0M was leaping to my defence given that I've never really seen him do that for anyone

Are you sure? I think I've seen him do it before.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Are you sure? I think I've seen him do it before.

Maybe I just have a short memory

 

[Smart Marx]

Hallo

Any thoughts thus far, Mr. Bird?

 

[Comrade Khan]

The problem is I ruined the trust with a few too many good scum games. I'm pretty comfortable in the thread which used to be an easy town read.

you did fool me last game so that is true

 

[RetepAdam.]

Hello fellow townies

Noticing that a whole lot of players didn't say hello back.

Really makes you think, tbh.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I'm in agreement with those saying Phenom's entrance felt off. I don't know why as town you would automatically remove someone from Day 1 consideration for what seems to be external reasons of she not playing for a while. I think Sky is pretty town seeming, but the reasons he choosed to justify not going in that direction for the day were very weird.

Vote Phenom

 

[Comrade Khan]

regarding nom, i wouldnt necessarily call him saying dont lynch sky allignment indicative. hes been nice and not wanting to kill certain folk n1 as scum when i was scum with him so my conclusion is just that's hes generally a nice guy. NAI

 

[Marty McFourth]

Noticing that a whole lot of players didn't say hello back.

Really makes you think, tbh.

Hello Retep, Hello Poyser, Hello to all the Mafia pals

 

[Comrade Khan]

unvote
vote 4th

Jeff no likey the nom vote at allllll

 

[Chris]

regarding nom, i wouldnt necessarily call him saying dont lynch sky allignment indicative. hes been nice and not wanting to kill certain folk n1 as scum when i was scum with him so my conclusion is just that's hes generally a nice guy. NAI

I don't really mind playing with these unwritten rules to not be dickish but I'm with you that if someone is scummy it should take precedence.

Agreed its not really AI but I wasn't a fan of how quick he shut it down when I think I'm the only one that had even mentioned disliking her posts I think?

 

[Poyser]

I'm in agreement with those saying Phenom's entrance felt off. I don't know why as town you would automatically remove someone from Day 1 consideration for what seems to be external reasons of she not playing for a while. I think Sky is pretty town seeming, but the reasons he choosed to justify not going in that direction for the day were very weird.

Vote Phenom

Pretty sure it was only sky that said that lol

I think it’s weird that you think sky is town and yet want to wagon someone that’s already said they don’t want to lynch her. I understand that white knighting is a thing scum do, and I’m not really saying N0M can’t be scum, but if this was specifically a scum ploy do you not think phenom would fake an actual town read rather than just taking an arbitrary stance?

 

[Marty McFourth]

regarding nom, i wouldnt necessarily call him saying dont lynch sky allignment indicative. hes been nice and not wanting to kill certain folk n1 as scum when i was scum with him so my conclusion is just that's hes generally a nice guy. NAI

Oh, Phenom is a lovely guy. I just don't recall him ever entering the thread that way as town. It's pretty much the only thing that pinged me at the moment. I don't like it because it seems to imply that no matter what happens or what is said he was ruling it out completely.

 

[RetepAdam.]

Hello Retep, Hello Poyser, Hello to all the Mafia pals

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don't really mind playing with these unwritten rules to not be dickish but I'm with you that if someone is scummy it should take precedence.

Agreed its not really AI but I wasn't a fan of how quick he shut it down when I think I'm the only one that had even mentioned disliking her posts I think?

that part is fair, but my counter point is to what purpose would nom do this and just pseudo vanish? not to hard defend the lad but it just seems like very low hanging fruit

 

[Chris]

Tbh I can see the potential in N0M white knighting sky if she's town bc shes admittedly not good at endgame and doesn't like the stress of it by her own account. So that's someone mafia would prefer to keep around later as opposed to other townies

Not really something I wanna entertain rn but it did come to mind