Prey At Night: The Strangers Mafia Game Thread

[Poyser]

Have a few good points FMPOV anyway, but yeah - Grim and Sky's claim first mostly because I i don't see a world where they are both on the same scum team and the equity makes no sense if it is actualy the case

Why doesn’t it make sense for Sky and Barry to be on the same scum team? Cant think of a single reason why they couldn’t be

 

[CakeWalker]

Just a general obbo

 

[CakeWalker]

2. Lethal - non consec x shot vig
3. Cake
4. Sky
5. Barry
8. Pendex - Survivor
9. Evans - Jailkeeper
12. Poyser - x shot watcher
13. Blaine - non consec gunsmith
14. Polar bear - double voter

-------------

Three Mafia Team [2 mafia team honestly would be super tough in a 14 man setup and I don't see it]

A Mafia member with a Double Voter + a Survivor + Lovers in the same game is madness.

On this basis - would pencil Polar down as town, based on mechanics flips.

2. Lethal - non consec x shot vig
3. Cake
4. Sky
5. Barry
8. Pendex - Survivor
9. Evans - Jailkeeper
12. Poyser - x shot watcher
13. Blaine - non consec gunsmith
14. Polar bear - double voter

Ratchet claiming survivor on Day 1 is crazy if he is mafia and considering Lethal claimed the vig skill, no real chance Ratch is actually SK here. Potentially Lethal could be SK - but based on number indies hunting really isn't the way forward. Would put both down as - NOT MAFIA.

2. Lethal - non consec x shot vig
3. Cake
4. Sky
5. Barry
8. Pendex - Survivor
9. Evans - Jailkeeper
12. Poyser - x shot watcher
13. Blaine - non consec gunsmith
14. Polar bear - double voter

OMB was Bus Driver, the Two Lover are the other roles confirmed so far.

Evans. Really thought about this slot and mechanically. I do not see a setup of this size where Mafia have a Janitor and a Jail Keeper on the same team. And based on usage which makes sense based on OMB usage claim and flip, I would actually go out a say Evans is also settling the truth in this scenario. If he is mafia, he would just stay silent - don't understand why he would reveal usage..

I am town - but it not my job to believe myself lol.

2. Lethal - non consec x shot vig
3. Cake
4. Sky
5. Barry
8. Pendex - Survivor
9. Evans - Jailkeeper
12. Poyser - x shot watcher ?
13. Blaine - non consec gunsmith ?
14. Polar bear - double voter

Poyser and Blaine both have investigative roles. So there is actually a very good chance that one of them is lying.

2. Lethal - non consec x shot vig
3. Cake
4. Sky
5. Barry
8. Pendex - Survivor
9. Evans - Jailkeeper
12. Poyser - x shot watcher ?
13. Blaine - non consec gunsmith ?
14. Polar bear - double voter

Claims from Sky and Grim are obviously important here, especially usage.

 

[Sky]

Vote Blaine

Got some splainin to do

 

[CakeWalker]

Claim?

 

[Sky]

I'd like Blaine to explain himself first, would rather not give him an opportunity to weasel out

 

[CakeWalker]

It's either him or poyser as scum already. But without claiming what you are, you could engineer a response based on their answers. If you have results, sharing them is more of town tell imo

 

[Sky]

It's either him or poyser as scum already. But without claiming what you are, you could engineer a response based on their answers. If you have results, sharing them is more of town tell imo

Don't tell me how to be a townie

 

[CakeWalker]

ATM you sound like you might be attempting a trap or your town and think this is an auto lynch gotcha. And if it's the second why stall?

 

[CakeWalker]

Don't tell me how to be a townie

Comments like this are just seeking non game baser reactions. Speculation of your behaviour is how you play Mafia.

 

[Sky]

ATM you sound like you might be attempting a trap or your town and think this is an auto lynch gotcha. And if it's the second why stall?

I don't see the complaint, this is just how I usually do this. If I go first the other person would come up with something that explains it away

 

[CakeWalker]

He has already claimed he can't use role on consecutive nights. He can't change his role now. Only Grim could offer a get out for a Blaine. You being town would be suggesting Blaine is Mafia and based on my POE Grim unless his claim creates more questions

 

[CakeWalker]

I also have a potential thing on Blaine based on threadplay

 

[Sky]

Would love @TOP GUY TIME to clarify last night

 

[CakeWalker]

Cause if your Mafia here, you could pocket me very easy lol