"Lawyer Fucked Me" A Shawshank Redemption Mafia Game Presented By Barry (Game Thread)

[Sky]

thats bad tho
ambiguity is a good thing as a host lol. people being able to solve your setup is literally the last thing you want

Not necessarily given that we apparently have hosts for whom it's not outside the realm of possibility that they included a role that depends on the doc, but not the doc itself

 

[Tremendez]

thats bad tho
ambiguity is a good thing as a host lol. people being able to solve your setup is literally the last thing you want

You shouldn’t mention specific roles in your set up, but if you mention a utility, it should be possible to use it so if you’re a faith healer, there should be at least one other protection role in the game that your role can interfere with.

 

[Poyser]

I don’t remember Rugrat being rain man lol

he does have a ridiculously good memory for details lol. if you bring up something you vaguely remember happening in a game, he will remember which game it was and what happened

 

[Tremendez]

My problem isn’t whether or not there’s a doctor my issue is I don’t believe both the hider and the faith healer are town.

 

[Poyser]

Not necessarily given that we apparently have hosts for whom it's not outside the realm of possibility that they included a role that depends on the doc, but not the doc itself

the faith healer doesnt DEPEND on the doc. its just a doc with a caveat. you're arguing silly things here

 

[Sky]

the faith healer doesnt DEPEND on the doc. its just a doc with a caveat. you're arguing silly things here

Im arguing that there is literally no reason to have a faith healer in the game if a doc does not exist

 

[Poyser]

You shouldn’t mention specific roles in your set up, but if you mention a utility, it should be possible to use it so if you’re a faith healer, there should be at least one other protection role in the game that your role can interfere with.

depends on the role. in this case i dont really think there'd be anything wrong with there not being a doc in the game, just makes lethal the doc

im assuming there probably is tho and that lethal is scum, but im basing that on his play rather than him being a faith healer

 

[Lethal]

My problem isn’t whether or not there’s a doctor my issue is I don’t believe both the hider and the faith healer are town.

Hence nyvaskingbbrett for info.

 

[Poyser]

Im arguing that there is literally no reason to have a faith healer in the game if a doc does not exist

sure there is, to stop people auto clearing the doc

 

[Poyser]

like i said, a FH with no doc is just a doc

 

[Lethal]

Im arguing that there is literally no reason to have a faith healer in the game if a doc does not exist

You’re side tracking too much with this

 

[Tremendez]

depends on the role. in this case i dont really think there'd be anything wrong with there not being a doc in the game, just makes lethal the doc

im assuming there probably is tho and that lethal is scum, but im basing that on his play rather than him being a faith healer

Then he should just be the doctor. This isn’t like a flavor issue where you call it the nurse or called the doctor you called a bodyguard. If you specifically spell out utility in the role description, it should be applicable to the game imo.

And no, I don’t think lethal or Brett should be solely lynched on their role, which is why I also don’t want to confirm town on their role, but I do think one of them is going to be scum.

 

[Lethal]

like i said, a FH with no doc is just a doc

And I’d call it doc or bodyguard. Very rarely seen faith healers if at all

 

[Sky]

You’re side tracking too much with this

Not really your place to say this, the possibility that there isn't even a doc in the game is the biggest reason why you're not auto-hammered already

 

[Barry Poppins]

Vote Count:

Lethal (1) - Jean
Looch (2) - Poyser, Sky
Poyser (1) - R-Troop

It requires 6 Votes to Reach Majority.