36 vs 93

[The New F'n Show]

Jerry Lynn

Jerry Lynn won the ECW title from Justin Credible on October 1st 2000 at Anarchy Rulz. He lost the title to Steve Corino in a Double Jeopardy match also involving Justin Credible and the Sandman on November 5th 2000 at November to Remember. He won the ROH title from Nigel McGuinness on April 3rd 2009 at Supercard of Honor. He lost the title to Austin Aries in a three way elimination match also involving Tyler Black on June 13th 2009 at Manhattan Mayhem.

Bam Bam Bigelow

Bam Bam Bigelow won the ECW title from Shane Douglas on October 16th 1997 in New York, NY. He lost the title back on November 30th 1997 at November to Remember.

 

[Deuce]

I loved watching Bigelow's title reign, great champion.

 

[The Wrestling Addict]

I also chose Bigelow. He just seemed more of a credible champ.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Really? Lynn was a very credible champ in two companies, Bigelow won it for storyline purposes, not liking this.

 

[TheZig]

Lynn gets my vote, Im going on purely because i saw Lynns reign in ROH, I only saw Lynn pre world title in ECW.

 

[PHX]

Thought this would have been kind of lopsided surprised. Lynn for me.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Really? Lynn was a very credible champ in two companies, Bigelow won it for storyline purposes, not liking this.

This but I do think Bam Bam could legit hold world titles in WWE or WCW in his prime unlike Lynn.

 

[Andrew]

Went Lynn, he's great.

 

[Keith]

I put Bigelow in the Van Vader catogoy as a guy who was so much more than a big guy, but at the same time was everything a monster heel should be. Like Vader he never had the headliner career he deserved. Lynn for me.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Lynn advances.