2024 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards

[Comrade Khan]

Also thin year for rookies I like Young OG and all but that was a landslide

I wonder if Harley still counts for 2025

 

[Cwalker]

Wait I found another one I disagree with…

Nia Jax winning “Most Overrated”

First off she’s improved leaps and bounds and second off, mfers still dont even rate her highly

 

[Comrade Khan]

Brother they hated Mandy Rose lol

Yea Dave n Co r workrate whores unless ur a draw. What's their take on Jey actually?

 

[Professor Booty]

The Roxy haters are actually inside the house. It's wwe fans w a certain penchant for size. Also her not being white doesn't help with "those" fans.

I’m gonna be real I wasn’t into it for awhile just cuz of her acting but I’ve come around and she’s really good. Also is hard though when the person on the show you hate most (Booker) is egregiously biased to them

 

[Comrade Khan]

Wait I found another one I disagree with…

Nia Jax winning “Most Overrated”

First off she’s improved leaps and bounds and second off, mfers still dont even rate her highly

Shoulda been punk by a landslide

 

[Chris]

Yea Dave n Co r workrate whores unless ur a draw. What's their take on Jey actually?

They like it, unsure about the subscribers. Probs split

 

[Chris]

The issues with most overrated and underrated is they're just named wrong

They mean most over pushed and under pushed, so think about it as his the company rates them, not fans

 

[Professor Booty]

I wonder if Harley still counts for 2025

Hasn’t she been having matches since 2023?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I’m gonna be real I wasn’t into it for awhile just cuz of her acting but I’ve come around and she’s really good. Also is hard though when the person on the show you hate most (Booker) is egregiously biased to them

For sure

But ya my point was just that's not the observer bias in that case. Ur more likely to see them complain about Rhea never wrestling

 

[Comrade Khan]

The issues with most overrated and underrated is they're just named wrong

They mean most over pushed and under pushed, so think about it as his the company rates them, not fans

This would solve a lot lol

 

[Cwalker]

The issues with most overrated and underrated is they're just named wrong

They mean most over pushed and under pushed, so think about it as his the company rates them, not fans

And I still don’t think Nia falls in that category

 

[Professor Booty]

Brother they hated Mandy Rose lol

Ok so I’m wrong man
I told you I don’t listen

 

[Chris]

I have no idea what the rookie equirements are I just remember some people were upset Oba Femi didn't count

 

[Chris]

And I still don’t think Nia falls in that category

Yeah but it's more understandable why she'd win lol I've always hated it bc you're right, she's not rated highly by anyone...except WWE themselves which doesn't really make sense for the name still lol

 

[Professor Booty]

And I still don’t think Nia falls in that category

We know