2023 BTB Of the Year Awards - THE RESULTS!

[Dubble J]

2023 BTB OF THE YEAR AWARDS

~*~*THE RESULTS~*~*

Welcome one and all to the 2023 BTB Awards!

I'm excited to be able to host these as your humble mod but obviously this section would be nothing without the people actually contributing to it through the many great BTBs, prediction contest contributions, voting in BTB of the Month, and of course the much beloved feedback. So thank you to everyone who did any of those things in 2023!

But let's get this show on the road!

First and foremost I want to thank those who submitted ballots for these awards, I love each of your more than you could ever know. This includes:
BattleTank, DTP, Dubb, Rant, RDT, Roy Mustang, Stojy, Tig, and White Rhyno.


And also a special thanks to BattleTank for volunteering and creating the awards graphics you will see for each category.

Let's get to the awards!

For suspense purposes, I'll be staggering the award reveals over the next couple of hours. So stay tuned!

Up Next, we'll get things going with our first award...

MATCH OF THE YEAR​

 

[Dubble J]

MATCH OF THE YEAR


Obviously the heart of a BTB is the writing and since these are wrestling BTBs, the matches are typically the ones that take center stage. And the best matches are the ones that have had a strong build, written well, booked well, and perhaps most importantly, tell a story.

I think it's safe to say each of our nominees hit those marks in spades.

Here were our nominees for 2023 BTB Match of the Year:

Adam Cole vs Kyle O'Reilly - NXT: End of the Line - Looking Glass's NXT

Booker T, Diamond Dallas Page, The Giant, Hulk Hogan & Kurt Angle vs Triple H, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Sean O'Haire & Brock Lesnar - Fall Brawl - WCW/ECW: The Alliance Lives by RDT

Four Horsewomen vs. Sisters of Doom - War Games, WWE Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL

Goldberg vs. Vader, Great American Bash - WCW by Jim Cornette by Stojy

Royal Rumble Match, Royal Rumble - WWE Unleash the Fury by KOP

World War 3 Match, World War 3 - WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb


***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

Booker T, Diamond Dallas Page, The Giant, Hulk Hogan & Kurt Angle vs Triple H, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Sean O'Haire & Brock Lesnar - Fall Brawl - WCW/ECW: The Alliance Lives by RDT
1 Winning Vote, 4 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: Runner Up

Royal Rumble Match, Royal Rumble - WWE Unleash the Fury by KOP
2 Winning Votes

Spoiler: 2023 BTB MATCH OF THE YEAR

Four Horsewomen vs. Sisters of Doom - War Games, WWE Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL
3 Winning Votes

Congratulations to Damage CTRL! This match and feud was perhaps one of the best built programs I've seen in a BTB and this was the big grand conclusion. And it obviously delivered above and beyond.

Well deserving of the win here!

 

[Dubble J]

PROMO OF THE YEAR


Up next, it's one of my favorite parts of a BTB... and that's the promos. Perhaps the best way to build characters is through the promos and segments happening between the matches.

Here are your nominees for 2023 BTB Promo of the Year!


A Moxley Family Affair - TNA by Tig

Christian and Edge's Contract Signing (8/14/18 Smackdown) - WWE ~ Way It Should've Gone by Finishline

Hulkamania's Funeral - WCW 1995: Going to Way by Dubb

The Horsewomen are dead - WWE 2019 and Beyond by DamageCTRL

W.A.S.T.E debut - WWE: New Vision by Order


***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

W.A.S.T.E debut - WWE: New Vision by Order

&

Christian and Edge's Contract Signing (8/14/18 Smackdown) - WWE ~ Way It Should've Gone by Finishline

1 Winning Vote & 1 Runner Up Vote Each

Spoiler: Runner Up

The Horsewomen are dead - WWE 2019 and Beyond by DamageCTRL
2 Winning Votes & 2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: 2023 BTB PROMO OF THE YEAR

Hulkamania's Funeral - WCW 1995: Going to Way by Dubb
5 Winning Votes

Thrilled to be able to earn your votes for this one as promos are what I enjoy writing perhaps even more than the matches themselves. This one was a big one for WCW 1995 as it kicked off my attempts to turn the Dungeon of Doom into a serious threat to WCW under it's new leadership of Randy Savage. Thanks to those who gave it the love but shoutout to Damage CTRL and that follow up promo to the Match of the Year with the runner up promo directly following the match!

​

 

[Dubble J]

NON-WRESTLING BTB OF THE YEAR


Hey, this section isn't just about wrestling. There's some really fun projects going on over at the Non-Wrestling subforum. You should definitely check these nominees and the others out sometime.

This award became synonymous with Shade over the years at WrestlingClique, which many of us used to call home. And for this reason, I also refer to this award as The Shady Acres award. And, of course, he himself is among those in consideration for the award once again.


Here are your nominees for Non-Wrestling BTB of the Year!


