I'm under the impression, and answered the poll with this in mind, that the scenario here is that I'm already previously interested in having sex with said girl before finding out that's she's picked up quite a bit of phones from prior gentleman callers. If that is indeed the case, then yes I would.
Let me be clear about something, I'm not interested in having sex. Having sex is something I can only imagine doing if it's with Ms. Right. And yes, unlike RiotRaven, I am a virgin. Mostly because, sex just doesn't hold an appeal for me, and I haven't found anyone that would make me take the plunge, double entendre intended. Now I could go on and on, explaining in way too much detail every little reason why that is, but honestly if you don't get the concept I'm not sure how much me rambling on about how I need love their personality in order to be attracted to them, how I need to find something to connect with, or something to that effect is going to help. In short, if I'm actually planning on having sex with her, if we're already at that stage, then no it's not going to matter one bit how many people test drove her in the past.