1979 California Angels by Autumn Wind

Brentford Saga by CakeWalker

Grey Dog Comics Universe by Chris

DC Extended Universe by Shade

NBA: The Modern Game Era by RDT


***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

Grey Dog Comics Universe by Chris
2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: Runner Up

NBA: The Modern Game Era by RDT
1 Winning Vote & 2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: 2023 Non-Wrestling BTB Of the Year

DC Extended Universe by Shade
5 Winning Votes & 1 Runner Up Vote

The king of the Non-Wrestling BTB reigns supreme once again! Congratulations to Shade who comes over after a legendary Marvel Non-Wrestling BTB and is doing the same thing with DC here at WrestlingSmarks.

 

[Chris]

Can't believe I got third I have a ton saved but not written out for that too bc I ran out of time lmao like probably 6x the amount that I've posted

 

[Dubble J]

BTB SHOW OF THE YEAR

Whether its WrestleMania, Starrcade, In Your House, or any other "supercard" - the big shows are what we are doing this for. We book our stories to conclude at the biggest of shows... so which big show stood out above them all to us this year?
Here are the nominees for 2023 BTB Show of the Year:


Armageddon 2010 - WWE: The New Vision by Order

Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL

Summerslam - WWE 2019: No Wildcards by Roy Mustang

Survivor Series Fall Brawl - WWE: The New Vision by Order

World War 3, WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb


***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

Armageddon 2010 - WWE: The New Vision by Order
1 Winning Vote, 2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: Runner Up

Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL
2 Winning Votes, 2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: 2023 BTB SHOW OF THE YEAR

World War 3, WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb
5 Winning Votes, 2 Runner Up Votes

Wow... again, very honored to pick up a win here in a field that included some really great shows. World War 3 in itself was a unique experience writing, so I am certainly glad people enjoyed the event!

 

[Dubble J]

BTB OF THE YEAR

We are getting down to it now. Which BTB has stood out the most throughout the year? Plenty of deserving names on this list.

Here are your nominees for BTB of the Year.


The Pandemic Project by DTP

World Championship Wrestling by Jim Cornette by Stojy

WCW/ECW 2001 and Beyond - The Alliance Lives by RDT

WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb

WWE 2019: No Wildcards by Roy Mustang

WWE 2019 and Beyond - DamageCTRL & Rasky


***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb
2 Winning Votes

Spoiler: Runner Up

WCW/ECW 2001 and Beyond - The Alliance Lives by RDT
2 Winning Votes, 2 Runner Up Votes

Spoiler: 2023 BTB OF THE YEAR

The Pandemic Project by DTP
4 Winning Votes

Congratulations to DTP! The Pandemic Project has proven to be one of the most consistent projects, as it's constant appearances near the top of the BTBOTM standings would attest. High quality writing, booking, along with the most beautiful format come together for an amazing BTB that has truly earned the award for BTB of the Year!

 

[Dubble J]

BTB BOOKER OF THE YEAR

Well, we've made it my friends. To the final category. There are so many talented writers in this section that it's hard to pick just one... which is probably why this was the most competitive category in terms of voting!

Let's not delay this any further.

Here are your nominees for the 2023 Booker of the Year Award:

DamageCTRL

DTP

Dubb

RDT

Roy Mustang

Shade

Stojy

***


AND THE RESULTS...

Spoiler: 3rd Place

RDT
1 Winning Vote, 1 Runner Up Vote

Spoiler: Runner Up

Dubb
2 Winning Votes, 1 Runner Up Vote

Spoiler: 2023 BOOKER OF THE YEAR

STOJY!
3 Winning Votes, 3 Runner Up Votes

Already among the legends of the BTB universe, Stojy adds to his legacy with this award as he pumped out a couple fun projects last year, most obviously the WCW by Jim Cornette one but also his short lived WWE Championship Scene one was a lot of fun. He is among the best to ever do this and certainly deserving of this award. Congrats Stojy!

 

[Dubble J]

And that concludes the 2023 BTB of the Year Awards! Thanks to everyone who voted! And if you haven't already - there's still like 15 hours left to get in your votes for BTBOTM for January!

 

[BattleTank]

Congrats to all of the winners and everyone who placed. Seeing this place thrive gave me motivation to start writing again, and the winners of the awards had a lot to do with that! Looking forward to being on the grind w you guys this year!

 

[Stojy]

Congrats to all the winners, all well deserved. Hoping you'll be up here next year, BT.

 

[The Gipper]

I got screwed over for Booker of the Year, DID ANY OF YOU EVEN SEE MY ONE INTRODUCTION POST?

In seriousness, Congrats to all winners.

 

[Finishline]

I've been a little less consistent on the website the last couple months. Trying to stay focused on my podcasts, radio show, and FFSN writing job, keeping these tabs open can be quite a distraction when my wrestling BTB creative juices flowing.

With that said, VERY honored and surprised the Edge/Christian contract signing got recognized as a nominee for the Promo of the Year. I started heel Christian before AEW started heel Christian so I'm glad people enjoyed this. It was something I felt needed to be done different than the rest of my show and needed emphasis, so very encouraged and admired to see people liked it.

Not surprised by the winners of these categories at all. Congrats to DTP, Stojy, Dubb, Shade, and Damage CTRL for winning! Excited for what this year brings us.